Fawk_U Haters
Junior
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2015
- Messages
- 4,510
[MENTION=11362]Fawk_U Haters[/MENTION]:[MENTION=11362]Fawk_U Haters[/MENTION]: Not sure if you played football or not, but scheme has a lot to do w/ why Chick, along w/ many others on the D-Line, are not getting to the QB. As a DE in the 3-4 system, you need strength and bulk to hold up. Chick did just fine w/ that. However, this 3-4 scheme is a read and react philosophy vs. a read and attack like most others.I like Chick, was he a 285 lb DE? Probably not, but I laugh when people talk like he was going to be a sack master at UM until he was "misused". Someone said he had 15 sacks while here, but lets be honest he should've had 15 more if he could just tackle and make a play when he got to the QB.
Someone mentioned this great pass rushing beast from the UA game. Did you watch the game? Correct me if I am wrong, but one sack was from a bad snap. One sack was a coverage sack where the QB, rightfully so, stepped up in the pocket and chose to go away from Clowney. Another sack was where he was unblocked and Clowney destroyed 2 people trying to block him had the QB wrapped up and couldn't take him to the ground, Chick was just right there for the clean up. I forgot when he got the other sack, but i'm sure Clowney had something to do with it. He looks a lot better when he has a great player opposite him like Clowney and Vernon his Freshman year.
He had a lot of sacks in HS, but stats are misleading. He had a few games against really bad team that he had like 5, 4, and 4 sack games. Not to hard to pad stats against BAD HS teams with a 195 tackle trying to block you. Against teams that have same level talent (Plant, Armwood, Hillsborough, and Brandon) he got 1 sack total and I don't think he got any QB hurries.
Like I said I like Chick, but for those that think he will be James Harrison/Kevin Greene/or any great pass rushing OLB you're not be honest. Chick looks explosive against lesser talent. He get sacks because of great coverage, hustle and effort, and by being in the right place at the right time. He has never been able to shed blocks really well and he will have a very hard time in the league if he doesn't learn how to do that. I think he is on the practice squad this year. Great pass rushing OLB, I just don't see it.
Our scheme is nothing like Quinn's Seattle 3-4 philosophy or Fangio's 49ers 3-4 philosophy; their 3-4 scheme is designed for corners to press up on receivers to re-set a QB's internal clock, and for the DE's to cause confusion between pinning their ears back and firing off the L.O.S or setting edges so the LBs can come down hill.
We've recruited pass rushers for the last several cycles (Chick, AQM, Thomas, Jackson) yet we're telling them to "hold the line" and allow the LBs to clean up the play. We've ranked in the bottom 3rd in sacks every year since Golden has been here...so no, I don't blame Chick for only having 15 sacks in his career at UM...AQM, Thomas, McCord, Jackson, Harris were all tremendous pass rushers in HS and now they are being taught to not to pin their ears back, but rather, hold the line, and neither one of them have been getting to the QB either.
That can be extremely frustrating for these types of players which is why I said Golden is a mediocre recruiter. He recruits press corners, roaming safeties, rush DE's, and yet he's constantly putting them out of position which is huring both the on-field and off-field potentials. Chick is letting the world know, as he should, that he was played out of position and misused. At the Sr. Bowl, he shined, again...just like he did at the UA all-star game. I'm sorry, that's not a coincidence.
How well these players do at the next level will be another indictment on how crappy Golden is as a coach, motivator, mentor, and leader of men (no disrespect to Genron). And I don't blame Chick for taking shots at Golden...Chick is a 3rd generation Cane; Golden is not even close to being a Cane. He's only here b/c he has no other choice (since his Alma-Mater wasn't foolin' w/ him).
Rellyrell,
Not sure you have reading comprehension above grade school, but nothing in your response led me to believe that you actually read and comprehended my post. My post was to indicate, no matter what the people on this board would like to think, Chick was never, and will never be some kind of pass rushing beast. You mentioned the UA all star game, but if you go and watch the game everything I said in my post was true. Just about all of his sacks in the UA game were the benefit of having the future #1 overall pick playing on the other side of him, being a coverage sack, or not getting blocked. Go watch the highlights and you'll see what I am talking about. I see where you didn't respond to where he got the majority of sacks in HS against 195 lb tackles trying to block him. Again, go to the film, watch it, digest it, and you'll see plain as day. Tape doesn't lie my friend.
You say the scheme held him back and that's why he only had 15 sacks (and yes Relly I played HS ball, college ball, and coached college ball as well. So I know what the difference is in defensive schemes) However I noticed you left out a response to where the scheme had him in position to make 10-15 other sacks and he MISSED. I also noticed you missed where I said in my opening sentence that, "was he a 285 lb DE...probably not." Again i'm not sure you're comprehending what you're reading.
I also noticed where you didn't have a response to where he couldn't get off blocks very well. Again he has had the same problem in HS, UA game, college, and he will have a very hard time in the league.
I'm not calling Golden the coach of the decade, but please, name for me 3 players since 2011 that we "misused" at UM and went on to do great things in the league. The fact that this past draft was the first class that had all 4 years under Golden and we've had the most draft picks in a very long time should tell you that, no matter your hatred for AG, we are developing and giving the NFL something to use.
by your response, I'm not sure about your reading comprehension (no shade)
I carefully outlined why Chick, AQM, Harris, Jackson, and Thomas are not getting to the QB. I carefully outlined why a read and react defense will not allow for D-Linemen to get to the QB. I also touched on how Miami, as a team, has been in the bottom 3rd in sacks since Golden's arrival. If you watched any of the past practices, the D-Lineman have been taught to engage and hold; not to engage and disengage (which would explain him "not" being able to get off of blocks). What we've seen from every single d-lineman thus far has been to engage and hold the line of scrimmage.
I firmly believe, regardless of what you think, that Chick would've been a very solid pass rusher under a different coaching staff. His performance at the Sr. Bowl is what got him drafted and the questions came about, what happend to him at UM.
You can have your opinion on him, but again it's not a coincidence that when he's been coached up by other personnel, his ability to get to the QB was on display.
We'll agree to disagree and we'll see where chick is at in a few years.
as for your dissertation on the 3-4 read and react and read and attack. Not all the guys you listed above are supposed to get to the QB in a 3-4. Mostly your rush end and your OLB get the sacks in a 3-4 my man. Chick was our Brett Keisal, not our James Harrison. I think we have some solid pass rushers and we'll see a difference this year. Least I hope so. I believe we've upgraded across the DL at every spot with who just left and who is playing there now.
Canessince4ever. Chick was the edge setting 3-4 end. We used him at DT on third downs to try and get more pass rushers on the field so I don't know what you're trying to say, but last year, when he was kicked down to DT, he was effective. He just didn't finish!