MEGA CFP - Plausible scenario in which Miami wins next two games, gets left out of CFP altogether

I have a great idea - how about we find a way to keep Daniel Hernandez from putting up 200+ yards of receiving on us. Maybe 🤔 we hold him to 80 yards. I think we win if we do this. and this way we dont have to worry about the CFP. and we get a 1st rd bye
Assuming you mean Wake's WR Carlos Hernandez, we held him to 69 yards our first meeting.
 
We’d see the media propaganda already if the intent were to box out an 11-2 Miami. ESPN, to the contrary, is treating Miami in the playoffs as a forgone conclusion.


The media propaganda started weeks ago, when we were told "Miami hasn't beaten any ranked teams". Even when Wake Forest was ranked.

"Oh, but you didn't beat Wake Forest WHEN THEY WERE RANKED..."
 
They put us in at the last minute last year without even playing a game.


For weeks (last year), the CFP Committee had been telling the world that they couldn't rank Miami over Notre Dame "because they aren't in the same comparative pod".

Then BYU lost the Big 12 Championship Game, and the whole CFP Committee rationalization fell apart.

Let's not pretend that the CFP Committee did Miami a solid...out of respect or love or logic.
 
For weeks (last year), the CFP Committee had been telling the world that they couldn't rank Miami over Notre Dame "because they aren't in the same comparative pod".

Then BYU lost the Big 12 Championship Game, and the whole CFP Committee rationalization fell apart.

Let's not pretend that the CFP Committee did Miami a solid...out of respect or love or logic.
i'm not saying they did us a favor.. i'm just saying if they were bias against us they could have kept us out and dealt with the backlash (zero consequence since our ACC commissioner is worthless)...

they also could have dropped Bama to #10 after looking like garbage in the SECCG and moved ND up to #9 and still kept a 1 team gap between us and ND...
 
you were wrong last year too


How was I wrong last year? Last year, when I said that we SHOULD be in over Notre Dame? Last year, when I said that we needed BYU to lose the Big 12 Championship Game? Last year, when I said that the only way the CFP would use the UM-ND head-to-head result was if we were ranked side-by-side?

So...tell me again how I was wrong?

You are just a fight-picking piece of garbage who can't handle the fact that I have crushed you in every thread in which I've chosen to criticize your awful and inaccurate porstings.
 
Last edited:
Again, if Miami finished 11-1 with an ACC title, we are probably somewhere between 1-5 and most likely 1-4.

If Miami goes 11-2 and has losses to:

ND in South Bend w/out Toney, by 7, and an inch of going to OT and

A loss vs WF in neutral site championship game and we beat them at their place and did **** to them that no one else did….

It is my contention that Miami still gets in.

Even with the two losses, those are two losses vs top 5 teams (WF will end up in top 5 if they win ACCCG vs Miami). And Miami will have a win vs a top 5 team on the road.

That will be the best resume of any 2-loss team.

Miami will get in.
you are way too optimistic about the ACC getting the 4 or 5 seed.
 
Sorry.
For those of you trying to use logic and reason to explain why there’s “no way” we miss the CFP if we lose to Wake, you’re wrong. I don’t say that looking for a fight. I don’t say that because your logic and reason is wrong. I say it because the committee has a job to do and that is to seed as many SEC teams as humanly possible and create enough bullschitt excuses and reasons for the media, ahem ESPN, for feed the justice-starving masses from outside the SEC.

The committee doesn’t give a fucc. They just don’t. It’s super obvious. If it’s not pods (wtf is a pod?), its quality losses. Strength of schedule is dictated by number of ranked wins and losses; yet the rankings are always loaded with SEC teams. Why? Because the back half of the rankings are littered with teams like Missouri, Ole Miss and LSU instead of Pitt or SMU with similar records.

What are we gonna do about it? Well until we form a collective to buy out Disney/ABC/ESPN, nothing. I mean are any of you willing to boycott watching the playoffs in their entirety? I would love to say I am, but it’s a lie. I imagine the rest of you are the same. Therefore, if the tv ratings stay the same, nothing changes. I believe it would take several years of very low ratings for any meaningful changes to occur with the selection committee. Therefore, we stuck.

You're assuming we will stay at 7, TrumpyCane sees us getting up to at least 5, and if we lose ACCC there's no way we are dropped 7 spots to 12 to be left out
This whole thread is a load of assumptive suppositions. Indiana fell several spots while not playing a game. We can do this all day, but BDDFC doesn’t want to do that and thinks TrumpyCane doesn’t really want to do that either.
 
I edited my last comment on the app and I think it’s lost. Miami, by way of tiebreaker, finished “3rd” in the ACC last year as well. Yeah I get it, there was a 17 team tie or whatever (<- hyperbole). You can dress it up however you would like and I am 100% not looking for an argument with you. All I’m pointing out is that if you think this committee won’t fucc us, you’re being naive. That is it.
I’m not being naive. Show me how the CFP left out a worthy Miami. It’s your responsibility to prove your assertion and you haven’t done that yet. So I’ll toss you a softball: show me when the CFP committee has screwed over a worthy Miami.
You’re completely being naive and you’re literally fighting with everyone on this thread. I don’t have to prove anything - you’re doing it for me. My assertion is proven by the committees past actions over the last couple years.

This isn’t binary. Miami COULD be left out. They also could be left in. They might lose; they might not. The rankings show a consistent SEC lean year after year.
 
you are way too optimistic about the ACC getting the 4 or 5 seed.
An 11-1 Miami who wins the ACC and defeats a top 10 WF TWICE and gives them their only two losses and who no other team has come close to beating and losing to a potential #1 seed ND in South Bend without Toney by 7 and an inch from OT doesn’t get a top 5 seed in this field?

I disagree.
 
You’re completely being naive and you’re literally fighting with everyone on this thread. I don’t have to prove anything - you’re doing it for me. My assertion is proven by the committees past actions over the last couple years.

This isn’t binary. Miami COULD be left out. They also could be left in. They might lose; they might not. The rankings show a consistent SEC lean year after year.
My assertion is that a deserving Miami will not be screwed over by the committee. And your response is:

1. People on CIS disagree with you and
2. The CFP Committee did not ***** over deserving Miami last year.

lol. Okay, brother.
 
You’re completely being naive and you’re literally fighting with everyone on this thread. I don’t have to prove anything - you’re doing it for me. My assertion is proven by the committees past actions over the last couple years.

This isn’t binary. Miami COULD be left out. They also could be left in. They might lose; they might not. The rankings show a consistent SEC lean year after year.
My assertion is that a deserving Miami will not be screwed over by the committee. And your response is:

1. People on CIS disagree with you and
2. The CFP Committee did not ***** over deserving Miami last year.

lol. Okay, brother.
You’re looking for a fight. Look elsewhere.

Lol. Okay brother.
 
i still think if we win out we jump ND..

conference champs get value and we'd have 2 wins over a top 12 team, one more overall win than ND and a loss to a top 10 team.....

i'm not sure if i want a bye or not but would definitely like the 5 seed (although the 7 seed doesn't look too bad either)
 
The actual play here is the committee rationalizing moving Miami to the 9 seed line where one of the 3 loss sec teams get the 8 seed and home game improving the chances of SEC teams advancing to quarters.

To me, that’s the objective with the committee, maximizing SEC teams making it in and advancing to second round
 
Unlikely though it may seem, here is how it happens.

In the current CFP Top 12 (and only 11 teams will make it, since a G6 team must be included), the Top 12 teams have no remaining regular season games against any other Top 12 teams.

Therefore, everyone in the Top 12 could conceivably win out.

The SEC has 4 of the top 9 teams. The loser of the SEC-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 10 has 2 teams in the top 8. The loser of the Big 10-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11.

We all know Notre Dame's deal.

Assuming no upsets between now and the championship games, the ACC-CG would become a must-win game for Miami.

Because, if Wake Forest beats Miami in the ACC-CG, even by a little, Miami will drop out of the top 11. Yes, we only lost to Notre Dame by a touchdown. Notre Dame still got dropped below a 2-loss Texas team who lost to two 6-4 teams.

That's our reality, folks. The same team that went to the national championship game after a 10-2 regular season last year could be on the outside looking in if we go 11-2 before the final CFP vote.
KebjlFYYXGxgsLpCEn.gif
 
As much as the committee leans SEC, there is a .01% chance they leave us out if we are 11-1 and our 2nd loss is to WF in the ACCCG.

I hope we never have to find out the answer to that question, but we can't be punished by playing in a championship game where ND goes 11-1 and sits at home because they're independent. Last year BYU is an exception, not the rule, because they were already on the fringe of the playoffs AND got blown out. We would still have a top 10 win on our resume (WF) and a close loss to another top 10 team without our best player. It just wouldn't happen.
 
Like how we got left out last year?

11-2 Miami with two losses to two teams that will end up in the top 5 (including a win vs one of those teams at their place) isn’t being left out of the CFP.
Friend...Miami was rated the defacto ACC Champ last year.
 
Back
Top