The stars might matter

[PUNCICANE]

Say stars don't matter? 49ers secondary consists of the No. 1 JUCO safety, No. 3 CB recruit 2000, & # 3 & 4 CB recruits from 2003

 

[JHallCanes]

And a 2 star QB with one scholarship offer

 

[[]_[]]

This is a groundbreaking thread. Sticky.

 

[jerzeycane]

Say stars don't matter? 49ers secondary consists of the No. 1 JUCO safety, No. 3 CB recruit 2000, & # 3 & 4 CB recruits from 2003

And their QB, top WR, and top TE?

 

[jump1cane]

And a 2 star QB with one scholarship offer

There it is.

 

[CaneShades]

KAPERNICK AND FLACCO, ED REED

 

[AboutTheU05]

Yeah and the best player in the secondary from both teams in the super bowl had two offers, Miami and Tulane.

 

[Southcane]

Say stars don't matter? 49ers secondary consists of the No. 1 JUCO safety, No. 3 CB recruit 2000, & # 3 & 4 CB recruits from 2003

You should be in politics.
You know how to pick the points that support your message and spin it real hard.
The other points that make your argument weak, naaah....we don't even acknowledge their existence.

 

[PUNCICANE]

So you guys would prefer we sign more 2 & 3 star players then 4 & 5?

 

[PUNCICANE]

Alex Collins and 6 aren't the most universally wanted recruits by ALL of you? The only 5stars

 

[dodaniels]

Patrick Willis was a 3 star recruit.

 

[Biscuits]

How did all these dues play in college?

All I give a **** about.

 

[JHallCanes]

So you guys would prefer we sign more 2 & 3 star players then 4 & 5?

Yeah that's it.

 

[jump1cane]

So you guys would prefer we sign more 2 & 3 star players then 4 & 5?

As long as we win, who cares.

 

[drifters1234]

Say stars don't matter? 49ers secondary consists of the No. 1 JUCO safety, No. 3 CB recruit 2000, & # 3 & 4 CB recruits from 2003

of course stars are relevant in terms of the probability of success at the college level. and everybody on here is thrilled when we are in it for a 5-star. People just say 5 stars don't matter when we lose out on a recruit.

But lack of stars and success are not mutually exclusive. There are plenty of 2 stars (or no stars for that matter) that develop into studs in college.

 

[Larry]

Of course stars don't matter...its professional football.

 

[PUNCICANE]

So you guys would prefer we sign more 2 & 3 star players then 4 & 5?

As long as we win, who cares.

Saban wins and he does it with Amari Cooper, Trent, Julio Jones

 

[Bennubird]

Thread could have ended here. Been down this road numerous times.

And a 2 star QB with one scholarship offer

 

[jump1cane]

So you guys would prefer we sign more 2 & 3 star players then 4 & 5?

As long as we win, who cares.

Saban wins and he does it with Amari Cooper, Trent, Julio Jones

So does Shannon with Forston, Brown, Armstrong. How about Coker, etc...

 

[jruiz]

It's a combination of talent AND coaching, you need BOTH to be successful