forums

Honest question...

Simple.

With Rosier, people felt the bigger issue was Rosier's inability to throw a football. With Perry in the game (and the hype he came in with) people felt like they would be watching a better offense with Perry's arm talent passing the ball but the offense looks about the same as it did with Malik. The common denominator then becomes Richt's play calling and the O-line/Searels.
 
Advertisement
One simple answer is that it wasn't cool to hate Richt for most of Rosier's PT.

Another is that, having crowned him, people might be hesitant to say Perry isn't all they hoped.

How about once something is somebody's fault, everything is their fault?
 
The Franchise said:
They have a very similar completion percentage this year. Yes Perry looks prettier throwing for 50%, but I’m just wondering why two QBs struggling under the same exact coach get treated so incredibly differently.

When Malik fails it’s all his fault; when Perry fails it’s all Rick’s fault.
Click to expand...
Similar comp% but Perry definitely opens the offense more due to his ability to hit more throws. I mean just ******* watch any of the bubble screens - Perry consistently allows the WRs to pick up YAC, while Rosier ******* throws behind the WRs just about every time. And obviously Rosiers noodle arm doesn't come close to Perry's with the distance throws or 10yrd outs and ****.

Perry throwing 50% Comp is a better QB than Rosier throwing 50% comp. Thats the reason I don'twant Rosier to play. Perry being bad is still ******* better than Rosier.
 
Because Malik has been here five years and has not gotten better and will not get better. We all know his lack of talent. Perry has the talent as evidenced by some truly amazing throws and five TDS against FSU (counting one to Wiggins that wasn’t reviewed). However he is going to have growing pains. Additionally, recruits and fans understand this. So we lose some games w Perry. The recruits appreciate that a Freshman is given the opportunity and understand that learning curve...so we actually still get top recruits that want to come here. Reality is that MR puts in a Non P5 qb talent who has experience at sucking. And MR opens his pie hole saying that this terrible talent is the best we have created in 3 years...And has earned the right to start...by sucking? It’s asinine for him to assume we’re all that ignorant. But he does, just as Golden did. The recruits see this as do players and their parents....ie. Harleys dad saying MR doesn’t know how to use talent. Then all of MRs ineptness w his system and play calls rise to the surface...magnified by fans, press, Harley’s dad. So what offensive recruit would want to come here to play for a stubborn, prideful, outdated Offensive coach? Oline sucks and we get the 4 star OG decommitment. Who can blame him. Serels hasn’t done squat with our Oline. So it ain’t gonna get better with less talent coming. New transfer rules will be interesting in off season. Good example. Remember bowl against WV MRs first year here. Look where programs were and are now. They’re way ahead of us...we’re not even ranked. We’ve regressed. All this exposed because MR went back to his inept talentless Non P5 caliber QB. Nothing against Malik as a person, he’s just a horrible QB. I can say id be horrible too. MR like having Al Golden-Dave Wandstatte Simese Twins
 
ddann said:
How is it relevant? Did Richt bring him in? Is he on the roster?
Click to expand...
It's relevant to the incompetant approach to QB's that Richt has demonstrated, from coach selection to recruiting strategy to offense to yanking Perry and putting Rosier back in...and it goes back to his final years at Georgia -Cam Newton, DeShaun Watson...probably Justin Fields too. If you cant see that, I can't do any more to explain it.
 
ddann said:
I read the previous posts.

I'm still wondering why you guys are still talking about Sitkowski.
Click to expand...

B/C the point was he was this close to being our QB due to a missed eval by Richt’s son. Just like MJJ was this close and he’s stinking it up in Oregon right now. It’s an indictment of J Richt as opposed to Sitkowski
 
Rosier is about 23 yrs old, Perry’s about 19. Four yrs of experience should count for something.

On a side note, does anyone know why Richt didn’t call more run plays for him at UVA? Feel like he had 1 or 2 that game but the offense has previously feasted on those plays when Malik has made the start.
 
RVACane said:
It's relevant to the incompetant approach to QB's that Richt has demonstrated, from coach selection to recruiting strategy to offense to yanking Perry and putting Rosier back in...and it goes back to his final years at Georgia -Cam Newton, DeShaun Watson...probably Justin Fields too. If you cant see that, I can't do any more to explain it.
Click to expand...

So a poorly performing QB that Richt did not bring into the program and who is not on the roster demonstrates Richt's failures as a coach?
 
RVACane said:
It's relevant to the incompetant approach to QB's that Richt has demonstrated, from coach selection to recruiting strategy to offense to yanking Perry and putting Rosier back in...and it goes back to his final years at Georgia -Cam Newton, DeShaun Watson...probably Justin Fields too. If you cant see that, I can't do any more to explain it.
Click to expand...

They don’t get it, bro. Another Richt follower trying to justify Richt.
 
Advertisement
Rellyrell said:
They don’t get it, bro. Another Richt follower trying to justify Richt.
Click to expand...

Well, it is kind of hard to "get it" when you guys are criticizing Richt for NOT bringing in Sitkowski and for NOT recruiting Justin Fields to UGA when he wasn't even there anymore.
 
Both these sorry MFers need to be watching and studying gamefilm like Dorsey did (like a Maniac) Instead of driving around flashing Wads of $$$ with a New Grill..trying to look like Tupac....and another one as a 5th yr Sr STILL does the Dumbest **** ever....Go home to Ocala to drive around with your homies flashing $$$$??....Maannnn get your *** in that G-**** film room....
 
Lazarre said:
Recruiting sites label Malik a player that shouldn't be a QB at Miami. So Richt and his system overachieved with Malik. Recruiting sites label Perry as one of the top QB of his class and should be good no matter what. So Richt is underachieving and his system is trash.
Click to expand...
I think we have a winner right here.
 
I think Richt needs to figure out its 2018.
Starting a True Freshman QB might be the best route to going forward.

Seeing N'Kosi play doesn't really change our offense much for the better. Rosier and Perry have quite a few similarities. They both struggle with accuracy, reading defenses and do not have "make you miss athleticism" in the open field limiting their upside as a runner.

I understand Jarren has had his fair share of freshman hiccups. However, at the end of the day you need to play the best player and teach them how to be the man from there.

Until Richt realizes, or publicly proves for that matter, that Jarren is the guy to lead the team from this point on - all of us as fans will continue to question whether or not Richt is the right man. To add to that, we will see a difficult perception in recruiting until our coach proves he plays the best player. You can tell the tension through his press conference today, when he added a lot of freshman feel like they have the right to be playing.
 
RVACane said:
It's relevant to the incompetant approach to QB's that Richt has demonstrated, from coach selection to recruiting strategy to offense to yanking Perry and putting Rosier back in...and it goes back to his final years at Georgia -Cam Newton, DeShaun Watson...probably Justin Fields too. If you cant see that, I can't do any more to explain it.
Click to expand...

The funny thing that no one talks about is Richt didn't even see Cam as a QB lol. He saw Cam as a TE prospect. Richt deserves to be questioned a lot about his QB evaluations and recruiting.

This is a quote from Richt when he was at UGA talking about Cam Newton:

"I remember him [as a recruit]," Georgia coach Mark Richt said Tuesday. "He was a very talented guy, a guy that we did look at."

But . . .

"We actually had him pegged as more of a tight end prospect," Richt said. "A lot of it had to do with what we like to do offensively, more of a fit [issue] than any disrespect to his ability to play quarterback."

LOL Ernest Hemingway would have trouble making this s-hit up man.
 
ddann said:
So a poorly performing QB that Richt did not bring into the program and who is not on the roster demonstrates Richt's failures as a coach?
Click to expand...
I gave you a number of examples and @Rellyrell gave you reasons as well. You're the one that's focused on Pickowski. What about the entire body of QB and Offensive malfunction we gave you? Why are you so focused on one name? We gave a bunch of names
 
ddann said:
Well, it is kind of hard to "get it" when you guys are criticizing Richt for NOT bringing in Sitkowski and for NOT recruiting Justin Fields to UGA when he wasn't even there anymore.
Click to expand...

OK Jon.
 
Advertisement
ddann said:
Well, it is kind of hard to "get it" when you guys are criticizing Richt for NOT bringing in Sitkowski and for NOT recruiting Justin Fields to UGA when he wasn't even there anymore.
Click to expand...
He didnt recruit Fields when he was there at UGA and he sure as shît didnt recruit him here.
 
RVACane said:
I gave you a number of examples and @Rellyrell gave you reasons as well. You're the one that's focused on Pickowski. What about the entire body of QB and Offensive malfunction we gave you? Why are you so focused on one name? We gave a bunch of names
Click to expand...

Well, why don't you guys focus on things that Richt has actually done that are worth criticizing instead of getting sidetracked on a guy he didn't even bring into the program?
 
Back
Top