I bought into the 'what he did at Temple' hype. I gave him the benefit of the doubt for a few seasons. The team he inherited was not good, by Miami standards. I believed the Shapiro scandal negatively impacted recruiting.
I lost all faith after the blowout loss to Louisville in the 2013 bowl game. All we heard was how the team was hyped to play in a bowl game after two years of sanctions. All the team did was come out and tank once Louisville made a few plays. I would have fired him the day after that game. Not for losing, sadly, I expected to lose, but for being completely man-handled by an average team.