Wow

The annual tradition of ****ting on people who bring actual legit information to a free message board is always entertaining.

@1murhurricane is also one of maybe 3 guys who had us landing Jackson Cantwell.


Yes.

If people don't like a thread like this, they don't have to come back to it.

And we certainly don't need any dopey white knights trying to defend a poster by misstating the issue.

It's very simple, if people don't like the subject matter of the thread, fine. Leave the thread. But don't attack the original poster, who is one of the most solid and reliable on the board.
 
Advertisement
Changing Season 9 GIF by Curb Your Enthusiasm
 
Yes.

If people don't like a thread like this, they don't have to come back to it.

And we certainly don't need any dopey white knights trying to defend a poster by misstating the issue.

It's very simple, if people don't like the subject matter of the thread, fine. Leave the thread. But don't attack the original poster, who is one of the most solid and reliable on the board.
I find it funny because unless you choose to support the site and get no ads all this info is legit free to read… if you don’t wanna believe someone from the internet that’s cool totally get it but wasting everyone’s time battling people is annoying. You and a couple of others have proven when yall drop hints it should be appreciated

Recruiting is never 100% done I mean we had that Alabama LB I forget his name who legit had an Auburn tattoo yet flipped to Bama lol it’s like cmon if you needed anymore proof that this stuff is fluid there it is
 
I think he meant me. I wrote a post that was derived from what OP implied, and from what DMoney said on a podcast. The basic point was that UM is using some system to determine value of player and value of position.
But as you and I would certainly agree, there needs to be a systematic way of determine $$$ value and not just throwing darts at a dart board.

Assuming UM has a system which is based on data analytics, and again I am basing this as much on common sense as actual knowledge, then from that assumption and looking at how UM has recruited the past few years, it seems very clear that we are not spending money on 5 star QB’s. We are definitely spending money on 5 star OLine and DLine, as well as DB starting with the money allocation in the portal this year, and the commits for 2026. Now none of this is specific to any one player. But from patterns we can make basic assumptions. And UM under Mario seems to have a clear recruiting pattern as to NIL allocation.

I also assume there is a data analytics system in place because every pro league with a salary cap uses a system to determine position value. QB, OT, DE, WR…….RB, Kicker. So if the NFL has the data to support how money should be allocated within a cap league, then it would almost be beyond belief, IMO, that UM and other major universities aren’t doing similar analysis. And if they are not, they are behind the curve because someone university is.

I would not call this Moneyball because that was based on a premise of identifying characteristics that were undervalued by every one else. Here everyone already has the data. But some read it differently than others, and still pay for 5 star QB’s.


Oh, I definitely knew he was referring to your post.

He just read too much into what you were saying. We are all aware of moneyball principles (one of my best friends from HS is the head "moneyball" guy for an MLB team), and while there may be some truisms (very few HS QBs are worth blowing the budget for), we do not hew strictly to that model. There may be a QB in the future who is worth the investment, but in this limited timeframe, we have not signed one (though we clearly pursued one who then flipped to Florida).

The situation is more ad hoc. The collective determines the high-end of what to pay a particular player. There are a few recruits who have commanded an "outside the box" number, but that is very rare and the money doesn't just go to "another player" if that recruit chose not to pick UM. It is "special one-time-only" money, so to speak.

Overall, my point was to say that the entire roster is not being constructed under moneyball principles. But there are certainly per-player limits. And as we have seen, sometimes we spend more on a particular position due to our needs, and not due to overarching "moneyball" limits.
 
I find it funny because unless you choose to support the site and get no ads all this info is legit free to read… if you don’t wanna believe someone from the internet that’s cool totally get it but wasting everyone’s time battling people is annoying. You and a couple of others have proven when yall drop hints it should be appreciated

Recruiting is never 100% done I mean we had that Alabama LB I forget his name who legit had an Auburn tattoo yet flipped to Bama lol it’s like cmon if you needed anymore proof that this stuff is fluid there it is


There is one phenomenon that has cracked me up, over and over and over again.

A. People seemingly come to this site (which boasts no affiliation with any major recruiting service, and very few actual "articles") to read crowd-sourced information about the team and recruiting which goes BEYOND what is reported in print newspapers, magazines and/or websites.

B. People immmediately complain about the unreliability of the information found on this website and choose to believe ONLY official reports found in print or online publications.

Bizarre.
 
Respect for your posts, I'll take you at your word, I just don't remember seeing the aha moment when he was Cribby who made his name on board and PM.
Thanks, brother! You’re a good poster and I respect your opinions. Cribby is our GOAT insider, and then next I would put OP. He has some great connections and has had a very high hit rate when he has brought info to the board.
 
Thanks, brother! You’re a good poster and I respect your opinions. Cribby is our GOAT insider, and then next I would put OP. He has some great connections and has had a very high hit rate when he has brought info to the board.


I would also point out that Cribby is in Hogtown and 1murhurricane is in Texas. Which should prove the value of connections/relationships. It's not always about proximity.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
Yes.

If people don't like a thread like this, they don't have to come back to it.

And we certainly don't need any dopey white knights trying to defend a poster by misstating the issue.

It's very simple, if people don't like the subject matter of the thread, fine. Leave the thread. But don't attack the original poster, who is one of the most solid and reliable on the board.
Lmao. This site is literally unreadable and 99.9% of the posts are fans posting gibberish. Unserious.
 
Back
Top