Wait, I didn't post what you highlighted on my previous postFTFY.
Manny isn't going to recruit a better team than he has now if he can't win with this team. 8-4 would be a disaster.
Wait, I didn't post what you highlighted on my previous postFTFY.
Manny isn't going to recruit a better team than he has now if he can't win with this team. 8-4 would be a disaster.
Don't remember which one but he was definitely rated 5* and #1 DT QB at some point. Found a couple articles from back then.SORRY Duke but NOT in any of the rankings I've seen. Not in 247, ESPN or SI
Just saying it doesn't make it so.
2017 Top Quarterback Recruits
The 247Sports rankings are determined by our recruiting analysts after countless hours of personal observations, film evaluation and input from our network of scouts.247sports.comESPN Football Recruiting - 300 Player Rankings
Where do the nation football recruits rank? Check out the player rankings on RecruitingNation.comwww.espn.comRanking top 100 college football recruits of 2017
Get to know the college football stars of the future with the top 100 recruits in the class of 2017, according to Scout.com's rankings, and where those recruits are looking.www.si.com
But Duke I'll gladly stand corrected if you can show me a reputable source that gave him 5 stars
We haven't had a 5 star QB here since Kyle Wright.
Having a 5 star would have been big news here and to date I've NEVER heard that
If Miami wins against UF in week 1, there's no excuse to lose to anyone else on the schedule outside of unlucky bounces (which could still happen). I just don't want to put too much emphasis on the first game of not only the season but of the Manny Diaz era. They could just as easily lose that game and look bad but put it together and win out.We have enough talent to cruise through the Coastal period and we "so called" have the coaching in place so no excuses. I expect maybe one loss to UF if not unbeaten IMO. The UF game is a barometer for the season cause if we win which we should and could then no ones beating us in the ACC period unless there some corching going on.
factsIf Miami wins against UF in week 1, there's no excuse to lose to anyone else on the schedule outside of unlucky bounces (which could still happen). I just don't want to put too much emphasis on the first game of not only the season but of the Manny Diaz era. They could just as easily lose that game and look bad but put it together and win out.
I mean, if Wisconsin, who isn't usually loaded with NFL players can consistently win their crappy half of the Big10, there's no excuse for Miami not to win their crappy half of the ACC.
Sorry, but if we beat both UF and FSU, anything less than a one loss regular season is a fail.I'll take 8-4 in Manny's first season so long as we beat UF and FSU.
If we beat UF, we'll likely run the table to the ACCCG.Sorry, but if we beat both UF and FSU, anything less than a one loss regular season is a fail.
We will always out recruit the other teams in the Coastal. Whether we lose to them or not. Al. Ways. Jimbo lost 4 games how many years losing too putrid Atlantic teams, and was still pulling in the big boys, mainly bc he beat our *** every season which is what he was selling (among other things).
I think we'll win 9-10 myself, but if you're telling me we're going to be 8-4, then I want 2 of those 8 wins to be against our biggest rivals.
Don't remember which one but he was definitely rated 5* and #1 DT QB at some point. Found a couple articles from back then.
View attachment 89934
View attachment 89935
Agree 100% LCE. As usual, you bring your sensibility to the board. 8-4 would be disappointing, but I too wouldn't be calling for Manny's head; especially if the losses were highly competitive.Justin Fuente went 10-4 his first season at Va Tech (not his first HC job though)
Lincoln Riley went 12-2 his first season as a HC at Oklahoma
Tom Herman went 13-1 his first season at Houston (but it's much easier to do that in the G5)
Josh Heupel went 12-1his season at UCF (again, easier to do at a G5)
John Harbaugh went 10-3 his first season at Michigan (was his 3rd college HC job)
Paul Chryst went 10-3 his first season at Wisconsin (was his 2nd HC job)
Jimmy McShark****er went 10-4 his first season at UF (was his 2nd HC job)
Kevin Sumlin went 11-2 in his first season at TAMU (was his 2nd HC job)
Jeff Tedford went 10-4 in his first season at Fresno St (was his 2nd HC job & G5)
David Shaw went 11-2 in his first season as a HC at Stanford
Chris Petersen went 13-0 in his first season as a HC at Boise St (different era, but still beat Okla in the Fiesta Bowl)
Gus Malzahn went 12-2 in his first season at Auburn (was his 2nd HC job)
Dan Mullen went 10-3 in his first season at UF (was his 2nd HC job)
Jumbo Fisher went 10-4 his first season at FSU
Steve Addazio went 9-4 his first season at Temple (G5)
Winning 10 games in your first season ever as a P5 Head Coach is rare, not impossible, but rare. In almost every situation the first time HC was coming into a program that was already built & managed to make some slight tweaks to keep things steady from the previous HC that had success.
So, what we have to hope for is that our situation is more like David Shaw or Lincoln Riley when they took over the program, but the difference is those teams were being run by very good HC's who could easily pass the baton, that's not exactly the case with what we had with Richt. Ryan Day at Oh St actually fits this profile perfectly having Urby Liar hand over the program to him & will most likely seamlessly transition into a Lincoln Riley type first season.
I think 9-3/10-2 is plausible & if we win our Bowl game we could end up at 10-3 or 11-2 at the end of the season. 8-4 would be a big disappointment due to our schedule, but people talking about banners or Diaz being on the hot seat after year 1 are basically just confirming that Earnest T Bass was 100% right about this fanbase, which is downright sad.
I also find it hilarious how all yall jumped on Tony Perps for saying Diaz has a 1 year window to prove himself, but then in this thread yall are all only giving him 1 year to prove himself lol.
I think we'll go 10-2/11-2 this year, I would not be happy with a 8-4 season, but I'm not grabbing the pitchforks in year 1 unless we go 7-5/7-6 again. Some of the best coaches in college football didn't go undefeated or 12-1 in their first year ever as a HC, year 2 is the real barometer. Almost every great P5 college coach regardless of what their record was in year 1 had a great year 2.
What 6 teams had better talent than us last year? Outside of Clemson, was Pitt or Wisconsin better in 2017? We have had more talent on our roster than 90% of the teams we play every year, yet here we are averaging 8 wins per year over the last decade.
Justin Fuente went 10-4 his first season at Va Tech (not his first HC job though)
Lincoln Riley went 12-2 his first season as a HC at Oklahoma
Tom Herman went 13-1 his first season at Houston (but it's much easier to do that in the G5)
Josh Heupel went 12-1his season at UCF (again, easier to do at a G5)
John Harbaugh went 10-3 his first season at Michigan (was his 3rd college HC job)
Paul Chryst went 10-3 his first season at Wisconsin (was his 2nd HC job)
Jimmy McShark****er went 10-4 his first season at UF (was his 2nd HC job)
Kevin Sumlin went 11-2 in his first season at TAMU (was his 2nd HC job)
Jeff Tedford went 10-4 in his first season at Fresno St (was his 2nd HC job & G5)
David Shaw went 11-2 in his first season as a HC at Stanford
Chris Petersen went 13-0 in his first season as a HC at Boise St (different era, but still beat Okla in the Fiesta Bowl)
Gus Malzahn went 12-2 in his first season at Auburn (was his 2nd HC job)
Dan Mullen went 10-3 in his first season at UF (was his 2nd HC job)
Jumbo Fisher went 10-4 his first season at FSU
Steve Addazio went 9-4 his first season at Temple (G5)
Winning 10 games in your first season ever as a P5 Head Coach is rare, not impossible, but rare. In almost every situation the first time HC was coming into a program that was already built & managed to make some slight tweaks to keep things steady from the previous HC that had success.
So, what we have to hope for is that our situation is more like David Shaw or Lincoln Riley when they took over the program, but the difference is those teams were being run by very good HC's who could easily pass the baton, that's not exactly the case with what we had with Richt. Ryan Day at Oh St actually fits this profile perfectly having Urby Liar hand over the program to him & will most likely seamlessly transition into a Lincoln Riley type first season.
I think 9-3/10-2 is plausible & if we win our Bowl game we could end up at 10-3 or 11-2 at the end of the season. 8-4 would be a big disappointment due to our schedule, but people talking about banners or Diaz being on the hot seat after year 1 are basically just confirming that Earnest T Bass was 100% right about this fanbase, which is downright sad.
I also find it hilarious how all yall jumped on Tony Perps for saying Diaz has a 1-year window to prove himself, but then in this thread yall are all only giving him 1 year to prove himself lol.
I think we'll go 10-2/11-2 this year, I would not be happy with an 8-4 season, but I'm not grabbing the pitchforks in year 1 unless we go 7-5/7-6 again. Some of the best coaches in college football didn't go undefeated or 12-1 in their first year ever as an HC, year 2 is the real barometer. Almost every great P5 college coach regardless of what their record was in year 1 had a great year 2.
What were Saban's, Oregeron's, Kirby's, and Dabo's records their first season w their current teams ?But our goal I thought was not out recruiting the Coastal teams. Everyone around here compares us to the Bamas, GAs, etc. and cry went we lose an "elite" to them. Four losses in the coastal after beating UF and FSU signals to many of our remaining targets, we're not ready for prime time. It could make holding our class together more difficult for our best recruits.
However it turns out, it's a must to show we're heading in the right direction or all this TNM magic that Manny's been creating will go for naught.
I agree.Then it begs the question of how far away are we? What I mean is - we went 7-6 last year with a championship defense and one of the worst offense and special teams I’ve ever seen. We lost 3 games by a possession last year where our defense was still held us in the game. If our offense improved by 7 points per game and everything else stayed equal, we had a 10 win season. We didn’t, so now we are in the reality of coming off a 7 win season because we couldn’t score.
So we have to answer 1. If our defense regresses, how much? 2. Does Enos and a new staff kickstart our offense to improve enough to offset any defensive regression? 3. It literally can’t get worse on defensive specials, so the only place to go is up - then how high and what impact? I think we were better than a 7 win team last year the same way I didn’t think we were a 10 win team in 2017. It all depends on this offense’s ability to improve enough to win the games they lost last year and that our defense stays around the same level.