• Attention: Register today to view CanesInSight Ad-Free for 7 days.

Will we see both Sheriffs & Rosier in Bethune Game?

the storm

Banned Under CIS Martial Law until 11/5/20
Joined
May 10, 2014
Messages
3,457
Will Coach Richt go with both QB's the first couple of games? Hope an announcement comes tomorrow. Personally I would like to see both of them in action since there's been no chance to watch scrimmages. GO CANES! :stormwarningflag-sm
 

DualThreat

Redshirt Freshman
Joined
Sep 14, 2016
Messages
741
I'd be shocked if one QB took every snap in a game we should be winning by 40 in the second half.
 

Canes82

Freshman
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
409
Good question.

Obviously they'll both play....but will there be a rotation of some kind for the first two games? Just to give both guys a look with the top O.

Can't really tell who's separating if you're looking at scrimmage stats. Looks pretty close to me.

A week ago, Pete and DMoney were saying Shireffs was leading.
 
Last edited:

ThomasM

Senior
Joined
Jul 9, 2014
Messages
13,554
All 3 will play

Why would Perry play when he could really use a redshirt season? Both the guys ahead of him aren't leaving after this season, so it's not like Perry has to be the starter next year. I'd rather see him playing as a redshirt senior than mop up duty as a true freshman. People need to cool their jets and have a little patience with the kid.
 

Cajuncane

Senior
Joined
Apr 22, 2017
Messages
9,561
All 3 will play

I don't think Perry will play until he shows enough in practices/scrimmages that he has a legitimize chance to start this year.

Why waste a year where he could RS for a few plays that dont mean anything other than game action.

Unless he shows Richt between now and then that he will be a threat to unseat Rosier THIS year I can't see the reward..jmo.
 

OldhamA

Senior
Joined
Dec 19, 2012
Messages
7,541
All 3 will play

I honestly think that's the last thing this team needs. Firstly this team needs stability at the QB position - nobody benefits if there's a QB battle going into the season. Pick a guy and stick with him until he gives you a reason to bench him.

Secondly if Perry isn't one of the best two QBs on the roster come September he shouldn't see the field barring injury. I'm not a fan of redshirting players as quite frankly if they're good enough they're gone in three years anyway.
 

ThomasM

Senior
Joined
Jul 9, 2014
Messages
13,554
All 3 will play

I honestly think that's the last thing this team needs. Firstly this team needs stability at the QB position - nobody benefits if there's a QB battle going into the season. Pick a guy and stick with him until he gives you a reason to bench him.

Secondly if Perry isn't one of the best two QBs on the roster come September he shouldn't see the field barring injury. I'm not a fan of redshirting players as quite frankly if they're good enough they're gone in three years anyway.

The gone in 3 year types are rarely QBs. The thought of a redshirt junior/senior Perry starting is was more exciting than a true freshman Perry getting mop up duty handing the ball off.
 

fivecent

Junior
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
1,656
All 3 will play

I honestly think that's the last thing this team needs. Firstly this team needs stability at the QB position - nobody benefits if there's a QB battle going into the season. Pick a guy and stick with him until he gives you a reason to bench him.

Secondly if Perry isn't one of the best two QBs on the roster come September he shouldn't see the field barring injury. I'm not a fan of redshirting players as quite frankly if they're good enough they're gone in three years anyway.

I strongly disagree. The competition between Malik and Evan seemed extremely close. Since Malik has shown in the past to be int prone, its wise to get Evan some playing time, just in case Malik gets the yips and reverts to form. Additionally, you don't want to give a guy like Jimbo too much tape on Malik. I say, give Malik the 1st half in the first two games, then if we are up big, put in Evan and Perry for final two quarters. Perry NEEDS the reps to be ready for next year.
 

TheEye

Cane Grad!
Joined
Feb 12, 2013
Messages
5,736
All 3 will play

Why would Perry play when he could really use a redshirt season? Both the guys ahead of him aren't leaving after this season, so it's not like Perry has to be the starter next year. I'd rather see him playing as a redshirt senior than mop up duty as a true freshman. People need to cool their jets and have a little patience with the kid.

I say no point in red shirting if they leave in their 3rd year regardlesss!
 

Astcloud11

Senior
Joined
Nov 4, 2015
Messages
5,813
All 3 will play

Why would Perry play when he could really use a redshirt season? Both the guys ahead of him aren't leaving after this season, so it's not like Perry has to be the starter next year. I'd rather see him playing as a redshirt senior than mop up duty as a true freshman. People need to cool their jets and have a little patience with the kid.

I say no point in red shirting if they leave in their 3rd year regardlesss!

Same here. Save the red shirt for possibly medical reasons. He shouldn't be here after 3 seasons
 

LatinCane

Sophomore
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
687
I am fine with playing two and redshirting two. If Perry and Weldon are that distant from Sherriffs and Rosier then save them UNLESS we have injuries and need them. It's up to the coaches however. I have full trust in this offensive coaching staff.

Even as decent as Jameis Winston was when he arrived at FSU, a redshirt season helped him immensely and he took claimed the starting job the following Spring practice. Lamar Jackson at Louisville is another good example.
 
Last edited:

TheEye

Cane Grad!
Joined
Feb 12, 2013
Messages
5,736
I am fine with playing two and redshirting two. If Perry and Weldon are that distant from Sherriffs and Rosier then save them UNLESS we have injuries and need them. It's up to the coaches however. I have full trust in this offensive coaching staff.

Even as decent as Jameis Winston was when he arrived at FSU, a redshirt season helped him immensely and he took claimed the starting job the following Spring practice. Lamar Jackson at Louisville is another good example.

But he still left early. He could have learned even more playing clean up duty in his Freshman year.
 

RHCanes

Redshirt Freshman
Joined
Apr 3, 2017
Messages
252
If Rosier and Shirreffs are putting up passing numbers like this against the second unit then we don't have the depth we thought. Perry will benefit from this experience by facing tremendous challenges: learning new plays and trying to execute against a fast defense. Rosier and Shirreffs have taken advantage of this opportunity but will the team be better off with Kaaya understudies? I still believe Weldon and Perry are better QBs but needs year to learn system.
 
Top