MEGA CFP - Plausible scenario in which Miami wins next two games, gets left out of CFP altogether

No disrespect to any posters, but anyone who thinks this scenario would not happen is being naive. We have very little margin for error rn imo with what I've seen from the committee.
Like how we got left out last year?

11-2 Miami with two losses to two teams that will end up in the top 5 (including a win vs one of those teams at their place) isn’t being left out of the CFP.
 
An 11-2 Miami with losses at ND (by a TD without Toney and an inch of sending that game to OT) and a loss to WF in the ACCCG at a neutral site AND Miami beat them by double digits at their place), isn’t being left out of the playoffs. No way.

Look at what you’re saying. If you thought the media blasted the committee last year for potentially leaving out Miami in favor of ND (although we beat them)….watch the **** storm that comes the committee’s way if they try to leave 11-2 Miami when losses at ND and neutral site WF.
Look at what happened last year. How did we jump ND?

We had to be compared head to head with ND by the committee according to the way they were ranking teams. Who was between us? BYU.

BYU lost to Texas Tech in the Big 12 championship game and moved down behind us in the final CFP ranking. I think the same thing could happen to Miami.

The championship game may be a tougher game than ND. Wake is playing the most complete football in the ACC right now. Rhey have momentum and confidence. They know their only way into the CFP is the win the ACC championship game. That makes them very dangerous.
 
Look at what happened last year. How did we jump ND?

We had to be compared head to head with ND by the committee according to the way they were ranking teams. Who was between us? BYU.

BYU lost to Texas Tech in the Big 12 championship game and moved down behind us in the final CFP ranking. I think the same thing could happen to Miami.

The championship game may be a tougher game than ND. Wake is playing the most complete football in the ACC right now. Rhey have momentum and confidence. They know their only way into the CFP is the win the ACC championship game. That makes them very dangerous.
BYU did not drop out of the playoff by losing to Texas tech in the big 12 title game. They were 12th going in (which was on the outside looking in) the top 11 made it. There has not been an instance yet where a team playing in a conference title game was dropped out of the playoff if they were in the playoff going into that game. Miami is in if they win their last 2 games period
 
Unlikely though it may seem, here is how it happens.

In the current CFP Top 12 (and only 11 teams will make it, since a G6 team must be included), the Top 12 teams have no remaining regular season games against any other Top 12 teams.

Therefore, everyone in the Top 12 could conceivably win out.

The SEC has 4 of the top 9 teams. The loser of the SEC-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 10 has 2 teams in the top 8. The loser of the Big 10-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11.

We all know Notre Dame's deal.

Assuming no upsets between now and the championship games, the ACC-CG would become a must-win game for Miami.

Because, if Wake Forest beats Miami in the ACC-CG, even by a little, Miami will drop out of the top 11. Yes, we only lost to Notre Dame by a touchdown. Notre Dame still got dropped below a 2-loss Texas team who lost to two 6-4 teams.

That's our reality, folks. The same team that went to the national championship game after a 10-2 regular season last year could be on the outside looking in if we go 11-2 before the final CFP vote.
I'm pretty sure no matter what we gonna have to win that acccg. We never are allowed the same concessions they establish for sec & big10. We need outta this ****** conference already
 
Need LSU to beat Tennessee this weekend. Huge game that would help us.

Also, need UCLA to lose one of Michigan/USC. Then lose Big10 champ gm. In this scenario, thats an almost exact comparison to Miami in your scenario and I think we get the bumb over them.

Not really many other upset opportunities in front of us left. I can actually see Texas A&M over Texas, but i dont think that would hurt Texas based off this committees actions.
 
An 11-2 Miami with losses at ND (by a TD without Toney and an inch of sending that game to OT) and a loss to WF in the ACCCG at a neutral site AND Miami beat them by double digits at their place), isn’t being left out of the playoffs. No way.

Look at what you’re saying. If you thought the media blasted the committee last year for potentially leaving out Miami in favor of ND (although we beat them)….watch the **** storm that comes the committee’s way if they try to leave 11-2 Miami when losses at ND and neutral site WF.
This, and what if Mensah wins the Heisman? Is the CFP seriously going to leave out an 11-2 team with a Heisman QB? If not a Heisman winner, then the Heisman runner-up because it looks like a 2 horse race between Mensah and Smith.

That would be the most laughably pathetic thing the CFP could possibly do. Putting in a **** Texas team with an overrated QB who threw more picks Saturday than Mensah has all season. Sure, let them put slap-****s like that in the playoff. Give Texas their participation trophies. But fans of the sport and prominent voices in the sport are noticing the blatant SEC stroking and leaving out an 11-2 Miami over any 2 loss team who didn’t make their Conference Championship Game, you can expect warranted criticism and backlash destroying any and all integrity the CFP claims to possess.
 
BYU did not drop out of the playoff by losing to Texas tech in the big 12 title game. They were 12th going in (which was on the outside looking in) the top 11 made it. There has not been an instance yet where a team playing in a conference title game was dropped out of the playoff if they were in the playoff going into that game. Miami is in if they win their last 2 games period
You are INCORRECT!!!

BYU was 11th going into their Big 12 title game. ND was 10th, and we were 12th. BYU lost the Big 12 title game and was dropped to 12th behind Miami. They were punished for losing their championship game. It didn't matter for BYU because their only way in was to win the Big 12 because there were 2 G6 autobids.

With the 10th and 11th rankings up for grab between Miami and ND, head to head became the deciding factor. Miam got ranked 10th and ND ranked 11th. ND was left out because there were 2 G6 autobids last year.
 
We need to win out to have our best opportunity for a CFP run. From this week's rankings, we would face BYU at home and Utah in the 2nd round. After beating Utah, we would face ND in the semi-final game for an epic rematch.

Lose the ACC title game and we could get left out of the CFP or play on the road in round 1 and be in a bracket with Georgia. I don't want to face Georgia until the championship game.

If UCLA loses to USC in their last game, they could drop 6-7 spots as they have only 1 ranked win (Oregon). A loss to USC would be a much bigger loss by ranking differential than we had with ND. If we dropped 6 places, UCLA should drop 7-8 places perhaps behind WF. This would create an opportunity for the ACC to get 2 teams into the CFP regardless of who wins the ACC title game.
 
Last edited:
Like how we got left out last year?

11-2 Miami with two losses to two teams that will end up in the top 5 (including a win vs one of those teams at their place) isn’t being left out of the CFP.
You keep saying this as if that scenario is the only outcome possible other than us winning out. It is not.
 
I’ve been a Miami fan long enough to know to never put the team outcome in someone else’s hands.

And us Cane fans should never ever trust anybody outside of CG to have Miami best interest at heart. Dropping Miami from #1 to #7 is all you need to know how it’s going to play out if we lose another game.

I tell you what, we need to blow the brakes off of VT and BC. And look very good in all 3 phases doing it.

Go Canes
 
Unlikely though it may seem, here is how it happens.

In the current CFP Top 12 (and only 11 teams will make it, since a G6 team must be included), the Top 12 teams have no remaining regular season games against any other Top 12 teams.

Therefore, everyone in the Top 12 could conceivably win out.

The SEC has 4 of the top 9 teams. The loser of the SEC-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 10 has 2 teams in the top 8. The loser of the Big 10-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11.

We all know Notre Dame's deal.

Assuming no upsets between now and the championship games, the ACC-CG would become a must-win game for Miami.

Because, if Wake Forest beats Miami in the ACC-CG, even by a little, Miami will drop out of the top 11. Yes, we only lost to Notre Dame by a touchdown. Notre Dame still got dropped below a 2-loss Texas team who lost to two 6-4 teams.

That's our reality, folks. The same team that went to the national championship game after a 10-2 regular season last year could be on the outside looking in if we go 11-2 before the final CFP vote.
I don’t see that happening. Unless Texas Tech wins the Big 12
 
The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11.
Uh this is where I disagree with you. Assuming all 3 make it if Utah doesn't win is a leap. But we will see in 2 weeks entering championship week - If bet the committee gets ahead of that issue.. I'd bet BYU drops to 12/13 with Wake and TTU jumping them if they both finish with 1 loss AND are the conf champ game participants. **** Oregon may jump them too... I think unless TTU drops a game BYU is out of the CFP. I def don't think Miami is dropping below BYU if we finish regular season top 7, with 1 loss...
 
We’ll know for sure in the penultimate rankings exactly what the committee wants (see last year when Bama moved up for a gutsy win over Auburn which essentially guaranteed them a spot).

1 upset, maybe 2 will happen in front of us which could shake things up. My hope is Auburn beats bama and A&M beats Texas.
 
Unlikely though it may seem, here is how it happens.

In the current CFP Top 12 (and only 11 teams will make it, since a G6 team must be included), the Top 12 teams have no remaining regular season games against any other Top 12 teams.

Therefore, everyone in the Top 12 could conceivably win out.

The SEC has 4 of the top 9 teams. The loser of the SEC-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 10 has 2 teams in the top 8. The loser of the Big 10-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11.

We all know Notre Dame's deal.

Assuming no upsets between now and the championship games, the ACC-CG would become a must-win game for Miami.

Because, if Wake Forest beats Miami in the ACC-CG, even by a little, Miami will drop out of the top 11. Yes, we only lost to Notre Dame by a touchdown. Notre Dame still got dropped below a 2-loss Texas team who lost to two 6-4 teams.

That's our reality, folks. The same team that went to the national championship game after a 10-2 regular season last year could be on the outside looking in if we go 11-2 before the final CFP vote.

I still think there is no way they are left out but it’s been clear for years the SEC has this rigged.

This year it’s worse than ever though and so blatant. I’m starting to think might actually have to run the table. Bama and Texas both still being ranked above Miami is crazy. I thought Miami would sneak in top 5 territory which then makes me feel better they wouldn’t drop more than 7 spots.

If Miami stays at 7 there may be a world they drop them completely out with another loss. Miami needs to win big the next two weeks
 
There’s a 0.00000% chance we get left out if we finish the regular season 11-1 no matter what happens against wake.

Reason #1 is we already have a win over them
#2 is no team has dropped more than 2 spots for losing a conf championship game
But we aren't SEC. This is the SEC invitational we are talking about here. A 3 loss SEC team has more quality losses than the quality wins and 11-2 Miami has.

If you are still confused look at what happened to Indiana compared to Alabama when both teams saw all of their wins lose on the same weekend.
 
Back
Top