forums

Rosier in midseason form

Advertisement
calinative umstudent said:
I don't think it's easy simply because I think Richt is going with Rosier for no reason other than age and the fact he started last season. No joke that is honestly the only reason I think Rosier is starting - because he's a RS SR and the others are freshman.
Click to expand...

We all want one of the others to be better, but what makes you think you know who's done what and what's going on inside Richt's head?
 
DemCanesByke said:
I agree to some extent but here is the problem. We have seen other videos of him doing the same thing in the spring. We have also seen him do that in games.
Click to expand...

You can agree or disagree, the point was that the guy that put out the tweet says it’s not a big deal, that It was his first practice throw. But yet we have now and 11 pages blowing this up.

Typical CIS overreaction by a bunch of sky is falling hormonal females.

The only thing that counts is how the rest of the practices go - we’re talking literally hundreds if not thousands of throws, and then the season.

And there’s actually still a quarterback competition no matter what Rich says. If somebody blows Malik out of the water in terms of camp performance, overtakes him, then that’s that.

All of the other quarterbacks have a chance to unseat this “inaccurate” QB...if they can’t, if they can’t learn a basic offense, read a basic defense, learn how to make the right decisions, and outperform an “inaccurate” quarterback, then that’s on them.
 
Practices just started and some in here are already in mid-season form.

So happy the off-season is over! Moar!
 
OriginalCanesCanesCanes said:
You can agree or disagree, the point was that the guy that put out the tweet says it’s not a big deal, that It was his first practice throw. But yet we have now and 11 pages blowing this up.

Typical CIS overreaction by a bunch of sky is falling hormonal females.

The only thing that counts is how the rest of the practices go - we’re talking literally hundreds if not thousands of throws, and then the season.

And there’s actually still a quarterback competition no matter what Rich says. If somebody blows Malik out of the water in terms of camp performance, overtakes him, then that’s that.

All of the other quarterbacks have a chance to unseat this “inaccurate” QB...if they can’t, if they can’t learn a basic offense, read a basic defense, learn how to make the right decisions, and outperform an “inaccurate” quarterback, then that’s on them.
Click to expand...

stop making excuses

how is that a difficult throw with no one around you but air for a division 1 quarterback
 
paksat said:
stop making excuses

how is that a difficult throw with no one around you but air for a division 1 quarterback
Click to expand...

I didn’t make one single excuse for this one throw, or any throws.

Not one.

I said that the baby ***** on this site love to overreact and bltch like hormonal menstruating teenage girls.

That’s an observation not an excuse.

I also stated there’s a whole month of practice to go. That’s not an excuse either.

But you silly ***** aren’t happy unless eveyone is shrieking like hysterical females like yourselves. I’m just not built that way. Most sane men aren’t.

I don’t need to make excuses for Rosier...he is what he is. Either the backups are ready to be better than him...or not.

Either he’ll improve, regress, or stay the same.

Agonizing and constantly bltching about it like over-emotional drama queens on a message board won’t change a fūcking thing. Other than pointing out who the over-emotional retards are.

See there, not a single excuse for Malik’s shltty throws.
 
Malik is good enough to get us by LSU, after that you can bet on seeing the young guys play the next couple of games. There is nothin wrong with that lol
 
Advertisement
What’s worse, overreacting to the clip (which I admit it is) or comparing it to ******* Aaron Rodgers or Brady missing a pass in practice. Jesus Christ

If Rosier didn’t **** the bed down the stretch then no one, including me, would care about it

But he did, and so here we are. He’s going to be scrutinized because he has a championship level team around him on offense, no one is attacking him personally

Get a grip
 
So when does Malik get benched and who replaces him?

Sorry, couldn’t help myself.
 
DTP said:
If only the offensive line would have blocked better on that practice rep, he would have hit the receiver in the numbers.

In all seriousness, nobody should be surprised to see this sort of thing. Inaccurate passers don't just all of the sudden become accurate. We are still going to see our share of frustratingly inaccurate passes but it doesn't mean the offense can't be successful. There's plenty that can be done to mask these issues. I'd love for Richt to employ some of Sonny Cumbie's tactics with Rosier. TCU played with Kenny Hill as their starter last year, a player markedly similar to Malik Rosier from their height, their build, their athletic ability and their poor throwing mechanics that lead to inaccurate passes. Instead of asking Hill to complete too many of the standard route tree passes, Cumbie ran a ridiculous amount of screen passes. Bubbles, middle screens, WR screens, RB screens, motion swing passes and a ton of shovel option stuff. They ran a ton of zone read stuff and a bunch of designed QB draws. The TCU offense averaged over 33ppg and 420 ypg of offense with very little star talent at the skill positions.

Now Hill is a better pure passer than Rosier but he was still flawed in that department. He went from 61% with a 17/13 TD INT ratio in 2016 to 67% 23/8 as a senior in 2017.
Click to expand...

Completely agree. There are ways to “hide” Rosier’s lack of talent. Shoot, the Jags did the same thing with Bortles here in the NFL and made it to the AFC Championship game. Meaning....it can be done, especially with a power rushing attack that grinds up yardage and forces defenses out of their comfort zones. If I was Richt, what you pointed out TCU wise is something I’d employ as well - and it gets our playmakers into space which will allow them room to do their thang
 
OriginalCanesCanesCanes said:
You can agree or disagree, the point was that the guy that put out the tweet says it’s not a big deal, that It was his first practice throw. But yet we have now and 11 pages blowing this up.

Typical CIS overreaction by a bunch of sky is falling hormonal females.

The only thing that counts is how the rest of the practices go - we’re talking literally hundreds if not thousands of throws, and then the season.

And there’s actually still a quarterback competition no matter what Rich says. If somebody blows Malik out of the water in terms of camp performance, overtakes him, then that’s that.

All of the other quarterbacks have a chance to unseat this “inaccurate” QB...if they can’t, if they can’t learn a basic offense, read a basic defense, learn how to make the right decisions, and outperform an “inaccurate” quarterback, then that’s on them.
Click to expand...
Great points...in your honest opinion, do you think that maybe CMR is being stubborn. Maybe others are outperforming him in practice but CMR is sticking with the guy whose most familiar with his system. As much as i bash #12, i do feel that he should start vs LSU w/out a doubt. The issue would be, if he struggles does CMR pull the trigger or not. I don't think he does and #12 remains the starter throughout the season, that makes this issue and cause for concern alarming.
 
Advertisement
CanesTruth said:
Great points...in your honest opinion, do you think that maybe CMR is being stubborn. Maybe others are outperforming him in practice but CMR is sticking with the guy whose most familiar with his system. As much as i bash #12, i do feel that he should start vs LSU w/out a doubt. The issue would be, if he struggles does CMR pull the trigger or not. I don't think he does and #12 remains the starter throughout the season, that makes this issue and cause for concern alarming.
Click to expand...

I have no idea what’s happening in practice other than what is reported here and in the media, they are only allowed to watch limited minutes of practice.

Part of performing as a quarterback is being able to execute the right plays i.e., implement the system, make the right reads, throw to the right receiver, during the game, or scrimmages..

If you’re not making the right reads as a quarterback and making the right throws, you’re not outperforming anybody.

The QB that performs the best overall, which is a combination of physical performance and mental performance,ie, understanding the offense and running it, is the one that plays.

You could have all the talent in the world, but if you’re not making the right reads, you don’t see that safety sliding over, you don’t see that linebacker backing up, you throw to the wrong spot on the field, guess what you have: lots of interceptions and chaos.

You can’t dumb down the offense so much that you turn it into a sandlot game. There has to be a game plan.

Everybody has their shot to complete both in a mental and physical aspect. Why the other guys are not overtaking Rosier, despite some of his limitations, is because they haven’t put it all together YET. Simple as that.

As August progresses, they’ll all get better over time.

Rosier said himself in an interview today that the guy’s behind him were getting better and will soon be ready to take over if they need to (I’m paraphrasing)
 
brock said:
Click to expand...

OriginalCanesCanesCanes said:
I have no idea what’s happening in practice other than what is reported here and in the media, they are only allowed to watch limited minutes of practice.

Part of performing as a quarterback is being able to execute the right plays i.e., implement the system, make the right reads, throw to the right receiver, during the game, or scrimmages..

If you’re not making the right reads as a quarterback and making the right throws, you’re not outperforming anybody.

The QB that performs the best overall, which is a combination of physical performance and mental performance,ie, understanding the offense and running it, is the one that plays.

You could have all the talent in the world, but if you’re not making the right reads, you don’t see that safety sliding over, you don’t see that linebacker backing up, you throw to the wrong spot on the field, guess what you have: lots of interceptions and chaos.

You can’t dumb down the offense so much that you turn it into a sandlot game. There has to be a game plan.

Everybody has their shot to complete both in a mental and physical aspect. Why the other guys are not overtaking Rosier, despite some of his limitations, is because they haven’t put it all together YET. Simple as that.

As August progresses, they’ll all get better over time.

Rosier said himself in an interview today that the guy’s behind him were getting better and will soon be ready to take over if they need to (I’m paraphrasing)
Click to expand...
Thanks for sharing your thoughts..
 
kryptonite said:
No, people don't argue that the playbook is limited because of Rosier, they argue it's because of Richt. Like if somebody called better plays, Rosier and the OL would be more consistent. The problem is that people assume everything else is exactly as they believe it to be and the only reason their brilliant plan isn't being put into action is that Richt just doesn't know enough about football.
Click to expand...

I have seen some make that case and others make the case that it is Rosier that limits Richt from opening the playbook and they get ridiculed. I am only referencing the latter. I don't disagree it may be more that voice the former and my post is really directed to them.
 
Back
Top