UM doesn't treat CFB like a business

wushah

Junior
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
1,635
UM isn't serious about football. They don't have legitimate buy-in from the people who matter. The President isn't interested, the AD is unequivocally impotent, and the BoT is rudderless. Manny plays whack-a-mole when trying to solve problems. He doesn't have the infrastructure in place to support his inexperience or to allow for sustainable growth, and he doesn't have processes in place to build efficiency, consistency, and success. If there was ever a program that needed an outside consultant, it's this one. There's no adult in the room.

The news of Manny demoting himself back to play-calling duties is the perfect microcosm of the bigger problem facing the program. More than ever, Manny needed to step into his role as head coach and own it. He needed to have his fingerprints on the offense, defense, special teams, analysts, everyone's responsibilities, flow of communication between analysts, coaches, and himself in practice and in games, with data analytics, investment into behavioral science for the players and coaches, S&C, nutrition, and the reestablishment of clear targets for the program. Instead, he's positioned himself, by his own design, into a position which will limit his growth as a head coach. In this sort of scenario, Blake James should have stepped up and stopped it from happening. In fact, it never should have even been an option, but the problem is that the infrastructure isn't in place to prevent this.

It's not about the TRob hire, the Jess Simpson hire, or even Manny making the absurd move to resume play-calling duties. It's not about Manny putting his *** on the line by calling the defense, or trying to get rid of Manny or Blake. It's about whether UM has organized itself, created the right infrastructure, implemented the right processes, set the right targets, to maximize its potential as a program. That's what good programs, businesses, do to create success.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
May be a little soon for this, but would love to hear thoughts on how the decision-makers view yesterday's moves.

My sense is that Blake James wants coaching staffs to sink or swim on their own merits, thereby reducing his liability and culpability. He seems to be there in a very ancillary, "call me if you need anything"-type of way. He's positioned EReed as a buffer between Manny and himself further reducing his own footprint on the program. A strong AD wouldn't have allowed Manny to make the decision that he did, but I don't think Blake James is that guy.

I'd love to hear what the BoT thinks too.
 
Isn't UM a private institution? In a sea of publicly funded universities?

Think about it.


I think this is used as an excuse far too often. I'm not expecting UM to spend money like Bama and OSU. The expectation the fan base should have is that the program maximize the potential of the program by running it appropriately. Nobody can successfully argue that it's being run in a manner to support sustainable success.
 
Advertisement
I think this is used as an excuse far too often. I'm not expecting UM to spend money like Bama and OSU. The expectation the fan base should have is that the program maximize the potential of the program by running it appropriately. Nobody can successfully argue that it's being run in a manner to support sustainable success.

What do you mean by "success"?

Because I can tell you a lot of positives gains we've made. With stats to back it up.


****! Makes you wonder why we just don't throw 7 million per year at the best coach, right?
 
There isn't a blank check like state run schools or large private institutions. In the Final AP 25 only 5 private schools are ranked: Notre Dame, BYU, Northwestern, Miami and Liberty. Of the 5 ranked: Notre Dame has it's own Athletic budget funded in great part by its TV contract & an endowment fund that would make all of us extremely wealthy! BYU has all the Mormon money behind it yet only occasionally has a top team. Northwestern & Miami both have limited budgets and Liberty is a freak. Hugh Freeze offense at Liberty was too much for Coastal Carolina in his 2nd year - but he did lose to NC State...1 year is not a program especially given Covid player availability. Coastal Carolina? Beat BYU and lost to Liberty.....crazy season but look where the budgets are. As a small school, which just had a financially difficult football season (& other sports affecting the AD budget) perhaps there was only so much money available THIS year. Miami has shown over the past several years post Donna Shalloser that it will spend $$ to rebuild the program. I expect that will continue after the 2020/21 budget year comes back to some normalcy.
 
Advertisement
Idk. Something tells me if Steele didn't take the Tennessee job CMD would've hired him as DC/LB coach, Baker would've been gone, and we'd all been calling CMD K1NG of the offseason and interest would've been as high as it was when we transitioned to the spread under Lashlee. Manny is just buying himself another year without having to make a rushed DC decision...Manny running the DEF full time isn't the long term play here, it's a one year handshake deal between him and UMs power brokers.....landing Steele had a certain $$$ on it and although a very respectable $$$ amount Steele instead opted to go to Tenn where there's a high probability that the HC job will be opening very soon....so once that happened with that same amount of $$$ left to obtain a DC there wasn't a guy out there at that pay range and Manny knew he couldn't get this one wrong so "it appears" an agreement was reached to take over the DEF/LBs himself, make Baker his asst, and if the progress continues from 6-7 to 8-3 to say 10-3 + bowl game outcome then Manny/Power Brokers let Baker's deal come off the books and we ADD Bakers salary to our DC salary pool which would now make us that much more of an attractive destination considering the upward trajectory of the program and the increased salary.

Simply put....this is a 1yr deal and I think it works out. Wasn't high on it when news first dropped but after taking a step back and trying to figure out "why the heck....etc" it makes sense now. UMs power brokers are slowly beginning to open that checkbook, proof is the TRob hiring and then DVD being paid as a CB coach just to be an asst Secondary coach which is BIG for our DB/CB room recruiting wise. As good as Stroud is the DL hire of Simpson is an upgrade as he will hone in on gap integrity and setting the edge, two things that KILLED US LAST YEAR.

If we can still land a portal CB (certain individual we all have in mind) then I will say while Manny didn't crush the offseason, he definitely would have significantly improved our football team coming into the 2021 season.
 
UM isn't serious about football. They don't have legitimate buy-in from the people who matter. The President isn't interested, the AD is unequivocally impotent, and the BoT is rudderless. Manny plays whack-a-mole when trying to solve problems. He doesn't have the infrastructure in place to support his inexperience or to allow for sustainable growth, and he doesn't have processes in place to build efficiency, consistency, and success. If there was ever a program that needed an outside consultant, it's this one. There's no adult in the room.

The news of Manny demoting himself back to play-calling duties is the perfect microcosm of the bigger problem facing the program. More than ever, Manny needed to step into his role as head coach and own it. He needed to have his fingerprints on the offense, defense, special teams, analysts, everyone's responsibilities, flow of communication between analysts, coaches, and himself in practice and in games, with data analytics, investment into behavioral science for the players and coaches, S&C, nutrition, and the reestablishment of clear targets for the program. Instead, he's positioned himself, by his own design, into a position which will limit his growth as a head coach. In this sort of scenario, Blake James should have stepped up and stopped it from happening. In fact, it never should have even been an option, but the problem is that the infrastructure isn't in place to prevent this.

It's not about the TRob hire, the Jess Simpson hire, or even Manny making the absurd move to resume play-calling duties. It's not about Manny putting his *** on the line by calling the defense, or trying to get rid of Manny or Blake. It's about whether UM has organized itself, created the right infrastructure, implemented the right processes, set the right targets, to maximize its potential as a program. That's what good programs, businesses, do to create success.
Submit this to a miami newspaper. See if they'll print it.
 
There isn't a blank check like state run schools or large private institutions. In the Final AP 25 only 5 private schools are ranked: Notre Dame, BYU, Northwestern, Miami and Liberty. Of the 5 ranked: Notre Dame has it's own Athletic budget funded in great part by its TV contract & an endowment fund that would make all of us extremely wealthy! BYU has all the Mormon money behind it yet only occasionally has a top team. Northwestern & Miami both have limited budgets and Liberty is a freak. Hugh Freeze offense at Liberty was too much for Coastal Carolina in his 2nd year - but he did lose to NC State...1 year is not a program especially given Covid player availability. Coastal Carolina? Beat BYU and lost to Liberty.....crazy season but look where the budgets are. As a small school, which just had a financially difficult football season (& other sports affecting the AD budget) perhaps there was only so much money available THIS year. Miami has shown over the past several years post Donna Shalloser that it will spend $$ to rebuild the program. I expect that will continue after the 2020/21 budget year comes back to some normalcy.

You inadvertently proved the point that every makes. If Liberty can do it, why can’t Miami? All it takes is hiring the right coach, which Miami has proven it can’t do.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top