Who has Dumph ever recruited? Blades was a lay down...so was Bandy. Banda was the main guy for Gil and Ivey. Dumph hasn’t won one major recruiting battle in his career.
It’s hard to argue he’s a good coach either when the CBs are being burned by walk ons from Wisky and scrubs from Duke/GTech. Jackson is the lone bright spot of his coaching career at UM. A guy he didn’t recruit though. Colbert is a FS in the NFL.
Banda has recruited Gil, Ivey, Carter, and Hall. He’s got the 2nd highest rated player in the class, Smith coming in.
I also don’t think anyone would argue that Johnson and Redwine have consistently at least met if not exceeded expectations as 3/4 star guys on the field.
The other guys like Smith and Finley recruited for S are now filling another position on the field. You can say what you will. However, the lack of depth and experience at CB almost forced Diaz to implement the striker role vs using more Nickel packages. Dumph needs to go.