forums

Chip Mailing It In?

If we want a truly top notch coach, we are going to have to out bid someone. That's the truth. It's going to come down to how high we will go. Otherwise, it's probably Butch.

And, I'm ok with that.
 
Advertisement
GoldenShowers said:
Are we seriously judging a guys coaching ability now on an NFL game with Mark Sanchez at QB?

Did you people see Saban, Botch, Spurrier, and Petrino in the NFL? Kelly has been better than all those dudes were in the league.
Click to expand...
Shhhhhh Butch taught JJ everything he knows about recruiting and talent evals and is responsible for multiple UM championships, havent you heard?
 
duke4heisman said:
The gimmick master is getting DESTROYED by the 3-7 Lions.
Click to expand...

I love Butch as much as the next guy and would be fine with him - IF we can't get Chip, Patterson, Dantonio, or Mullen. But the BBB crowd needs a little perspective. Butch went 5-11 in his 3rd season with the Browns and 3-8 in year 4. Most coaches aren't made for both college and the NFL (see Saban, Spurrier, Butch). If you don't like Chip, that's your thing. But don't act like the dude hasn't been a beast in College as an HC.
 
B.B.B said:
No one is concerned with Chip's defenses?
Click to expand...

Why do people think he doesn't care about D? Of course if you run your O at a fast pace you are going to give up some yards. He also was working with a weak recruiting base.

That said, here's his D yards per play rank at Oregon:

12th
11th
35th
26th

Hardly horrible and he'd be working with a lot better talent here.

If Chip comes back to college at a program with a great recruiting base its bad news for the rest of college football.
 
Tad Footeball said:
Dwinstitles said:
He aint mailing it in he just cant run that O vs great DLines that are physical. No body mails it in he just simply destroyed there roster and thought he was the smartest person in the room,nikka got that ag behavior but hes won at oregon so im not comparing the two. His defensive personal n decisions are awful.
Click to expand...

I was being facetious with the "mailing it in" title. That said, he does seem a little too comfortable letting this rookie CB give up about 21 points on his own in like 10 mins.
Click to expand...

Imma defensive guy and im ok with being a stingy d with an ok offense like bama. And some people are lets score 50 and give up 40, im not with that new age. The teams who seem to with championships always field a mean d and people concerned with chip have a right just like butch has questions. I like butchs resume with evidence of dominating in sfla.

Wouldnt be mad at chip herman but butch is top for me because of his evaluations and his defense, imma roll with what saban says cfb is about recruiting.
 
Advertisement
Butch is one of my favorite coaches because I watched his teams growing up but you guys are insane. Kelly is an elite coach with incredible offenses. Please tell me how many west coast teams have great defenses? They just don't breed those guys out there. Kelly would have a much better defense here and the top offense in the nation. His name would recruit itself and instantly make us relevant. You guys are crazy to down play him because he's an absolute pipe dream hire.
 
The ****** is strong ITT. Saban, JJ, Spurrier and BUTCH all sucked as college coaches too. He would absolutely bring us back to dominance. I love Butch but only if we can't get get Chip!
 
Butch coached an expansion team. Meaning he started from scratch. Probably the hardest coaching job in the NFL to take on.
 
KevinCaneFace said:
Klamalama said:
KevinCaneFace said:
A Gimmick coach that's 46-7. Give me that gimmick all day.
Click to expand...

Potato Chip must have been undefeated before this season, because he's 4-7 (and falling) for 2015.
Click to expand...

Again, love Butch but what was his record during his last year in the NFL?
Click to expand...

Butch and Potato Chip both have 1 NFL playoff appearance. One can fairly say that both are NFL failures.

Butch already proved that he could come back to college and succeed. Chip may succeed again, I don't know, and you don't know.
 
kendallcanes said:
Butch coached an expansion team. Meaning he started from scratch. Probably the hardest coaching job in the NFL to take on.
Click to expand...

The Jaguars and Panthers made the conference championships their second year as an expansion. Success is still possible. It's dumb to judge college coaches off of NFL success
 
I would love Chip Kelly. He is number 1 on my list. That being said, his Defense scares the **** out of me. In order to win championships you need a top notch Defense. Just saying. This isn't the NFL. F that, most Super Bowl champs have a good Defense. It's the common denominator to any championship.
 
Advertisement
Klamalama said:
KevinCaneFace said:
Klamalama said:
KevinCaneFace said:
A Gimmick coach that's 46-7. Give me that gimmick all day.
Click to expand...

Potato Chip must have been undefeated before this season, because he's 4-7 (and falling) for 2015.
Click to expand...

Again, love Butch but what was his record during his last year in the NFL?
Click to expand...

Butch and Potato Chip both have 1 NFL playoff appearance. One can fairly say that both are NFL failures.

Butch already proved that he could come back to college and succeed. Chip may succeed again, I don't know, and you don't know.
Click to expand...

He may very well succeed as you saw Oregon isn't the same team anymore after players have left. I wonder if there is any shot of him going back to Oregon.
 
A what's up with this butch knows how to recruit south fla crap, there are not secret to recruiting south Florida kids just win and send guys to the NFL and they will come chip kelly just need to hire a solid DC and we good
 
Back
Top