Those overall records are nearly identical.
Schnellenberger inherited one good recruiting year from Saban, but he won a championship in his fifth year, thus the players were his.
JJ inherited a great team from Schnellenberger, but he won a championship in his fourth year, thus the players were his.
Erickson inherited a great team from JJ, and he won his championships in his first year (all JJ's players) and third year (most were JJ's players). After JJ's players were gone, while our record was decent, our players became undisciplined. Probation would have happened even if Erickson had stayed, so if he had to deal with 31 scholarship losses, his last few years at UM would have been abysmal. The worst/most prominent violations (Pell Grant, hidden drug test, etc.) happened fully on Erickson's watch, and other violations continued or increased on Erickson's watch.
Butch inherited a terrible team and we should have played for a national championship in his final year.
Coker inherited a great team from Butch, and won a championship in his first year, with Butch's players. We then got worse every single year that he remained.
Erickson is a tiny bit better than Coker, as far as results go. But they accomplished the same big-picture things, the decline of our program.
.