MEGA CFP - Plausible scenario in which Miami wins next two games, gets left out of CFP altogether

CFP predictor has UM at a 99% chance of getting in with winning the last 2 and losing the ACCCG. It also has us with an 80%+ chance of hosting round 1 in that scenario. Seems unlikely we’d be left out but of course the committee does whatever it wants.
 
How is this...(which assumes no upsets in the remainder of the regular season)

Texas Tech defeats Utah in Big 12 Championship
Indiana defeats UCLA in Big 10 Championship
Wake Forest defeats Canes in ACC Championship

Your 12 bids would/could be as follows: (in no particular order)
Georgia
Alabama (getting in if lose SEC title game)
Indiana
Texas Tech
Wake Forest
Utah (would still get in)
UCLA (would still get in)
Notre Dame
Texas
Tennessee
Boise (absolutely ridiculous - why does the highest ranked G6 get an automatic when they can be and have the opportunity to be ranked along with everyone else? The fact that this is an automatic is an absolute travesty)

That leaves 1 spot for Miami or BYU.
Does the committee punish Miami for losing ACC title game?
Both teams have 2 losses.
Common opponent - Notre Dame - BYU won, Canes lost (yes, without Toney).

Possible in this scenario we are shutout?
 
How is this...(which assumes no upsets in the remainder of the regular season)

Texas Tech defeats Utah in Big 12 Championship
Indiana defeats UCLA in Big 10 Championship
Wake Forest defeats Canes in ACC Championship

Your 12 bids would/could be as follows: (in no particular order)
Georgia
Alabama (getting in if lose SEC title game)
Indiana
Texas Tech
Wake Forest
Utah (would still get in)
UCLA (would still get in)
Notre Dame
Texas
Tennessee
Boise (absolutely ridiculous - why does the highest ranked G6 get an automatic when they can be and have the opportunity to be ranked along with everyone else? The fact that this is an automatic is an absolute travesty)

That leaves 1 spot for Miami or BYU.
Does the committee punish Miami for losing ACC title game?
Both teams have 2 losses.
Common opponent - Notre Dame - BYU won, Canes lost (yes, without Toney).

Possible in this scenario we are shutout?
I believe it can happen
 
Sorry.
For those of you trying to use logic and reason to explain why there’s “no way” we miss the CFP if we lose to Wake, you’re wrong. I don’t say that looking for a fight. I don’t say that because your logic and reason is wrong. I say it because the committee has a job to do and that is to seed as many SEC teams as humanly possible and create enough bullschitt excuses and reasons for the media, ahem ESPN, for feed the justice-starving masses from outside the SEC.

The committee doesn’t give a fucc. They just don’t. It’s super obvious. If it’s not pods (wtf is a pod?), its quality losses. Strength of schedule is dictated by number of ranked wins and losses; yet the rankings are always loaded with SEC teams. Why? Because the back half of the rankings are littered with teams like Missouri, Ole Miss and LSU instead of Pitt or SMU with similar records.

What are we gonna do about it? Well until we form a collective to buy out Disney/ABC/ESPN, nothing. I mean are any of you willing to boycott watching the playoffs in their entirety? I would love to say I am, but it’s a lie. I imagine the rest of you are the same. Therefore, if the tv ratings stay the same, nothing changes. I believe it would take several years of very low ratings for any meaningful changes to occur with the selection committee. Therefore, we stuck.

You're assuming we will stay at 7, TrumpyCane sees us getting up to at least 5, and if we lose ACCC there's no way we are dropped 7 spots to 12 to be left out
 
No, my position is that 11-2 Miami with:

A road loss to ND by 7 without Mali and an inch from going to OT

A loss to 1-loss WF in the ACCCG at a neutral site, vs a team we beat at their place and did things to them that no one else has done to them….

Will not be left out of the CFP. The committee won’t ignore that resume.

You’re the one ignoring me and my reasons for why you’re wrong.

If both ND and WF run the table including WF winning the ACCCG, they both will be in the top 5. So Miami’s two losses will to teams in the top 5 including a win vs a team in the top 5. IMO, they won’t be left out of the CFP


You're being stubborn and hard-headed and your argument needs to be directed to the CFP Committee.

The same CFP Committee that is not listening to logic, and whose chairman Hunter Yurachek (the Arkansas Athletic Director) is clearly biased in favor of the SEC.


1795014745402.png
 
How is this...(which assumes no upsets in the remainder of the regular season)

Texas Tech defeats Utah in Big 12 Championship
Indiana defeats UCLA in Big 10 Championship
Wake Forest defeats Canes in ACC Championship

Your 12 bids would/could be as follows: (in no particular order)
Georgia
Alabama (getting in if lose SEC title game)
Indiana
Texas Tech
Wake Forest
Utah (would still get in)
UCLA (would still get in)
Notre Dame
Texas
Tennessee
Boise (absolutely ridiculous - why does the highest ranked G6 get an automatic when they can be and have the opportunity to be ranked along with everyone else? The fact that this is an automatic is an absolute travesty)

That leaves 1 spot for Miami or BYU.
Does the committee punish Miami for losing ACC title game?
Both teams have 2 losses.
Common opponent - Notre Dame - BYU won, Canes lost (yes, without Toney).

Possible in this scenario we are shutout?

Yea i think the loser of the ACC title game will be ranked 12. and first team out replaced by the G5. I see the writing on the wall.
 
We are currently 3 spots ahead of byu. BYU has lost to ucf which is awful. There is no way the committtee will drop us behind byu if we lose in a conf title game (no matter the score)and they aren’t even playing. We won’t get penalized that much adding in the fact that we already beat them on the road. Committtee will take 2 big 12 and 2 Acc in this scenario
 
Like how we got left out last year?

11-2 Miami with two losses to two teams that will end up in the top 5 (including a win vs one of those teams at their place) isn’t being left out of the CFP.


You just keep repeating the same bull****, as if saying it will make it happen.

I don't want it to happen, but I also don't deny that it could happen.

"Like how we got left out last year?" Hey, genius, what happens if BYU wins? Can you guarantee that we would have jumped Notre Dame?

Yeah, stop acting like "last year" will control what happens THIS YEAR.

Moronic thought process...
 
Sorry.


You're assuming we will stay at 7, TrumpyCane sees us getting up to at least 5, and if we lose ACCC there's no way we are dropped 7 spots to 12 to be left out

I dont think Miami can move up based on the remaining schedule. I think at best if we look good and dont throw up on ourselves we stay at 7. If we struggle in any of these two games or play tight, they will move us to 8. In prime position to fall to 12 with a loss in ACCCG.
 
I have a great idea - how about we find a way to keep Daniel Hernandez from putting up 200+ yards of receiving on us. Maybe 🤔 we hold him to 80 yards. I think we win if we do this. and this way we dont have to worry about the CFP. and we get a 1st rd bye
 
BYU did not drop out of the playoff by losing to Texas tech in the big 12 title game. They were 12th going in (which was on the outside looking in) the top 11 made it. There has not been an instance yet where a team playing in a conference title game was dropped out of the playoff if they were in the playoff going into that game. Miami is in if they win their last 2 games period


Nobody said Miami got in over BYU last year. But Miami only vaulted NOTRE DAME because we were not yet in the same "comparison pod" to Notre Dame until BYU lost.

As for your claim about "conference title games", I have three words.

F.

S.

U.

Or maybe just two words - THE SNUB.
 
I edited my last comment on the app and I think it’s lost. Miami, by way of tiebreaker, finished “3rd” in the ACC last year as well. Yeah I get it, there was a 17 team tie or whatever (<- hyperbole). You can dress it up however you would like and I am 100% not looking for an argument with you. All I’m pointing out is that if you think this committee won’t fucc us, you’re being naive. That is it.
I’m not being naive. Show me how the CFP left out a worthy Miami. It’s your responsibility to prove your assertion and you haven’t done that yet. So I’ll toss you a softball: show me when the CFP committee has screwed over a worthy Miami.
 
You're being stubborn and hard-headed and your argument needs to be directed to the CFP Committee.

The same CFP Committee that is not listening to logic, and whose chairman Hunter Yurachek (the Arkansas Athletic Director) is clearly biased in favor of the SEC.


View attachment 380547
Show me when the committee screwed over a worthy Miami for an SEC team in the CFP.
 
I dont think Miami can move up based on the remaining schedule. I think at best if we look good and dont throw up on ourselves we stay at 7. If we struggle in any of these two games or play tight, they will move us to 8. In prime position to fall to 12 with a loss in ACCCG.

Why?

UCLA still has Michigan/USC
Bama still has auburn
Texas still has @A&M
Utah still has @TCU and WVU
UGA has @South Carolina

Chances are slim but there's bound to be 1 or 2 upsets in those 7 games in TrumpyCane's opinion

Actually think UCLA loses this weekend to Michigan
 
You just keep repeating the same bull****, as if saying it will make it happen.

I don't want it to happen, but I also don't deny that it could happen.

"Like how we got left out last year?" Hey, genius, what happens if BYU wins? Can you guarantee that we would have jumped Notre Dame?

Yeah, stop acting like "last year" will control what happens THIS YEAR.

Moronic thought process...
You’re trying to insult me because you can’t prove your assertion. And it’s tiresome.
 
We make the ACC Championship game...we are in.

Two losses - both against what would then be Top 5 teams?

We're in and hosting a home playoff game.
 
Why?

UCLA still has Michigan/USC
Bama still has auburn
Texas still has @A&M
Utah still has @TCU and WVU
UGA has @South Carolina

Chances are slim but there's bound to be 1 or 2 upsets in those 7 games in TrumpyCane's opinion

Actually think UCLA loses this weekend to Michigan

We need to get UCLA bloodied up and beaten by USC. This would help.
 
You guys all yelled this at the top of your lungs last year (me included, to be fair), and then at the end, they did the right thing and put us in over ND, which I'd never have thought they'd do. Now all of a sudden the entire thing exists just to ***** over Miami? Battered wives syndrome is a real thing, yall gotta chill.

11-2 Miami is in with an even remotely competitive game in Charlotte.

If we win the next 2, we will be no lower than 7th.....we're going to go from 7th to 12th for losing a close game to a team who will be in the playoffs? 5 spots for losing a conference championship game? Something that's literally never even come close to happening, ever? OK.


"At the end, they did the right thing" was solely predicated on BYU losing, which then "allowed" the CFP Committee to consider the UM-ND head-to-head outcome, since BEFORE the BYU loss, UM and ND were not in the same "comparative pod".

If BYU would not have lost that conference championship game, we would not have vaulted Notre Dame. That wasn't the CFP Committee "doing the right thing". More accurately, that was the CFP Committee losing their "we can't rank Miami over Notre Dame because they aren't ranked close enough" argument, because the "logic" finally collapsed on their heads.
 
Back
Top