forums

Mensah better than Carr

theuksu

theuksu

Redshirt Freshman
Joined
Jun 15, 2012
Messages
301
Just heard another analyst hyping up CJ Carr. Mensah is a better QB, IMO. And maybe I need to take off my orange and green shades but position by position Miami has a better team.

QB - edge Miami
RB - edge Miami
WR - edge Miami
TE - even (no proven starter on either team)
OL - even (both teams have to fill holes)
DL - edge Miami
LB - edge ND
CB - edge Miami --- Leonard Moore is great player. I'd love to see @Lance Roffers breakdown his game compared to Xavier Lucas'. Overall we have a better starting unit.
S - - slight edge Miami ----Shuler is a better S than Poyser. But if Fitzgerald can add some weight during the offseason he's the best S on either team.

Curious to hear others thoughts?
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
3FW said:
Moore is better than Lucas. Rare skills. Lucas is a very good CB, I think OJ is better. Moore though is a top 5 pick type CB.
Click to expand...
Moore is a great CB, the only way u can really attack him is in the run game. But as a CB u take the elite coverage skills all day. Lucas is pretty good in the run game and a great tackler.
 
theuksu said:
Just heard another analyst hyping up CJ Carr. Mensah is a better QB, IMO. And maybe I need to take off my orange and green shades but position by position Miami has a better team.

QB - edge Miami
RB - edge Miami
WR - edge Miami
TE - even (no proven starter on either team)
OL - even (both teams have to fill holes)
DL - edge Miami
LB - edge ND
CB - edge Miami --- Leonard Moore is great player. I'd love to see @Lance Roffers breakdown his game compared to Xavier Lucas'. Overall we have a better starting unit.
S - - slight edge Miami ----Shuler is a better S than Poyser. But if Fitzgerald can add some weight during the offseason he's the best S on either team.

Curious to hear others thoughts?
Click to expand...
U think Shuler is better than Poyser? There pretty wash, i don’t know how u can say one is better than the other. Maybe PFF grades say otherwise. I don’t have access to those.
 
theuksu said:
Just heard another analyst hyping up CJ Carr. Mensah is a better QB, IMO. And maybe I need to take off my orange and green shades but position by position Miami has a better team.

QB - edge Miami
RB - edge Miami
WR - edge Miami
TE - even (no proven starter on either team)
OL - even (both teams have to fill holes)
DL - edge Miami
LB - edge ND
CB - edge Miami --- Leonard Moore is great player. I'd love to see @Lance Roffers breakdown his game compared to Xavier Lucas'. Overall we have a better starting unit.
S - - slight edge Miami ----Shuler is a better S than Poyser. But if Fitzgerald can add some weight during the offseason he's the best S on either team.

Curious to hear others thoughts?
Click to expand...

Media wants to gas up Carr because he plays for ND. I see a lot of similarity at this point between Carr and TVD. Racked up gaudy stats on mostly garbage defenses
In year 1. in year 2, good defenses will have plenty of film and know how to make him nervous in the pocket.
 
I would love for us to make up for that trash game we lost to them in Chicago....I think we lost 41-7. B. Kelly vs. A. Golden in 2013 I think.
 
Back
Top