Talent wise and most consistent- kaaya #1 by far
Berlin- beat the rivals ALOT so it matters a good bit.
The 4th quarters vs UF in 03 and FSU in 04 don't happen with KaayaIn all fairness, with Kaaya against UF we probably wouldn't have been digging out of a hole. Berlin was putrid for 2.5 quarters. The comeback was amazing, but let's not forget why we were in that hole to begin with.Kaaya wouldve put us in a whole that he, unlike Berlin, wouldnt have been able to dig us out of.That's such crap. You people are mad at Kaaya for not winning those big games with Golden specials while comparing him to QB's using some of the best teams of all-time. 2003 had Hall of Fame talent on it. Kaaya throwing 405 yards vs FSU was the only reason we were in that game at the end. He even got us the lead in the 4th just for it to get blown. This year Kaaya was great until getting his molar knocked out and still threw a game tying touchdown at the end.