Patrick Surtain Jr. or Tyson Campbell ... who is better?

[BTerrinoni]

Both of these guys are number 1 and 2 cornerbacks in the country, they are ELITE ... who actually is better? What skill set does one bring over the other? Thought this would be a good discussion to pass time till Signing Day.

 

[AllbouttheU]

Yes.

 

[CaneMatt02]

Which ever chooses to come to Miami, clearly.

 

[Cane901]

Neither are coming to Miami so I don’t care.

 

[Morey161]

DJ Ivey

 

[bobbydigius]

Campbell is out right faster and looks longer. His uncle still said he was growing though. So think a faster Antonio Cromartie. Surtain is bigger, still extremely fast. Think TC has a higher ceiling but Surtains floor is higher now and either way his ceiling is elite. Think a better version of VHIII.

 

[Harpdog]

No 1 knows for sure. They are both going to be playing on Sundays and I am praying that we get one of them.

 

[canecat]

Surtain. And that happens to be the one I think we get. But both are amazing.

 

[sedlst11]

Whichever one chooses miami

 

[Koke]

Nigel Bethel

 

[Tweed]

Campbell is out right faster and looks longer. His uncle still said he was growing though. So think a faster Antonio Cromartie. Surtain is bigger, still extremely fast. Think TC has a higher ceiling but Surtains floor is higher now and either way his ceiling is elite. Think a better version of VHIII.

LOL, Hargreaves is 5'10

 

[ball915]

Raheem Buxton

 

[ghost2]

Raheem Buxton

wow. Well played.



As to the OP they're both amazing players and it's hard to separate them talent-wise. They're #1 and #2 rankings-wise, both big, fast guys that can run and are elite CBs. Pick one and I'll be thrilled.

 

[brock]

Both are very good, surtain is bigger and built like an nfl db already, Campbell is faster and is more physical. Both are elite, I prefer Campbell but surtain is an elite as well. They are far and above the top 2 cb prospects this class

 

[CanesFan93]

Campbell is out right faster and looks longer. His uncle still said he was growing though. So think a faster Antonio Cromartie. Surtain is bigger, still extremely fast. Think TC has a higher ceiling but Surtains floor is higher now and either way his ceiling is elite. Think a better version of VHIII.

LOL, Hargreaves is 5'10

Was just about to say LOL

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

 

[dukemv]

There was a clip on PS2's highlight tape, I believe, in which TC outpaces him on PS2's own punt/kick return. I think there's also a clip of Bethel getting tracked down by TC. That type of speed has to be game-changing. And, his highlights showed that he likes to pop people. Both have incredible potential, but TC might be THAT guy wherever he ends up.

 

[Insanecane]

Tyson is a bit faster, but PS2 is more polished at this time.

 

[Gatorhater]

Which ever chooses to come to Miami, clearly.

And a Pox on whoever doesn't and his family.

 

[skeeter]

Campbell is out right faster and looks longer. His uncle still said he was growing though. So think a faster Antonio Cromartie. Surtain is bigger, still extremely fast. Think TC has a higher ceiling but Surtains floor is higher now and either way his ceiling is elite. Think a better version of VHIII.

LOL, Hargreaves is 5'10

Was just about to say LOL

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

1 and 1A

On tape comparisons:

Surtain- Jimmy Smith or Richard Sherman
Cambpell- X Rhodes, or a little faster Minkah Fitzpatrick...Reprotedly still growing though so can he stay outside?

You guys that have seen them live...Good or bad comparisons?

 

[Gatorhater]

Neither are coming to Miami so I don’t care.

Then a Pox on both of them, their families, the team they sign with and it students and fans.