Malik vs Kayaa

[brock]

Kaaya underthrows that throw with Thomas.

 

[OldhamA]

Kaaya is more talented, but Rosier is a winner....

I will take the winner, Rosier.

I'd actually say that Rosier is more talented. Kaaya is more refined.

 

[Ivan The Terrible]

Kayaa does not have the arm strength Rosier does. Also Kayaa never had a good O-line to protect him.

 

[AUcane]

Kayaa was maddening to watch but in defense of him, his OL were not good, his OC was not good and his HC was not good. That said, if kayaa plays this year, we’d be 5-2 now.

 

[brock]

Kayaa was maddening to watch but in defense of him, his OL were not good, his OC was not good and his HC was not good. That said, if kayaa plays this year, we’d be 5-2 now.

Agree and I’m a kaaya fan, it is what it is. Rosier is built different. He’s a work in progress but he’s proven he’s our qb

 

[jkaz1]

Rosier is undefeated after 7 games. Kaaya never was. Rosier beat FSU (albeit an awful FSU team). Kaaya never did.

Winning is the #1 measure of a QB.

Who do you think is better and what would our records be right now if kaaya was qb ?

 

[ShadowSpring]

Malik played one of his worse games thus far and still had over 350 yds and 3 TD's. Kaaya only did that a few times in his career.

I'll take Malik.

 

[Doppelganger]

I'd actually say that Rosier is more talented. Kaaya is more refined.

Rosier is very average talent wise.

Kaaya has better arm talent and is more accurate.

 

[Doppelganger]

Kayaa does not have the arm strength Rosier does.

Huh?

 

[Doppelganger]

Rosier is undefeated after 7 games. Kaaya never was. Rosier beat FSU (albeit an awful FSU team). Kaaya never did.

Winning is the #1 measure of a QB.

Rosier "won" the Duke game in 2015. That was one of the greatest flukes of all-time.

It was won because of something that had nothing to do with Rosier.

Kaaya also led us down for a score against FSU that could've led to a win.

But the PAT was blocked.

Again, nothing to do with the QB.

 

[snipergang]

Rosier is undefeated after 7 games. Kaaya never was. Rosier beat FSU (albeit an awful FSU team). Kaaya never did.

Winning is the #1 measure of a QB.

Rosier "won" the Duke game in 2015. That was one of the greatest flukes of all-time.

It was won because of something that had nothing to do with Rosier.

Kaaya also led us down for a score against FSU that could've led to a win.

But the PAT was blocked.

Again, nothing to do with the QB.

Kayaa was not a leader in any way , I'll take Roiser all day

 

[snipergang]

Rosier is undefeated after 7 games. Kaaya never was. Rosier beat FSU (albeit an awful FSU team). Kaaya never did.

Winning is the #1 measure of a QB.

Rosier "won" the Duke game in 2015. That was one of the greatest flukes of all-time.

It was won because of something that had nothing to do with Rosier.

Kaaya also led us down for a score against FSU that could've led to a win.

But the PAT was blocked.

Again, nothing to do with the QB.

did you ever see kaaya talking to his team getting them hype ? or kaaya at doak telling the crowed to get up and then have a game winning drive ?!?!... tell me some great stories of kaaya having a game winning drive and kaaya being a leader?

Malik walked out to the field vs GT before the last drive and spoke to the Defense : Leader , never seen kaaya do anything close to that besides studder in his interviews

 

[CaneSince4Ever]

Kaaya also led us down for a score against FSU that could've led to a win.

But the PAT was blocked.

He threw the almost game tying TD, but He didn't lead us down the field...Berrios got most of the yards on that possession on His long punt return.

 

[CaneSince4Ever]

While Rosier is more mobile than Kaaya, their lack of improvisational skills are about the same.

 

[Doppelganger]

Kayaa was not a leader in any way , I'll take Roiser all day

Based on what?

This is silly fanboy stuff.

 

[Doppelganger]

did you ever see kaaya talking to his team getting them hype ? or kaaya at doak telling the crowed to get up and then have a game winning drive ?!?!...

This is silly playing the result kind of stuff.

Typical of clueless fans.

 

[canecat]

With kaaya I think that the games would be more of a blowout against inferior teams. with rosier we are going to be close with every team.

But with kaaya we lose close games and rosier will win them.

Also kaaya is a ****ing statue and it made me want to hang myself

This is the truth. We lose to FSU and GT with Kaaya. He didn't have that ice water pumping like Rosier . kaaya was a much better passer but not as good QB.

 

[Doppelganger]

He threw the almost game tying TD, but He didn't lead us down the field...Berrios got most of the yards on that possession on His long punt return.

He threw a dime TD on 4th down against FSU.

The PAT was blocked.

Rosier's a legend and a "leader" yet Kaaya is a bum.

 

[Doppelganger]

This is the truth. We lose to FSU and GT with Kaaya. He didn't have that ice water pumping like Rosier . kaaya was a much better passer but not as good QB.

I love the revisionism.

Despite the fact that Kaaya had beaten GT the previous two years and had great games against FSU, we definitely would have lost with him!

No question!

 

[Doppelganger]

While Rosier is more mobile than Kaaya, their lack of improvisational skills are about the same.

True.

Rosier can scramble a lot better than Kaaya obviously but he runs into sacks just about as much.