Look, I think we have talent, but you're just plain wrong about depth. Comparing it to last year doesn't matter, because our depth last year was also horrible. It's like not even debatable.
Patchan has literally never started a game, and it's not like he was some stud last year. I hope with him being fully recovered he will be a stud, but to assume he will be anything more than a solid rotational player is kinda ridiculous.
Hill was kicked off the team last time he played. He is a big risk, whether we want to admit it or not. He was above average as a Sophomore, and off to a good start as a Junior, but he missed basically the entire season. Who knows how he's going to return after all that time away. Hopefully he has been working his *** off, but without being part of a team for basically an entire year, it wouldn't be surprising if he wasn't in very good shape.
Rousseau was a **** true frosh last yr that played a few plays in 2 games. He has a **** load of potential, but that's it right now, same with Harvey. Do I think they'll be studs? Yes, hopefully. But they haven't proven ANYTHING yet.
So like I said, where we are RIGHT NOW, is not good depth wise. Garvin is the only 100% proven guy right now. So Depth is objectively not good. It's quite literally below average considering we have ONLY 3 Non-Freshman who are eligible at the position. When you're heavily dependent on 2 freshman (Rousseau & Harvey) to be able to play, you're depth is average or worse.