Empirical Cane
We are what we repeatedly do.
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2018
- Messages
- 48,628
Post in thread 'I’ll just leave this here' https://www.canesinsight.com/threads/i’ll-just-leave-this-here.213011/post-8626114
I’m also not trying to convince you. lol I’ve already given you the my personal opinion caveat. But I mean I 100% think Oklahoma’s defense is good enough to take a 6 win record so far to at least 8 wins in the acc right now
It’s like this sport only happens to Miami fans and no one else. Victims everywhere around here lol
I’m reading through this and I don’t even disagree with anything you said. It seems like our disconnect directly stems from my belief that the league is just better than everyone else this year. Sure Texas and bama could lose round 1 (I mostly feel that way about Texas) but they would also be favored in round 1 in just about every matchup.But that's not the point, the whole "but what if Ohio State played in the Ivy League" nonsense.
The sword has two edges. If you want to be a member of a tough conference that plays 75% of its schedule in-conference while ducking almost all of the quality OOC games (oh, except there will be ONE P4 OOC game going forward), then you have to deal with the mathematical reality.
Currently, 7 of the 16 teams in the SEC have a 6-4 record. That is mid. Anyone can construct a fantasy world where Oklahoma is running roughshod, but the reality is that they have lost FOUR GAMES, and one of them was to unranked Michigan.
Again, it's not personal. Assuming that the CFP is not crazy enough to put both Alabama and Texas in the top 4, I would bet money on both to lose first round games, regardless of homefield. Texas has certainly proven that they can lose at home to mid teams.
Wait, you think the committee will dump ND AGAIN, this time with a head to head win over Miami? LOLIf Miami and Notre Dame both win out, it will be close.
ND’s resume: best Miami at home by 7 without Toney but lost to BYU on the road also in controversial fashion.
Miami’s resume: two wins vs top 10 team. One of them on the road and the other at a neutral site. And Miami would be the only loss for that top 10 team. Loss to ND at home by 7 without Toney and inches from pushing that game to OT.
Although ND beat Miami, and argument for Miami’s resume could be made.
I’m reading through this and I don’t even disagree with anything you said. It seems like our disconnect directly stems from my belief that the league is just better than everyone else this year. Sure Texas and bama could lose round 1 (I mostly feel that way about Texas) but they would also be favored in round 1 in just about every matchup.
In your OP to start the thread, you said: "The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11".I've proven that the CFPC favors the SEC over all others multiple times.
Meanwhile, you act as if "you win" by claiming some sort of bizarre courtroom-like "burden of proof" standard.
You didn't read what I wrote and just jumped to a conclusion. I said I could see the argument.....typically, in the English language that means, "I disagree with your take, but I can see how you came up with that argument".Wait, you think the committee will dump ND AGAIN, this time with a head to head win over Miami? LOL
Not happening.
Wait, you think the committee will dump ND AGAIN, this time with a head to head win over Miami? LOL
Not happening.
In your OP to start the thread, you said: "The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11".
Can't believe how many people think a 10-2 BYU sitting at home will be in and 11-2 Miami losing the ACC title game would be out. Absolutely zero chance of that happening.
I’m with you. I hate the “wears down” framing of it cause that’s where they lose me. Every team is going to wear down it’s a long season. If you leave that out of it I’m more inclined to hear the sec out. It starts and ends with the acc needing to be properly ranked but I wonder is it because a team will be very good one year and then bad the next? For me the teams that deserve to be ranked Missouri style in our league include Louisville, Smu and Duke bare minimumI agree with you, it's the differential between macro and micro.
I can fathom how the overall conference has talent and ability and may, on the whole, be better than any other conference.
But from a rankings standpoint, I think we need to do the micro analysis. And on that basis, I simply don't sign off on TWO 2-loss teams being in the Top 5 "because SEC".
Whether the "SEC schedule wears teams down" argument is true or not, those are the choices that players and coaches and programs make. But if a team loses two home games to a pair of 6-4 teams, that team shouldn't be in the Top 5.
Let's not forget, Miami lost to a pair of 9-4 teams last year (one a road overtime game) and we BARELY made it into the CFP. If not for the BYU loss in the Big 12 championship game, Miami would have been excluded from the CFP, and I think that 2025 SMU and 2025 Louisville are better teams than 2026 Oklahoma and 2026 Florida.
BYU beat Notre Dame.
Miami did not beat Notre Dame.
I'm not saying that I agree, I'm just providing the flimsy logical basis on which the CFPC could ***** Miami.
That's a statement not an argument.Guys it’s going to happen. UM has to win the ACC. There’s a 0% chance we get in IMO with a Wake loss. Even if we crush these next 2 games.
On the planet where they beat Ohio St with their starting QB, who is still ranked 14 with their backup who isn't good and lost them multiple games. They beat the #9 ranked team who beat Alabama. Then they lost to two teams in 20s and beat 3 teams that are in 20s. They are top 10 in SOS, SOR, Game Control, FPI. The only other team that has that is Bama. But compare best wins. Bama is literally only ranked that high because they have good losses. Texas has better wins. Including vs the team that beat Bama. And with same record.On what planet should Texas be the 2nd ranked SEC team (and presumably the #3 team overall, because the CFPC loves SEC teams)?
Texas lost TWO home games to 6-4 teams. What have they done that is so deserving? What, because in their last 4 games they beat three 6-4 and one 4-6 team? Good lord, SEVEN teams in the SEC have 6-4 records. The whole conference is the definition of "mid".
I agree with you. I didn't finish out my response because I had to pause for a meeting, and then when I returned, I saw a notification from the other poster, and didn't realize my unfinished response to you was going to be attached to my response to the original poster.And?
To assist you with your atrocious reading comprehension, I will provide a visual aid.
Assuming that these three teams win out their remaining (easy) games, Texas Tech would play Utah in the Big 12 championship. Assuming that Texas Tech beats a higher-ranked team AND THE HORRIBLE POSSIBILITY THAT MIAMI LOSES TO A LOWER RANKED TEAM IN THE ACC-CG. it is not such a bizarre idea to think that Texas Tech would move ahead of Miami.
Or that Miami (which was already dropped 6 spots for losing a 1-score road game to a Top 12 team) could be dropped 5 spots for losing a neutral site game to a Top 12 team).
Don't be naive. Or obstinate.
View attachment 380567
Interesting point on Toney. Mario rather cleverly said Mali would be out 4 to 4 1/2 weeks which literally brackets the acc champ game.Playing Wake in a normal field with grass instead of cement will help us. We had too many injuries and they were able to score on us in the 2nd half. Plus this game is too important and I would bet the Toney plays.
That's a statement not an argument.
That's the right point. Like in March Madness a bubble team needs to always be concerned about a team getting an automatic bid from conference championship (a team that otherwise would not make the CFB playoffs) and sneaking past them.Can't believe how many people think a 10-2 BYU sitting at home will be in and 11-2 Miami losing the ACC title game would be out. Absolutely zero chance of that happening.
It would take Oregon or Ohio State beating undefeated UCLA in the Big 10 and TT beating undefeated Utah in the big 12 for Miami to be left out.