LOL. PLzwork4 You did not read my post. My point is - regardless of all the explanations and excuses you guys come up with - Perry's stats are better than Jack's. And, this society has a habit of looking at what you did in the past in order to project how you will do in the future. For example, your high school grades determined if and where you could go to college, and whether you would be an honor student, etc.. Your high school stats as an athlete determine if and at what level you'll be able to play sports. And I've already said, coaches like colleges evaluate more than stats. But again, and hopefully for the final time, Perry's stats are better than Capt. Jack's and it's not even close.
Again, there are a lot of factors that go into projecting QB play and competition and the skill level of teammates does play a part in any analysis. Having said, that coaches are still going to look at a QB who threw 14 INTs differently than one who only threw 2. How many INTs are you realistically blaming the receivers for? What was causing Jack to throw INTs if not his own decision making? The numbers in that regard are not even close. As I said, what will matter most is how they perform once they are both at UM. What they did in high school won't matter because that was just their ticket to this stage, but thinking that QB stats don't matter doesn't make sense. They do matter. They aren't all you look at, but they do matter.
Nope. No no no.
High school stats absolutely do not matter now that the kid is on the team. The only thing that matters is how they perform on Greentree at this point. I could see Richt "Well Jack sure does look good right now, but **** those 14 picks he threw in high school really worries me. Perry only threw a couple." The best QB wins the job...no one cares about what either QB did in high school, especially with a million variables in play regarding high school stats.
What the ****? You talk about stats determine where you will go to college...Jack is already in college. That's in the past. Obviously the staff saw enough in him (even with the 14 picks) to determine he was worthy of a scholly. From here on out...high school stats mean absolutely nothing. No one gives a **** how well someone has done in high school. If that were the case we would have a statue of Kyle Wright in front of the school instead of him taking the brunt of 99% of our jokes. Get over it...high school stats mean next to nothing over their evaluations. You are reaching in the worst kinda way.
Production ALWAYS matters.
Guys who can...DO
Guys who can't...DON'T
There are always extenuating circumstances for particular cases, but generally, guys who are productive at each level, continue to be productive. Projecting is certainly apart of evaluation, but I'm almost always going to lean towards a kid who has the resume to back up his skills and traits.
Especially at a position like QB. This isn't moving a linebacker to end because his speed may translate off the edge. We're talking about reading defenses, ball placement, accuracy, and arm strength.
Once the guys are on a practice field, the coaches will decide who is prepared to compete at a championship level, but for purposes of prognostication, I'd almost always lean towards N'Kosi because of the combination of skills and production. Those types of players have better odds at being successful.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
