I understand that our Qb talent might not be the best. I understand that we seem to have a helluva defense. I understand that we might still have some work to do on the Oline. But I am not so sure that I can accept that out of these Qbs, all with different skill sets, some who have been in this system for more than a year, that not one of them can put together anything resembling competent Qb play. I am starting to wonder if we have a case of another coach married to a system that simply doesn't fit his talent.
Even under Kaya, A Qb who claimed/seemed to have fully grasped the system, this system was never really that good. Last year, the offense looked very boring at the start against bad teams. Then very bad during the middle against good teams. And then good enough at the end against OK teams. Things seemed to only click when everything was absolutely perfect. I don't know enough about schemes and sets to be able to diagnose what's going on, but I know a pattern when I see one, and I don't believe in coincidences.
It was noted in another thread that Perry has been running something similar to Richt's system for awhile now. Perhaps that is why Richt is so in love with him. However, if Perry gets here and has the same struggles that EVERY other Qb has had, I'm calling bullcrap on, "we don't have talent at QB."
This is the crux of your confusion. You don't know what you're looking at and take a simplistic approach to analyzing a complex problem.
Saying you understand we "still have work to do on the oline"(which is a constant with all QBs/Offensive execution) and a "helluva defense", then not being able to "accept" why none of the QBs can put together "competent" play is counter-logic.
Richt is a proven QBs coach, OC, & HC in college football. The longer he delays putting his proven system in place (for the lack of ability among position groups), the longer he puts the entire offensive unit & team behind in development & success. Kaaya's mental grasp of the system is irrelevant for the reasons stated above, as well as the need for talent (speed) from skill players.
It was a transition year where we won 9 games playing inconsistently, in a new system with pieces that didn't fit. Offense is different than defense in rhythm, timing, and execution; you can't put your best 11 out there, line em up, simplify the reads, and tell them play fast.
You have to give this thing some time.. We will have better tempo and score this season but the accuracy from QBs isn't a system problem, it's a talent problem.