That's fine by all normal standards, but I know what I read, I know what I saw, and it wouldn't be the first guy Golden has caused a fall in his draft stock.
You're also comparing Feliciano who was drafted a senior playing 39 starts at LG and 7 at the Tackle spots in his time here (spot duty in his draft notes). At best he was an honorable mention for All ACC. There was consistency at one position over the majority of his time here which is what scouts are going to review. His lack of Athleticism was also noted as a weakness for the draft which became abundantly clear while he was playing tackle.
Compare that to Washington who was a sophomore when he was First team All ACC, on multiple award watch lists and constantly grading out over 90% at guard and then asked to start an entire season at Tackle his Junior year before going pro, a season in which his coach constantly threw him under the bus. To say that the most recent season does not stand out over game tape is a joke as you see how many guys stay an extra year somewhere and freefall in a draft from a bad year.
Again there's what should normally happen (review history/tapes) and then there is what happened here. I even bolded it for you man. Now you got me wasting time proving a point I already provided evidence for. Take it how you want.
Ok, so then what's Washington's problem right now? Is Golden still holding him back from being a stud Guard?
I never said he would be all world in the pros, I just said Golden cost him some draft stock. Even guys who excel in college don't always do well in the pros.
You're right! Robert Gallery is a good example. I get was Machado is saying but there's no way to explain going from All-ACC guard to barely getting drafted. I was a huge fan of Feliciano but he struggled more than Washington at tackle. He had issues false starting at tackle. We can't say if this player was a stud in college then they should be one in the pros. I mean explain to me why Brett Romberg and Honzalez was all-pro players. If that was the case the term bust would not exist. And Tony Rice, Tim Tebow, Yim Couch, Ryan Leaf and Peter Warrick would be stars. A player can be good in college but bad in the pros, however a player can't be bad in college but good in the pros.
Feliciano was wayyyy better at Tackle than Washington. He was one of Miami's highest grading lineman during his tenure at Miami. Only OL that graded higher on a regular basis was Linder.
And everybody false started at RT here. It was due to the silent count. False starting isn't "struggling" at playing a position.
Please provide a link to their grades.
In no way am I saying Washington is all world or is or would have been a superstar in NFL. I'm saying Washington was pretty **** good in college despite people forgetting that. He had flaws, no doubt. He was definitely not a tackle, but the kid had some hype and was hurt by moving to tackle whether you believe it or not.
I didn't even talk about false starting. I was more referring to the fact that in the previous post I made where it's stated that he was continuously beat by more athletic DE and it's off a small sample size.
Here's a few more snippets for you prior to the draft.
Brandon Washington*, G/OT, Miami
Height: 6-4. Weight: 320.
Projected 40 Time: 5.21.
Projected Round (2012): 4-5.
12/13/11: After being an All-ACC pick last year at guard, Miami moved Washington to left tackle after Seantrel Henderson was injured. Washington had a mixed season at left tackle. He did a quality job of run blocking for Hurricanes running back Lamar Miller. Washington has a nice combination of power and mobility, but belongs on the inside. Head coach Al Golden was openly critical of Washington after he struggled against North Carolina and defensive end Quinton Coples. Washington took offense at his coaches' criticism, but remained the starter at left tackle. He has some talent, and his situation at Miami looks murky. Washington should return to school.
8/17/10:
Brandon Washington has the size and athleticism to be a starting guard in the NFL. He is a pretty good pass blocker and packs a nice punch as a run blocker. Washington plays with a mean streak and was twice named the ACC Offensive Lineman of the Week in his first year as a starter. He was an All-ACC first-team guard last season.
Here's another one:
At Miami (FL) -- (Official School Bio)
2011: Started all 12 games of the season for the Hurricanes...
Made the shift from left guard to left tackle for his junior campaign... Finished the year with an overall grade of 86 percent... Made only five mental errors over the course of the season, and registered only three penalties against. 2010: One of three offensive linemen to start all 13 games... Second on the team with 56 pancake blocks, and 11 lumberjack blocks...
Graded out at 99 percent against Pittsburgh, the highest grade of any starter all season... Graded out at 95 percent against Virginia Tech... Earned ACC Offensive Lineman of the Week honors after Virginia Tech (loss) and Duke (win) games...
Leader of Miami offensive line that earned more weekly honors than any school in the league during the 2010 season. 2009: Played in all 13 games mainly on the place-kicking unit, but made first career start at left guard against USF while playing 53 snaps and grading out at 90 percent with five pancake blocks.
From Mel Kiper:
Kiper
One of the best drafts in terms of lining up needs and getting guys at spots where I didn't think they'd still be around. They moved up to get Fletcher Cox, an immediate starter. Mychal Kendricks is a perfect fit, and at No. 46, a really good value. The Eagles look a lot better up the middle after this weekend. If Vinny Curry came off the board really early in the second round, nobody would have been surprised, so to get him at No. 59 is a steal. Nick Foles has the upside of an NFL starter, and Andy Reid could turn him into something. Brandon Boykin is my No. 9-ranked corner, so I love the value as a fourth-rounder. I thought they might get a tackle earlier, but it's hard to quibble given the value they got with every pick early on. I love this draft, and Bryce Brown will be an interesting story if he sticks.
Keep an eye on Brandon Washington, a sixth-rounder with the upside of a starter at guard.
Needs - A, Value - A-, Overall - A
From Football Nation:
Eagles selected Brandon Washington, G, Miami, 200th overall (from Patriots)
Wow! This guy was a freak in college. Washington has very good speed for a OL and understands blocking assignments very well. He also has pretty good size and strength. If given time to develop and transition to the pro-level, Washington should become an all-pro G. Not to mention, he never missed a game and even filled in at RT sometimes.
Grade for this pick - B
For those with revisionist history that forgot the hype people had on Washington back then, here are a few other forums to see fan reactions at that time.
NFL Forum :: - Brandon Washington G/T Miami
Eagles draft Brandon Washington, OG, Miami - 6th rd, 200 overall
Macho you want it, go ahead. I'm done with it. You're right. Golden has never cost a player draft stock. Washington was obviously a bum in college.