Lol I agree Hall was somehow worse but like I said blame manny for bad evals, maybe he doesnt see what is so obvious to us but the notion he is just playing guys because they are older is unlikely and unsupported by any logic or reasoning. Does he play favorites? Perhaps, but I think that happens every where and also doesn't necessarily mean "older".
In reference to Cam, you bring up Dee a lot, did you miss his post where he said Manny told Cam (after he only got one yard on a short yardage situation) that we wasted a scholarship on him and he belongs at FIU? At least to me, that doesn't seem like a coach playing only upperclassman. I agree both Don and Rooster have higher ceilings, but when Cam was healthy, he was a dude, he also was the best in blitz pickup and pass protection. You also say Cam himself was complaining and feeling like he should play more, would that not insinuate that the other 2 freshman were playing enough to **** off your upperclassman? Don was also nicked this year and Rooster obviously ended up hurt. I thought Manny (or whoever) handled the RB room touches well.
Cam 126 car, 643 yds 10 td 5.1 avg
Chaney 68 carries 322 yds 3td 4.7 avd
Knighton 52 carries 209 yds 1td 4.0 avg