- Joined
- Oct 21, 2011
- Messages
- 15,504
Has nothing to do with my curiosity, which is a really weird direction to take the conversation. Especially since you don’t know me and have little to no basis to infer my feelings. I’m fortunate to be invited to watch some full practices and get to hear from people who watch every practice play, so my curiosity is fairly satisfied. That’s separate from believing it’d be helpful to the program watching his actions in live games.Again, sounds a lot like you wanted your curiosity about Williams satisfied more than anything else and really your curiosity doesn't mean a **** thing. Diaz has spoken multiple times about the position. It sure sounds like he wasn't impressed by any of them. No mention of lack of opportunities being a factor either in his displeasure.
It isn't the first time a freshman QB didn't get any snaps in a lost season. The new redshirt rule won't change that for a lot of QBs. They will continue to sit behind older players even if those older players are a disaster. Specifically if the coaches determine the younger players are worse than the QBs in front of them. Allegedly the team was split because some players got to play when they didn't "deserve" it. You know what is most divisive? Playing QBs who don't deserve it. I have heard nothing from anybody to suggest Williams earned his way on to that field. Not even from detractors of the staff. Even in a lost season, I believe your opportunities should be merit-based. If he got fat and lazy when he realized he was out of it then he got what he deserved. He got to be an observer.
Let’s make this simpler via three parts (hopefully, we can remain on topic):
I. Did you get to watch Williams in spring practices or just the Spring game? If yes, did you think he was far below the other two players?
II. do you believe it’s helpful to see players, particularly QBs, in live games against players who aren’t part of the program? Why or why not?
III. Let’s say you answer affirmatively to previous question, do you think our program and the QB situation would have been significantly affected to the downside by playing Williams?
Appreciate any response.