Incredibly relevant detail (thanks, Thomas Goldkamp)...
"The July 22 police report notes that Toney told officers he bought the gun from Big Daddy Guns as protection from locals."
This is not "I was out hunting deer". This is not "I just got back from the gun range". This is "I NEED A WEAPON TO PROTECT ME FROM LOCALS". Oh yeah, what locals? You mean the locals who gave you an Enterprise Rent-a-Car discount?
This situation needs to keep mushrooming until the good citizens of Alachua County have all the answers.
.