While I think there could have been a veteran HC found that might improve in a few areas (maybe discipline and attitude) I am basically happy with Diaz. Sure he could have been allocated funds or resources to hire a bit of a better staff, especially for recruiting prowess, and maybe some super aides de camp like Bama does, but he was dealt what he was dealt.
In these new Miami times, politically charged and otherwise, there are no more Bear Bryants or Lombardis that get the big bad players behaving like scared little rabbits fearful of a dressing down or even a stern look. Some use the word “soft” I think over-rated or smug or too self-sure is more accurate. At times, appearing more concerned with career prospects, stature, and playing time - - -prep and practice and improvement seem to take a second seat when much of the actual talent on hand really needs it. And with all the secret practices and clamp-down on leaks, hard to know the score (in these areas.)
Diaz was basically dealt Jeff Thomas (punt reception decisions and foibles) Baxa (bungles) 4th and 17 (defenders with mental mistakes at critical times) Zion, Campbell, Scaife (OL woes) JW (choose to throw to Mallory (who drops it) rather than obvious easy run-in) Knowles, and much much more…
…this can be a winning hand against less than stellar teams, or even against top teams if some of the high-potential talent have stellar performances, and mishaps are kept to a minimum. It seems highly doubtful Urban Meyer or other similar HC would have won either of the first 2 games with this roster, and going even 8-4 with it this year may be more of a feather in Diaz cap then a failure!
I think Meyer would be 2-0. Remember he wouldnt have Mannys staff.