What exactly is dumb about my argument?
You guys are the ones making logical fallacies saying because we have won without an ipf, we Shouldnt get one.
I said the school needs to start spending money on the football program. Is that true? Without a doubt.
I said we have had numerous cancelled and delayed practices. Is that true? Yes.
Also we're already far behind these other big schools, not having an ipf when literally every othet school does, is a major stayement saying we arent as committed.
You're probably the kind of guy that thinks new helmets like revo-speeds are unneccessary. "Well we won national championships with the old school schutt helmets". very similar ideas.
The "we have won without it, so that must mean we don't need it" argument is retarded, not yours. Relax, I'm agreeing with you.
The "we have won without it" argument implies more than what you'r giving credit for.
As I noted in another post, we've long heard about how our good teams from the 80s, 90s and early 2000s would convene on their own for "voluntary" practices and workouts, and they'd hold each other accountable for those workouts. I haven't heard about anything like that for a decade now--so it seems clear that our previous coaching staffs instilled a sense of drive and competition in our players that made them want to push themselves harder than our recent staffs (under Shannon and Golden in particular) have done.
That competitive drive is what's been causing us to lose games over the last decade. Well, that and crappy schemes and crappy game-day coaching. Point is that an IPF isn't going to make a **** bit of difference to our W/L record. It's a bull**** excuse.
Who on God's green earth is arguing that an IPF will make a difference in the W/L column? Let me guess, you are going to follow up with, "herp derp then why does it matter?"
So the argument FOR it is that A) "we're losing practice time," and B) "everyone else has one." But no one knows how much practice time we're actually losing...And no cares or knows why our players aren't taking it upon themselves to make up any practice time lost.
So, yeah, you're right. it's obviously a necessity.
Herp derp indeed.
Honestly...what would you rather spend ~20 mil on...an IPF or a competent coaching staff? An IPF or a top-notch weight room that would rival Bama's? An IPF or put 20 mil toward a long-term plan to build a new stadium?
My point is that there are better, more urgently needed things to spend this money on. If we had a great staff, a great weight room, a great stadium...****, I'd be all for it. But as is, this is a great example of the phrase "putting lipstick on a pig."