The fact of the matter is that most schools' fanbases don't have such a prevalent, big, and quality message board following recruiting that is public like this one. Most teams' recruiting boards that go as in depth in conversation and coverage as this one are private sites. There is a great thing about the greater accessibility this site provides, but there is definitely also the negative concerns mentioned in this thread.
Every recruiting board has people saying the full spectrum of things (blind praise, fair criticism, crazy ******** cursing out teenagers), the difference is that when every other school is doing that on a private forum that is less accessible to the recruits and this site has all of that accessible to recruits, in their minds the reality becomes that Miami fans are ******** and it may influence the extent to which they want to be a part of it.
Every recruiting board has people saying the full spectrum of things (blind praise, fair criticism, crazy ******** cursing out teenagers), the difference is that when every other school is doing that on a private forum that is less accessible to the recruits and this site has all of that accessible to recruits, in their minds the reality becomes that Miami fans are ******** and it may influence the extent to which they want to be a part of it.