Is Toney the GOAT UM Freshman?

[Rellyrell]

DUKEEEEEEEE!!! Duke was that dude !!

****; Duke’s first carry was a 50 yrd house call. ****, see how easily we can forget? Duke was absolutely electric.

 

[SlimeyChan]

Duke Johnson

 

[CocaneCowboy27]

Jit is the truth

 

[bacane]

Lot of great freshmen, but Toney is the most impactful to this point. Don’t recall the others impacting games to this degree. He’s the best player on offense & one of top overall.

 

[johnnytsunami01]

I'll never forget Duke's first game against BC, incredible. But based off opportunities and depending on how far this team goes (big we'll see) he has the potential to be #1 by EOY

 

[Sabetta]

He’s not better than Duke Johnson yet

Disagree. I love Duke but we'd be .500 without Toney

 

[JHallCanes]

17 catches
230 yards
3 TDs

Against ND/UiF/FSU (and had that monster TD against FSU called back for bull****)

That puts him over the top for me

 

[SinCityCane]

Yes.

 

[mosthated305]

Why the **** wasnt Thomas trying to block ahead of Toney instead of behind him?

Should have been a TD

 

[Supacane954]

DJ Dallas!

 

[Mr. Dynasty1]

Disagree. I love Duke but we'd be .500 without Toney

Impactful doesn’t equal better. I get The recency bias tho

 

[Supacane954]

Lamar miller!

 

[dorsey1]

Toney best freshman in Miami history-He does it all.

I’ve seen them all-This kid is just different-

He’s the best freshman WR in the country and he’s our best player without a doubt.

 

[TemplarCane]

Hard not to put Toney in as the GOAT TF since he's making most of the big plays and the team's best playmaker.

 

[Dghustla]

Duke and then Toney it’s really close. But that’s the list.

 

[SinCityCane]

Why the **** wasnt Thomas trying to block ahead of Toney instead of behind him?

Should have been a TD

Even if he'd just gotten out of the way Malachi scores.

 

[PimpCane]

Idk about all time but since 2000 it's between Duke and Mali. Too early to call it tho, we'll see how Mali finishes the season.

 

[90scane]

Why the **** wasnt Thomas trying to block ahead of Toney instead of behind him?

Should have been a TD

Twice

 

[BALLHAWKU]

He’s not better than Duke Johnson yet

I disagree

 

[BALLHAWKU]

Lot of great freshmen, but Toney is the most impactful to this point. Don’t recall the others impacting games to this degree. He’s the best player on offense & one of top overall.

I agree