Sean Taylor or Ed Reed

[Drewny1]

If he were just coming out of college today, probably. If he were still in the league now from when he entered, he'd eventually shift down to $backer at some point and be dominant there.

You think ST would still be in the league if he was still alive?

 

[dskilz3]

I'm just thankful that we didn't have to choose between the two, we had em both!

 

[Ohio_Cane]

Ed would tell you the answer is Sean. Sean would tell you the answer is Sean.

RIP, 26...

 

[JD08]

I was afraid this thread was gonna be like Ginger or Mary Ann.

 

[TreOFive]

that is like being asked to choose the best between these fine specimens...

you really cant go wrong when you have two HOF caliber choices

 

[kendallcanes]

Ed Reed coaches up his team and leads them to championships. He is one of the smartest players to ever suit up.

Ed Reed would start as FS over ST every time, which is fine because ST can play about 5 other positions at All-American/All-Pro level.

 

[bshaw28]

Sean Taylor

- Ed Reed was 24 years old his Rookie year
- Sean Taylor was 24 years old when he died

It's a projection, but ST might not have even been in his prime yet. Can't answer wrong either way though.

 

[SWFLHurricane]

I think Sean would've had to get outta Washington eventually....Ed was in a much better run organization with the Ravens....