Hate to bring up criminoles for comparison but our situation, in a way, reminds me of FSU when Jamies Winston was a true Freshman. Winston got shirted as a frosh then came in the next year and we all know what happened. Manuel was in front of him and had much more buzz as a quality QB compared to Rosier but I was never impressed with what he did for them as a QB.
Manuel at FSU
*2011 Florida State ACC JR 203/311 65.3% 2,666 yds 18/8 td/int 151.2 pass rating team record 9-4
*2012 Florida State ACC SR 263/387 68.0% 3,397 yds 23/10 td/int 156.1 pass rating team record 12-2
Fairly pedestrian given the accuracy numbers. Very much a game manager imo. Solid yds/att but not astounding. Slight improvement year 1 to 2 with improved on field results to go with it
Compared to Rosier
2017 Miami (FL) ACC JR 224/415 54.0% 3120 yds 26/14 td/int 131.1 pass rating team record 10-3
Made big plays and got pts but couldnt sustain drives or convert crucial 3rd downs due to his inaccuracy. Also had some really poorly timed INTs, egregious errors.
And Winston's Numbers as a thought of what Williams/Weldon might be able to do for us if one of them takes Rosier's spot.
*2013 Florida State ACC FR 257/384 66.9% 4057 yds 40/10 td/int 184.8 pass rating team record 14-0
*2014 Florida State ACC SO 305/467 65.3% 3907 yds 25/18 td/int 145.5 pass rating team record 13-1
Unreal first season with a tremendous supporting cast. Came back to earth a bit in year two for a number of reasons not worth discussing.
Timely accuracy is the only thing separating Malik from being a good QB that is capable of leading this team to the playoff. If he completes the numerous bad throws to open wideouts that he missed last year, especially the third down throws, we would have gone 13-1. Our only loss being to Clemson.
The line separating an incredible season from the rollercoaster we went through last year is fairly thin. Something like 6-8 throws per game. In order to take the next step we need to find a way to get those 6-8 completions. Richt is going to give Rosier the chance to make those plays unless Williams/Weldon is the second coming of Tom Brady in fall practice.
For the record. I don't think Rosier's accuracy will improve much but Richt will start him. I am not convinced Richt will give Wiliams or Weldon the nod based on practice performance. Perry has no shot if he contineus to struggle with accuracy. Right now Perry's numbers show he is an even more streaky version of Rosier, capable of getting flame thrower hot and also going arctic cold. All coaches crave consistent QB play and Perry ain't it right now. I think Rosier will have to flame out in live action for Jarren to get his chance to prove he is the better QB. I'm hoping Williams/Weldon doesn't see the field this season other than mop up duties unless he somehow takes the starting role from Rosier in fall practice.
If Williams or Weldon start agaisnt LSU I will be surprised but excited, we could be in for an epic year if either of them practice well enough to take the spot outright .
If Rosier holds the job make no mistake about it he will be on a short leash because of his inaccuracy.