I'd take Willie Williams 10 out of 10 times.
We aren't playing hindsight here. Top athletes. Top football players. They are must get. If you miss on some...its ok...it happens. Doesn't change the end result. Saban doesn't care if Alonzo Lawrence is a bust because he has recruited 3 other top athletes, top football players in the same recruiting cycle. Urban Meyer doesn't care if Johnnie Dixon ends up just 'ok'...he's recruited Paris Campbell, Terry McLaurin, Victor, etc.
Stack chips.
You've been around long enough...Miami's mindset of "we'll just get the next one" is why we are here today. No one is priority, no one is must get, no one is given priority attention. So, we miss out on the top guys, we miss out on the second tier talents, and we ended up with having to recruit New York, New Jersey, and other places late in the process to fill out a class. The mindset has been all wrong and we are seeing that permeate fans here.