South Florida '19- The QBs

DMoney

D-Moni
Staff member
Joined
Oct 13, 2011
Messages
11,024
#1
Over the past decade, we’ve seen a steady stream of superstar college QBs from South Florida. Lamar Jackson, Geno Smith, Teddy Bridgewater, Shoelace Robinson, Winky Flowers and others have put up big numbers and won games for their programs.

Although I expect that trend to continue, this class is a bit of a step back. There are good players, but not too many Power 5-caliber playmakers. With that said, it’s easy to envision some of these guys putting up numbers in the right system.

* means verified numbers

Nik Scalzo- 5’10, 179, 4.84* (Cardinal Gibbons)- The Johnny Manziel of Broward County. Instinctive playmaker who put up numbers in an Air-Raid offense (2,065 yards, 23 TDs, 6 INTs). Lit up American Heritage’s star-studded defense. Elite field vision. Average arm strength but very accurate. Athletic. Put on a show at the Opening catching passes while doing backflips. Smart player with Ivy League offers. Kentucky commit.



Gio Richardson- 6’1, 195, 4.67* (Oxbridge)- FAU commit and the top QB in Palm Beach County. Threw for 1,593 yards and 24 touchdowns while rushing for 495 yards and another nine scores. Played well in state title game against Chaminade. Strong runner who excels on vertical throws. Can drop the ball in a bucket.



Mariano Valenti – 6’0, 211* (St. Thomas)- High upside prospect who flashed the most arm strength at the Miami Opening. Transfer from Michigan. Sneaky athlete who likes to improvise. Similar build to Matt Stafford. Will compete with Curt Casteel for starting job. Northern Illinois commit.

Mariano Valenti HL

Isaiah Velez- 6’0, 160* (Northwestern)- Smooth pocket passer who models his game after Ken Dorsey. Underrated in my opinion. Always on balance. Transferred from North Miami to compete with better talent. Fringe physical tools but excellent accuracy. Turned heads at the LSU camp. Has some FCS offers but should get FBS interest with a big season.

Velez HL (North Miami)

T.J. Smith- 6’1, 179* (McArthur)- South Broward transfer who was arguably the most consistent passer on the local camp circuit. Good velocity and above-average placement. Freakish 10.63 inch hands. USF offer.

TJ Smith HL

Curt Casteel- 6’2, 200, 4.84* (St. Thomas)- Polished QB that struggled as a junior. Shared snaps with 2020 LB Derek Wingo. Good size with marginal arm strength. Will battle with Mariano Valenti for the Raiders’ starting job. Harvard commit.

Curt Casteel HL

Daniel Richardson- 5’9, 190* (Carol City)- One of the most prolific, but mistake prone, QBs in South Florida history. Started since his freshman year at Booker T (including state title in 2015) but will spend his senior year with Carol City. Built like a RB. Pass-first spread QB with similar arm talent to Treon Harris. On pace to challenge several Dade County records.

Daniel Richardson HL (Sophomore)

Cariq Rackley
- 6’, 165 (Palmetto)- Precise and productive (21 TDs, 7 INTs). Led the resurgent Panthers to an 8-2 record. Excels on back-shoulder throws. Not a physical presence. Made his name as a standout freshman at Killian. UAB offer.

Cariq Rackley HL

Kamran Kadivar- 6’0, 190 (Pinecrest)- Small school prospect with intriguing arm strength. Ball jumps out of his hand. Solid athlete who can throw on the move and from odd angles.

Kamran Kandivar HL

Maurice Underwood- 6’3, 158, 4.86* (Central)- Tall athlete whose game is still catching up to his tools. Has some arm strength. Needs consistency-- Central often functioned better with Wildcat QB. Marshall commit.

Maurice Underwood HL

Jesse Rivera- 6'3, 190 (Western)- Tall, pro-style passer who transferred from Archbishop McCarthy. Will be interesting to watch how he progresses with better talent around him. Ivy league offers.

Jesse Rivera HL
 
Last edited:

TC7D

2000 Cane
Joined
Jan 28, 2015
Messages
1,532
#2
No wonder we went all the way to Oregon to find a QB
 

brock

All-American
Joined
Dec 4, 2011
Messages
21,566
#3
Definitely a down year but one of these guys I’m sure will end up a stud in college. Always seem to happen
 
Joined
May 2, 2018
Messages
250
#4
Ima go with Scalzo kid is a baller! Ya hes undersized but his command and leadership are p5 kid is a football player!!
 
Joined
Sep 3, 2016
Messages
2,023
#5
Meh
 
Joined
May 13, 2018
Messages
236
#6
Take that Scalzo kid, just in case we make it to the National championship game against Georgia and we’re down 23-20 in overtime, short QBs are their Achilles heel.
 
Joined
Dec 11, 2012
Messages
625
#7
Why is the whole crop so short outside of Underwood? He will probably go all Rakeem Cato at Marshall.....
 

DB4

Freshman
Joined
Jun 5, 2017
Messages
885
#8
I liked what I saw of the Velez kid in his highlights against Atlantic. I actually think if he stayed at North Miami they’d have a chance to make noise in 8A region 4.

I’ve seen a fair amount of TJ Smith recently and I don’t think he has it to be an elite QB. I can see him at a group of 5 school but there’s a lot he has to do to even get that.

Definitely no Miami caliber QBs in the list. Maybe Scalzo if they badly want a QB for this cycle
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
1,774
#9
I’ve seen a fair amount of TJ Smith recently and I don’t think he has it to be an elite QB. I can see him at a group of 5 school
I think "elite qb" came and went a long time ago if No MJJ for this cycle...So if you have a kid that can play power 5 locally, may take him...If a backup doesn't know soon, I'd offer Richardson/one of the STA kids/TJ Smith, and then make it the #1 need for next year, sending out about 8-10 serious offers instead 3-4 (2-3 of which we had no shot), and take 2 if 2 want to come, but def get 1.
 

Drewny1

Redshirt Freshman
Joined
May 4, 2017
Messages
1,717
#10
Out of all the 7on7 and the camps that are played in the Tri-County. This is the best when it comes to QBs? That's pathetic
 
Joined
Jun 28, 2018
Messages
26
#11
The Scalzo kid looked pretty good in my opinion. Solid arm, good accuracy. Moved his feet well. I wouldn't hate if he got an offer if MJJ does indeed fall through. They should be having a long look since Bogle is there.
 
Joined
Jun 7, 2018
Messages
327
#12
So this won’t be a class we look back and ask “why didn’t we recruit___?”
 
Joined
Dec 13, 2015
Messages
9,771
#17
Anybody negging anyone who’s saying we should get Scalzo doesn’t know **** about football and should quit watching all together. If he was 6’3, he’ll be considered a top 75 prospect and you’ll be begging Mark Richt to pursue him the way y’all are begging for Tai.
 
Joined
Feb 7, 2018
Messages
937
#18
Anybody negging anyone who’s saying we should get Scalzo doesn’t know **** about football and should quit watching all together. If he was 6’3, he’ll be considered a top 75 prospect and you’ll be begging Mark Richt to pursue him the way y’all are begging for Tai.
I’m more concerned about his lack of arm strength than his size.
 
Joined
Dec 13, 2015
Messages
9,771
#19
I’m more concerned about his lack of arm strength than his size.
lol, guy chucked a ball 50 yards with zip on it and you’re worried about arm strength? Ever heard of a kid named Todd Reesing? Go take a look.
 
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
1,849
#20
I mean, I think we all (those of us who aren't fortunate/degenerate enough to get to watch a lot of SF HS football) scoff at this list because we don't see the prototypical 6'3"-6'5" guys weighing 225, but that's never really going to be the SF QB scene. We've also seen that you don't need to be 6'5" to be a great college QB. We also shouldn't be worrying, at this point, and when recruiting players, about being QBU. It's pretty evident that championship caliber QB's in CFB and championship caliber QB's in the NFL are not the same guys, for the most part. This is one position where I could not care much less if we don't churn out NFL all-pro's as long as we're in the CFBP every year, and you could make the case you are less likely to do one, if you are doing the other.

If we have an open mind, who knows, one of these guys could be worth a look. Especially if they have the athletic ability to transition to another position such as RB or WR if it doesn't work out for them at QB1. We've definitely missed out before by turning our noses up at local QB talent for "more highly regarded" players, and then regretted it later.
 
Top