MEGA CFP - Plausible scenario in which Miami wins next two games, gets left out of CFP altogether

Unlikely though it may seem, here is how it happens.

In the current CFP Top 12 (and only 11 teams will make it, since a G6 team must be included), the Top 12 teams have no remaining regular season games against any other Top 12 teams.

Therefore, everyone in the Top 12 could conceivably win out.

The SEC has 4 of the top 9 teams. The loser of the SEC-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 10 has 2 teams in the top 8. The loser of the Big 10-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11.

We all know Notre Dame's deal.

Assuming no upsets between now and the championship games, the ACC-CG would become a must-win game for Miami.

Because, if Wake Forest beats Miami in the ACC-CG, even by a little, Miami will drop out of the top 11. Yes, we only lost to Notre Dame by a touchdown. Notre Dame still got dropped below a 2-loss Texas team who lost to two 6-4 teams.

That's our reality, folks. The same team that went to the national championship game after a 10-2 regular season last year could be on the outside looking in if we go 11-2 before the final CFP vote.
It could happen for sure.
 
Like how we got left out last year?

11-2 Miami with two losses to two teams that will end up in the top 5 (including a win vs one of those teams at their place) isn’t being left out of the CFP.
First, what other ACC team would they have put in? #19 UVA at 10-3 after losing to Duke in the ACCCG or unranked Duke at 8-5?

We were there because they needed an ACC team and they picked the one most likely to make ratings getting throttled by an SEC team.

We will not get that same courtesy when they can use Wake as a Cinderella story for being overlooked as a good team most of the season.
 
Shouldn't be able to be punished multiple spots by losing a P4 conference championship game.. Especially to a team you already beat at their home.

Our resume would include beating the ACC Champs as well as 2 losses to top 10 teams.
 
Unlikely though it may seem, here is how it happens.

In the current CFP Top 12 (and only 11 teams will make it, since a G6 team must be included), the Top 12 teams have no remaining regular season games against any other Top 12 teams.

Therefore, everyone in the Top 12 could conceivably win out.

The SEC has 4 of the top 9 teams. The loser of the SEC-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 10 has 2 teams in the top 8. The loser of the Big 10-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 12. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will most likely have 3 teams in the top 11.

We all know Notre Dame's deal.

Assuming no upsets between now and the championship games, the ACC-CG would become a must-win game for Miami.

Because, if Wake Forest beats Miami in the ACC-CG, even by a little, Miami will drop out of the top 11. Yes, we only lost to Notre Dame by a touchdown. Notre Dame still got dropped below a 2-loss Texas team who lost to two 6-4 teams.

That's our reality, folks. The same team that went to the national championship game after a 10-2 regular season last year could be on the outside looking in if we go 11-2 before the final CFP vote.
While I don’t disagree with any of this it’s time everyone with a voice, message board people media personalities administration coaches alumni everyone- needs to say this beauty pageant is broken and no one should pay any attention to it.

The simplest way to show how ridiculous it all is to ask someone from the committee to explain how Alabama is ranked above Notre Dame. There is no way to even pretend this makes any sense. Somehow they need to pretend a win vs a 3 loss Kentucky is better than a win over the number 1 team in the country. Thats a lot of mental gymnastics.

Then you look at the pile of 4 loss teams from the SEC crammed in the backend of the ranking to boost ranked wins and it’s all a con job. Then look at 26-35 where every other sec team is ranked so that they all benefit from high SOR SOS etc.

It’s a system owned and rigged by Disney to protect their investment. 3 yrs in a row without a team in title game broke them.
 
1795008587920.png
 
You guys all yelled this at the top of your lungs last year (me included, to be fair), and then at the end, they did the right thing and put us in over ND, which I'd never have thought they'd do. Now all of a sudden the entire thing exists just to ***** over Miami? Battered wives syndrome is a real thing, yall gotta chill.

11-2 Miami is in with an even remotely competitive game in Charlotte.

If we win the next 2, we will be no lower than 7th.....we're going to go from 7th to 12th for losing a close game to a team who will be in the playoffs? 5 spots for losing a conference championship game? Something that's literally never even come close to happening, ever? OK.
 
Like how we got left out last year?

11-2 Miami with two losses to two teams that will end up in the top 5 (including a win vs one of those teams at their place) isn’t being left out of the CFP.
Last year, DeSantis and Rubio offered vocal support for Miami to get in, and even threatened to get Trump involved, the committee was under pressure to 'do the right thing'. No matter what you think of those politicians they helped Miami's effort to get in.

And that political support won't be coming this year, the setup this year is totally different and op's scenario is possible.
 
You guys all yelled this at the top of your lungs last year (me included, to be fair), and then at the end, they did the right thing and put us in over ND, which I'd never have thought they'd do. Now all of a sudden the entire thing exists just to ***** over Miami? Battered wives syndrome is a real thing, yall gotta chill.

11-2 Miami is in with an even remotely competitive game in Charlotte.

If we win the next 2, we will be no lower than 7th.....we're going to go from 7th to 12th for losing a close game to a team who will be in the playoffs? 5 spots for losing a conference championship game? Something that's literally never even come close to happening, ever? OK.
The CFP dropped IU 5 spots and they didn’t play that week. The CFP has proven they don’t know their *** from a hole in the ground and an undeniable SEC bias. That being said, anything is possible.

At this point, I’m just gonna let it play out and ***** and moan if/when they ***** us.
 
The CFP dropped IU 5 spots and they didn’t play that week. The CFP has proven they don’t know their *** from a hole in the ground and an undeniable SEC bias. That being said, anything is possible.

At this point, I’m just gonna let it play out and ***** and moan if/when they ***** us.

There are a ton of data points happening weekly at this point that cause sizeable moves.

Much, much less in a conference championship weekend.
 
With the field moving to 24 teams, when do we stop talking about "ranked wins" because obviously rankings are a joke from 15-25 anyway (there are also jokes being played in the top 3, nonetheless)

Time to pivot to the basketball logic and start talking about quad 1 wins and develop a formula for NET-type ratings and just generalize everything. Anyone from 15-35 is likely the same respectability of a program and a comparable win. Just call it "xyz is 4-1 vs quad 1 and has 2 wins against net top 10 teams"
 
We’d see the media propaganda already if the intent were to box out an 11-2 Miami. ESPN, to the contrary, is treating Miami in the playoffs as a forgone conclusion.
 
Here is how it happens.

In the current CFP Top 12 (and only 11 teams will make it, since a G6 team must be included), the Top 12 teams have no remaining regular season games against any other Top 12 teams.

Therefore, everyone in the Top 12 could conceivably win out.

The SEC has 4 of the top 9 teams. The loser of the SEC-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 10 has 2 teams in the top 8. The loser of the Big 10-CG will not drop outside of the top 11.

The Big 12 has 3 teams in the top 11. As long as Utah does not win the Big 12-CG, they will still have 3 teams in the top 11.

We all know Notre Dame's deal.

Assuming no upsets between now and the championship games, the ACC-CG would become a must-win game for Miami.

Because, if Wake Forest beats Miami in the ACC-CG, even by a little, Miami will drop out of the top 11. Yes, we only lost to Notre Dame by a touchdown. Notre Dame still got dropped below a 2-loss Texas team who lost to two 6-4 teams.

That's our reality, folks. The same team that went to the national championship game after a 10-2 regular season last year could be on the outside looking in if we go 11-2 before the final CFP vote.
An 11-2 Miami with losses at ND (by a TD without Toney and an inch of sending that game to OT) and a loss to WF in the ACCCG at a neutral site AND Miami beat them by double digits at their place), isn’t being left out of the playoffs. No way.

Look at what you’re saying. If you thought the media blasted the committee last year for potentially leaving out Miami in favor of ND (although we beat them)….watch the **** storm that comes the committee’s way if they try to leave 11-2 Miami when losses at ND and neutral site WF.
You must not have been paying attention this year. All the talk has been Miami schedule is terrible. They definitely won’t blast the committee this year if that were to happen
 
Back
Top