Height - Basketball: grade A (mandatory with very few exceptions for elite point guards); Football: grade C (players of almost any height can specialize in any position, megget, sanders, flutie, and tons of other); Soccer, Baseball, Hockey: grade C (almost any size, although tall players over 6'6" will struggle with agility).
Speed - Soccer and Football: A critical for almost all positions (except goalie and defense in soccer, and QB and OL); Baseball, Hockey, Basketball C - average importance.
Weight/Mass- Football - A. Baseball, Soccer, Basketball, Hockey: C-, (heavy weight usually discouraged for various reasons distinct in some ways to each sport).
Physical Overall Strength- Football: A + (obviously every position [except kickers] regardless of weight, must have great strength for their weight). Basketball: B. Hockey: B. Soccer C-.
Hand Eye Coordination - Soccer: A+ (try heading a 40 yard pass on a dime on a specific sq. inch of your forehead to angle the ball at a 20* into the coroner of the net from 20 yard out over an outstretched 6'5 keeper. Then try to figure out how hard it is to head the ball just 2 yards over the bar on the same play (which is what happens 50% of the time). Baseball: A (try hitting an 80 mph slider and intentionally dropping it in center field or hitting the gap). Hockey: B (it's not easy passing that thing lightening fast, even once you've mastered how to skate). Football and Basketball: C (catching a ball, even while running on full sprint, is not that difficult to do even when thrown as hard as the pros- and they throw the hardest of anyone).
Total Field perception - Soccer A+ (every player on the field should be able to see, and play, essentially the entire field at any given time, and make tight passes at any time with a flick of the foot, head, etc.). Hockey: B+ (almost like soccer, but much tighter field to view). Basketball: B (close field to view, but have to make tight traffic passes). Football: C (occasionally important to some players, and to some degree to most players for at least the for 10 yards in front of them. The exception is kick returners and QBs, both of which should have heads on swivel). Baseball
- (rarely do players have to look at more than one or two locations in the same 3 second period).
Depth perception - Soccer: A+ (again, knowing the angle to place your foot, and whether use instep, outside of foot, dorsal strike, or heel/ankle on a pass, or shot in close quarters, greatly exceeds any other sports requirements to perceive depth at a given instant - except for a batter). Baseball: A (also important to all positions fielding ball, but really only the batter requires extreme concentration during very specific, anticipated, milliseconds). Hockey: B+ (again very fast moving ; stick position and control, reaction critical). Baseball: B (it's very hard to grade this one. Obviously if you are a pure shooter, you need great depth perception, but otherwise, you can have average perception, and still hit a reasonable % of shots). Football: C (I mean you have to be able to perceive where the ball is in the air, at any position, but really, unless you are flying through the air as a WR on a deep, well-covered route, you really only need average human depth perception).
Intangibles (heart, courage, sheer determination, and other BS you hear from media) - don't know what this Sh-- means, bit I imagine a pi--ed off DT is going to cause a **** of a lot more damage than a pansy striker who throws himself down in the box in the 90 minute (although the latter actually has a much better chance of drawing a chance on goal). Everything else is also a wash. Occasionally a player hits a streak, but they are by definition unpredictable. Jordan might be the one consistent exception. MJ could turn it on whenever he wanted. Every sport has players with sheer will, great crunch time presence, or "another gear", but that is more about the individual, not what sport they play.