I don't believe either QB produces a clear, evident advantage over the others. I believe all three to be flawed. However, from this group of three very talented options, my belief is that we will find ONE guy that can make it happen. Only problem is we may not know who the BEST option is by the end of this summer or even the end of this year.
To clarify:
Tate doesn't work well from under center. The strength of Enos' offense is the use of multiple formations, motions, and power runs mixed with PA passing. Tate limits the use of these features. IMO, this balances out against any advantage that we gain from his ability to move around and make off-schedule plays. Tate is a guy that could come in and give us a Johnny/Baker/Kyler type guy and season or he could come in and put the ball on the turf and throw to the opposition trying to make a play. He's a gun-slinger and ****y ****** I like that in my QBs, but this season is too important and our team is too fragile for a Boom-Bust guy, IMO.
Jarren provides the most upside, IMO, after '19 because of what he can do in all facets and the fact that a QB who throws a catchable ball that leads the receiver is worth his weight in gold. I feel from reports that he was the most advanced in that area this spring. The fact that he experienced growing pains as a RS Freshman during his first spring (if it's his second, please correct me) on campus does not surprise me, nor does it dissuade me. Kid can play. But he's young and is going to have negative moments and I've never seen him in crunch time.
N'Kosi to me is a guy that is bothered too much by the moment. I've seen the look in his eye that the situation and the moment was getting to him. I do not want that in my starting QB. The fact that he has a strong arm and moves well is nice. The fact that when he locks in and puts it all together, he can be a highly productive QB is nice. I want to trust him, but I don't. Off-the-field he made plenty of mistakes last year. I'm hopeful that he's over those and can be a model citizen throughout his career. Unfortunately for him, because of the internet mistakes are forever.. and past performance is the best indicator of future success. So again, I don't trust him.
So, to recap, I think any of the three could wind up being a great QB. But the law of percentages says that keeping all three QBs on the roster and continuing to bring in talented arms is our best chance to reach a championship level.
Hopefully this clears up any confusion for you and anyone else that took issue with the "dumbness" of my prior post.