forums

On why Rosier is starting - Miami Herald

its coaching. comes down to coaching if you cant get your boys to remember what to do when they need to do it. If anything its an indictment on the staff, not the players.
 
Advertisement
Read online that Boston College's top seven O-linemen have 140 career starts combined. I think little things like that are lost in the whole "we're more talented" statements that are made here daily.

Imo right now this offense is a mixture of playcalling that is overcompensating for it's deficiences by being way, way too conservative, a ton of inexperienced freshman making mistakes all over the place and a QB that has about 60% of his passes not end up where they're supposed to in any given game.

It's a combination of a ton of factors, not just one thing, with each part needing the other to improve. That is definitely not happening and the result is the **** show we witness weekly..
 
If Rick wants to admit he made a mistake with Weldon and Perry, so be it. That means he needs to give William's reps with the 1s.

Rosier can't throw on the run; he can't adjust his passes if a receiver gets pushed off his route; and if someone gets past the OL and Rosier doesn't have room to run forward, the play is over as he simply doesn't have the ability to escape the pocket and keep his eyes downfield while moving and make an accurate throw.

Rick's offense might be beautiful on the chalkboard and works if everything goes perfectly. It rarely does, which is why we are 1-6 against P5 teams over the last 7 games.

I'm selling Rick. The team isn't improving and is going to be breaking in a new qb next year, which means more chances of imperfection and more losses. Best thing to do is fire him now, take the hit, and go hard after Brohm or even Dino Babers. I'm done with coaches whose pride supersedes common sense.
 
For_The_U said:
Jeff Thomas was just quoted this week saying even though they run the same play "a million times" in practice some people get jitters in games and do the wrong thing. So, no, not all lack of execution is a result of coaching.
Click to expand...

Sounds like they’re mentally soft. That’s coaching too,
 
ncncanes said:
Sorry but Cager and Langam are JAG's - 2 huge plays vs FSU & Ga Tech yes but zero separation
Click to expand...

Cager didn’t look like a JAG hauling in 2 TDS v FIU and 2 TDS vs FSU

Wonder why that is ... hmmmm

/ I don’t know if he played v UNC. But if he did, RICHt only allowed 12 passes.
 
Last edited:
1mg of Epi said:
So you’re playing the q.b because other players aren’t doing their job. Hmmm.... seems that’s exactly when you’d want the more talented guy in the game.
Click to expand...

No. It makes perfect sense actually. If the more talented QB offense still struggles, that’s a clearer indictment of the **** offensive playbook and playcalling. He’s protecting his coaching staff by playing the ****** QB.
 
Meast21 said:
The valid points are that the WRs & OL routinely make dumbass mistakes which makes the QB look worse than they are. Doesn't matter if Rosier, Perry, or Tom Brady is the QB. If no one blocks or WR's run wrong routes, it ***** up the O. Tried telling you all the WRs are overrated but no one wants to hear that.

Frankly I have a different takeaway from this article than the rest of the board - seems Richt simply doesn't trust his offense at all. Not just Perry, but even the WRs, OL, TE's to execute the basic plays. Hence he feels forced to simplify / dumb down the entire offense which frankly may explain the lack of creativity it has and his decision to go with Rosier over Perry. Because as awful a passer as Rosier is, he is at least fairly intelligent and can read a D way better than Perry can

To be clear, i'm not defending Richt. Year 3 and this is complete failure to recruit, develop, and execute which 100% falls on him. I want to see Perry and Williams from here on out but Richt is only going with someone he can trust to execute the basics. That's obvious to me
Click to expand...

It's deep into year 3. These are Richt's guys. Other teams can roll out true freshman at any of the positions you've mentioned and their respective offenses keep ticking.

Richt hasn't had a consistent offense for several years now, even factoring the later part of his UGA tenure. That's the bigger indictment on him.
 
Advertisement
ThomasG954 said:
If anything, this provides more reason as to why Kosi should start. Malik needs everyone to do their job and even then his lack of accuracy or strength may not get the ball where it needs to go.

Kosi on the other hand, has played his entire life off improvisation. He can make plays when someone misses an assignment because he’s more accurate and strong.

I also believe that if he had more experience in feeling the pocket and when to tuck and run, he’d be a better runner than Malik. Malik is solely better at this from having been in the program for half a decade and playing over 20 games.
Click to expand...

I agree. And this is what's starting to make me think this is the reason that Perry's not playing right now - because he doesn't run Richt's offense the way he likes and improvises too much. This was always mentioned in the Spring, and it's probably what's irritating Richt right now.
 
Liberty City El said:
I blame the OL
I blame the WR's
I blame the RB's
I blame the Defense
I blame the fans

I blame anybody & everybody except for Richt or Rosier, it's not their fault nor is it their responsibility to make sure our Offense runs efficiently.

Richt & Rosier do everything perfect, it's everybody else who needs to execute properly. When Rosier throws an INT, it's on the OL & WR's. When we lose a game, it's on Diaz & the rest of the team not Richt.

The problem is this team just isn't good enough outside of Rosier, he's our best player & carries this team, the rest of these guys just need to shut up & do as their told.
Click to expand...

And by extension, the fans should just shut up and wait for us to get lucky with good players because even though Richt recruited almost all of these players whose fault our struggles are, it’s still not his fault, eventually, we will get all perfect players and one day all eleven men on the field will do their jobs perfectly, and it will be good.

In the mean time, spend your money on us, come to the games and cheer no matter how we play, but otherwise shut up and don’t be “in a tizzy”.
 
ItsAUThing.com said:
It's not on the coaching staff to have Langham and Cager play to their body size, or to keep Wiggins from dropping catchable balls.
Click to expand...

It’s not? Hey, do you want to be my boss? I want to get paid lots of money with no responsibility or accountability.
 
CaneSwag1995 said:
There is plenty of blame to go around, but the fact none of Malik’s deficiencies were highlighted in that article says a lot.
Click to expand...

This goes to what I’ve been saying. There’s a group of guys in the locker room that the coaches baby & coddle to the point of resentment from the other players. Malik, Homer, Cager, & DeeJay are the ones I hear most about & it’s reiterated by the coaches in interviews. THAT’S how you lose a locker room & team.
 
ItsAUThing.com said:
Please. Everyone wants to blame coaching. No one wants to blame players for half-assed effort and a lack of execution.

It's not on the coaching staff to have Langham and Cager play to their body size, or to keep Wiggins from dropping catchable balls.

When are people going to quit inventing ways to ***** about Richt in year three and admit that he doesn't yet have the talent and depth it takes to complete at a high level.

Program was 60-47 from Coker's last year to Golden's firing—for a reason.

79 scholarship kids; 31 are freshman and 17 are sophomores—48 players on the team underclassmen ... and trying to get it done with a sub-par offensive line and no answer at quarterback—as the two underclassmen are proving grossly immature and doing nothing to beat out a very below average, perennial back-up, r-senior who is starting due to the depth chart and nothing else.

If the program still looks like a hot mess in 2020, different story. It's year three. Dabo needed seven years to make Clemson a bonafide contender. His fifth year, No. 3 Clemson got waxed at home by No. 5 Florida State, 51-14.
Click to expand...

The program doesn't have the talent and depth to beat Virginia and Boston College? And to not look like absolute trash against Ed O and an LSU team that has been garbage for the last few years? GTFOH.
 
Advertisement
MikeCane18 said:
HAHAHA all of that is probably true but not once in that article does he say Malik had a poor read, threw a poor ball, or made the wrong decision. He covered for Malik. And it's his and his son's job to get Perry and the other QBs better at pre snap reads and recognizing coverages. Such a cop out.
Click to expand...
This is sad but true! Mark Richt is covering for himself and his son like there is no culpability on there part to get these problems ironed out especially when we are deep into the season!! Arrogance rears its ugly head once again!! And he is responsible for Searles not improving his guys on the OL. WR coach not getting the job done is on Richt who oversees that side of the ball!!

Richt can make all the excuses he want but if he continue to stand by these assistance coaches then he is ultimately responsible for their ineffectiveness with they'er group!

Richt is done at this point and need to move on with his life! Enough of blaming other people!!
 
Amateur hour in Coral Gables. Throwing absolutely everyone and anyone under the bus to protect the play calling and their QB. Poor coaches. Don't blame them for not being able to coach up their players in the same amount of time as every other coach in America. It's the kids fault, not theirs!
 
Don't mind stating problems that others make but to essentially say it was everyone's fault but Rosier's is odd to me
 
Back
Top