You're talking about the guy who's qbr was ranked 30th in the nation according to ESPN. About 56% completion rate, twice as many TD's as Int's. My argument isn't that Richardson was great or even very good, but I don't think he was awful from an overall standpoint either, and I guess you're implying Henderson would have been significantly better with a more accurate passer. Better? Sure. An impact player??
Look - I like the take (prospectively), but feel he's a guy who can play a role to improve the room. The speed is undeniable; how good the receiver is - we'll see.
Dude, I'm not mad at you, but those stats are garbage.
First of all, you are citiing "QBR", which will take into account his running. And I have acknowledged that his running was a strength, but that's really not a big deal TO A WIDE RECEIVER hoping to catch more passes.
As for completion rate, where are you getting that from, his career? Because in his one year as a full-time starter (last year) his completion rate was 53.8%. That is TERRIBLE.
And this "twice as many TDs as INTs crap? Not even. He had 17 TDs and 9 INTs, so you have to "round up" to get to your stat. And for the first 8 games of the season, he was dead-even, with 7 TD passes against 7 INTs. It was only in the final four games, against aTm (5-7), South Carolina (8-5), Vanderbilt (5-7) and F$U (10-3) that he got to a positive TD-to-INT ratio. It was only in THOSE FOUR GAMES that AR-15 was able to go +8 in TD passes over INTs. And two of those four teams had EVEN WORSE records than Florida.
So, look, you can either accurately quote stats (53.8% completion rate) or you can look at stats that tell a bigger story (such as 7.8 yards per pass attempt, which factors in the incompletions). The fact remains, AR-15 completed 176 passes for 2,549 yards. Over 12 games, THAT IS FEWER THAN 15 COMPLETIONS PER GAME FOR JUST OVER 200 YARDS PER GAME. Seriously.
Now factor out AR-15's "long" passes per game:
23 - Utah
28 - Kentucky
33 - USF
44 - Kentucky
75 - Eastern Washington
20 - Mizzou
51 - LSU
78 - UGa
23 - aTm
27 - South Carolina
74 - Vandy
52 - F$U
That means 528 yards (over 20% of his total passing production) came on 12 passes.
Seriously, you just have to go back and watch the games.