MEGA CFP - Plausible scenario in which Miami wins next two games, gets left out of CFP altogether

i still think if we win out we jump ND..

conference champs get value and we'd have 2 wins over a top 12 team, one more overall win than ND and a loss to a top 10 team.....

i'm not sure if i want a bye or not but would definitely like the 5 seed (although the 7 seed doesn't look too bad either)
If Miami and Notre Dame both win out, it will be close.

ND’s resume: best Miami at home by 7 without Toney but lost to BYU on the road also in controversial fashion.

Miami’s resume: two wins vs top 10 team. One of them on the road and the other at a neutral site. And Miami would be the only loss for that top 10 team. Loss to ND at home by 7 without Toney and inches from pushing that game to OT.

Although ND beat Miami, and argument for Miami’s resume could be made.
 
My apologies. I didn’t know CIS had a seat at the CFP committee table.
Gato...I think that is the very point some folks are trying to make.

We + you see the logic of an 11-2 Miami in the Top 12 slots, but we don't have a seat at the table and the committee is filled with biased hacks.

Thoughts?
 
i
If Miami and Notre Dame both win out, it will be close.

ND’s resume: best Miami at home by 7 without Toney but lost to BYU on the road also in controversial fashion.

Miami’s resume: two wins vs top 10 team. One of them on the road and the other at a neutral site. And Miami would be the only loss for that top 10 team. Loss to ND at home by 7 without Toney and inches from pushing that game to OT.

Although ND beat Miami, and argument for Miami’s resume could be made.
I agree it'll be close but they could also justify it by just saying "They're a power 4 conference champ and beat a top 10 team twice"..

especially if Mali is back and we look good beating them...
 
You guys all yelled this at the top of your lungs last year (me included, to be fair), and then at the end, they did the right thing and put us in over ND, which I'd never have thought they'd do. Now all of a sudden the entire thing exists just to ***** over Miami? Battered wives syndrome is a real thing, yall gotta chill.

11-2 Miami is in with an even remotely competitive game in Charlotte.

If we win the next 2, we will be no lower than 7th.....we're going to go from 7th to 12th for losing a close game to a team who will be in the playoffs? 5 spots for losing a conference championship game? Something that's literally never even come close to happening, ever? OK.
It’s like this sport only happens to Miami fans and no one else. Victims everywhere around here lol
 
i

I agree it'll be close but they could also justify it by just saying "They're a power 4 conference champ and beat a top 10 team twice"..

especially if Mali is back and we look good beating them...
I agree. I think style points will favor us if we can beat WF again by two scores. No one has done that to WF except for us….twice
 
I’m not against what you’re saying but why shouldn’t Texas be over ND?


Because Texas has TWO HOME LOSSES to 6-4 teams? And because Notre Dame's ONE LOSS was a road game to a team in the CFP Top 10?

Come on, man, I know you're from Texas and all, but this is some pretty egregious nonsense from Hunter Yurachek. I don't care how many 6-4 SEC teams that the CFP Committee stuffs into positions 21-25, that doesn't make them "quality losses".

Effectively, Texas was "dropped" from its one-time position as the #1 team (yes, I realize it was before the CFP Committee voted) ALL THE WAY DOWN TO NUMBER FIVE, off of TWO HOME LOSSES TO 6-4 TEAMS, while Miami got dropped from #1 all the way down to #7 off of ONE ROAD LOSS to a CFP Top 10 team.

Make it make sense, without using "everything is bigger in Texas" and/or the SEC to justify it...
 
Gato...I think that is the very point some folks are trying to make.

We + you see the logic of an 11-2 Miami in the Top 12 slots, but we don't have a seat at the table and the committee is filled with biased hacks.

Thoughts?
I just don’t see the committee leaving out Miami. They didn’t last year. 11-1 Miami with ACC title certainly isn’t being left out. And I don’t think an 11-2 Miami an ACC loss to WF will be left out either.
 
Because they have TWO HOME LOSSES to 6-4 teams? And because Notre Dame's ONE LOSS was a road game to a team in the CFP Top 10?

Come on, man, I know you're from Texas and all, but this is some pretty egregious nonsense from Hunter Yurachek. I don't care how many 6-4 SEC teams that the CFP stuffs into positions 21-25, that doesn't make them "quality losses".
I’m genuinely asking. I have no allegiance to Texas I’m a UH grad lol this is just my personal stance. For the first time in years I agree with the back end rankings of those particular sec teams. They only thing I don’t like is that Smu and Duke aren’t ranked but that doesn’t really change my stance. Smu and Duke should have been in the 15 to 20 range anyway
 
Unlikely though it may seem, here is how it happens.

In the current CFP Top 12 (and only 11 teams will make it, since a G6 team must be included), the Top 12 teams have no remaining regular season games against any other Top 12 teams.

Therefore, everyone in the Top 12 could conceivably win out.

The SEC has 4 of the top 9 teams. The loser of the SEC-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 10 has 2 teams in the top 8. The loser of the Big 10-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11.

We all know Notre Dame's deal.

Assuming no upsets between now and the championship games, the ACC-CG would become a must-win game for Miami.

Because, if Wake Forest beats Miami in the ACC-CG, even by a little, Miami will drop out of the top 11. Yes, we only lost to Notre Dame by a touchdown. Notre Dame still got dropped below a 2-loss Texas team who lost to two 6-4 teams.

That's our reality, folks. The same team that went to the national championship game after a 10-2 regular season last year could be on the outside looking in if we go 11-2 before the final CFP vote.
Your post is 100% accurate. None of us want Miami to miss the playoff but all you are saying is it is entirely possible based on the bias of the playoff committee towards the SEC and the reality of the rest of games to be played during season and conf title games.

Do you think Miami can make a top 4 bye with a win over wake for acc title without any major upsets? That will be difficult IMO.

My hope is Miami just beats Wake with or without Toney which won't be easy. One game at a time. Go Canes!
 
And? What, no other conference 3rd place team makes the CFP?
O wins vs ranked teams. In fact we didn’t play a ranked team iirc.

A team with the #1 offense, Heisman finalist, and the #1 player in the draft didn’t have a ranked win, finished with 2 losses (to unranked teams), and didn’t win or even play in their conference championship and you’re crying about being left out of a 12-team playoff? Okay.
 
You responded to me first, dude. Looks like you’re the one who was looking for something.

Don't be an a-hole. Not over this. We can fight over something else in the future. I still remember yur name change to NumbNuts, then back, so you can't be too bad of a guy.

I commented elsewhere ont this topic this morning and in more detail. I'll find the post and tag you. You'll see what I'm talking about with regard to the committee. You likely won't agree, but hey, that's Shpoople.
 
To me this is really just the rare case where I agree the sec is better than everyone else this year. That’s MY opinion I’m not trying to force it. Prior to this year I would say it’s been the big 10 and the acc was stronger.
 
Sorry.


You're assuming we will stay at 7, TrumpyCane sees us getting up to at least 5, and if we lose ACCC there's no way we are dropped 7 spots to 12 to be left out


How are we getting to #5 when the six teams ahead of us play incredibly easy schedules for the next two weeks?

Georgia plays South Carolina and Georgia Tech. Even if Georgia were to lose to South Carolina, the CFPC already has TWO 2-loss SEC teams ahead of us. Why would Georgia drop?

Utah plays 5-5 TCU and 5-5 WVU. Praying for a miracle here?

Alabama plays Chattanooga and Auburn.

UCLA plays Michigan and USC.

Texas plays 4-6 Arkansas and 4-6 aTm. Even easier than Utah's schedule.

Notre Dame plays SMU and Syracuse.

Get comfortable with Miami being #7. We could score 100 points each against VaTech and BC and still be #7 if teams 2 through 6 do not lose a single (easy) game over the next two weeks.
 
To me this is really just the rare case where I agree the sec is better than everyone else this year. That’s MY opinion I’m not trying to force it. Prior to this year I would say it’s been the big 10 and the acc was stronger.
That's fair and maybe true, however the conspiracy creeps in because even the years when the SEC wasn't better they received preferential treatment.
 
For those of you trying to use logic and reason to explain why there’s “no way” we miss the CFP if we lose to Wake, you’re wrong. I don’t say that looking for a fight. I don’t say that because your logic and reason is wrong. I say it because the committee has a job to do and that is to seed as many SEC teams as humanly possible and create enough bullschitt excuses and reasons for the media, ahem ESPN, for feed the justice-starving masses from outside the SEC.

The committee doesn’t give a fucc. They just don’t. It’s super obvious. If it’s not pods (wtf is a pod?), its quality losses. Strength of schedule is dictated by number of ranked wins and losses; yet the rankings are always loaded with SEC teams. Why? Because the back half of the rankings are littered with teams like Missouri, Ole Miss and LSU instead of Pitt or SMU with similar records.

What are we gonna do about it? Well until we form a collective to buy out Disney/ABC/ESPN, nothing. I mean are any of you willing to boycott watching the playoffs in their entirety? I would love to say I am, but it’s a lie. I imagine the rest of you are the same. Therefore, if the tv ratings stay the same, nothing changes. I believe it would take several years of very low ratings for any meaningful changes to occur with the selection committee. Therefore, we stuck.

@P-Tizzle

Read this. I had already written this by the time we were going back and forth. If you want to pick my words apart, pick these words apart. The other messages I sent had these thoughts subliminally attached to them as I assumed you saw this.
 
How was I wrong last year? Last year, I said that we SHOULD be in over Notre Dame. Last year, I said that we needed BYU to lose the Big 12 Championship Game. Last year, I said that the only way the CFP would use the UM-ND head-to-head result was if we were ranked side-by-side.

So...tell me again how I was wrong?

You are just a fight-picking piece of garbage who can't handle the fact that I have crushed you in every thread in which I've chosen to criticize your awful and inaccurate porstings.
You're confusing what you thought SHOULD happen with what actually mattered. That's your first mistake.

Miami wasn't being held back by some magical BYU scenario. BYU losing the Big 12 Championship wasn't a requirement for Miami to deserve a playoff spot. You invented a hypothetical path and now you're presenting it like you discovered some legal loophole.

Second, your argument about Miami and Notre Dame needing to be ranked side by side completely misses the point. Head-to-head is a selection criterion, not some rule that magically becomes relevant only when two teams are ranked consecutively. The committee had the ability to evaluate Miami's win over Notre Dame regardless of where either team was ranked.

Third, saying Miami SHOULD have been ahead of Notre Dame isn't a prediction. It's an opinion. You don't get credit for being right simply because you believe your own argument.

So your entire defense consists of an opinion, a hypothetical involving BYU, and your personal interpretation of how the committee operates.

And the funniest part? You wrote an entire closing argument declaring yourself undefeated in internet debates. Congratulations, counselor. Unfortunately, confidence isn't evidence, and calling yourself the winner doesn't make your argument correct.

You weren't explaining what was stopping Miami. You were inventing scenarios to explain why you thought Miami needed help. There's a difference.

Case dismissed.
 
Back
Top