forums

Honest question...

It's maliks attitude answering questions during the press conferences following the 3 loses from last year.he seemed to not care about the way he played.plus he wasn't a fan favorite like Perry or Williams.and you see how fast cane fans turn on a dime.before the season we are winning our 6th.after Perry came in did what he did they were slurping on him now it's fire cmr sit Perry get an oc now or BBB.all this knowing we do not have a certified div 1 qb and oline before the season started.and a coach who doesn't adjust his game plan.
 
Advertisement
caneinorlando said:
This entire QB situation is inexcusable...This is yr 3.....I'll give you yr 1.....and I sorta give you yr 2....But in yr 3 we have
A 5th yr Sr who STILL can't grasp the SIMPLEST of Offenses....
A RS Freshman who runs around thinking his *** is a Gangsta, and won't take his Bow-Legged *** into the Film-room, but sure can study Social Media to no end....
And another QB, who either is smoking a Blunt...or sticking his finger up some Chicas ***, then rubbing his eye....
You cannot make this **** up....FML
Click to expand...
Gotta laugh 'cause I don't want to cry - thus the funny emoji.
 
caneinorlando said:
"Honest Question"....Do I go with
*Pastrami and Baby Swiss on Marbled Rye ...or..
* Roast Beef & Provolone w/ Roasted peppers??......I'm utterly confused...
Click to expand...
Love pastrami but not the swiss. Go for the roast beef.

Did you recall the warehouse district near the OB? My father used to take me to a restaurant right in the middle of it that was about 100 feet long and only about 20 feet wide with a bar half as long as the building. Best pastrami on rye I ever had.
 
What's the point of this thread again? If Rosier sucks because of the play calling it's Richt's fault. If Rosier sucks because he hasn't been developed, it's Richt's fault. If Rosier is only playing because ' sucks worse, it's Richt's fault. If ' is as much of knucklehead as he seems to be, it's Richt's fault for recruiting him. Bottom line is our QB situation is a disaster and it's Richt's fault.
 
I don’t blame Malik he is what he is and probably reached the ceiling on his talent. I do blame Richt and Perry I don’t see our QB’s improving. I see teams with far less talent achieving much more. The offense for the most part is predictable and that’s coaching.
I’m not there at practice or in the locker room but Perry should by now be ourQB but he’s not. Is because he’s not a hard worker doesn’t watch film, can’t read defenses. I don’t know. So I blame coach and Perry for the struggles on offense. We have way to much talent to lose to a Virginia. I will say at this point you play Perry and see if he is the future or not.
 
JHallCanes said:
Highly touted RS Freshman vs lowly recruited 5th Year SR

That’s all.
Click to expand...

if malik had did the crap perry does off the field, he'd be crucified. perry just gets a pass bc hes 19. perry has the tools but he needs to seriously get his bleep together. tired of not holding these kids accountable.
 
lol so now mods give out infractions for "trashing players"....for saying Malik Rosier is ******. How ******* ridiculous.

Malik Rosier, Mahoney, Jahair Jones, Robert Knowles and a few more guys on the team ALL SUCK AT FOOTBALL and should have their scholarships pulled immediately.
 
Lokest said:
People are prepared to roll with the evil they don't know rather than the one they know too well in rosier. Perry somehow turning it around is the only form of optimism one can have going forward this season. Rosier in this offense just ain't it.
Click to expand...
Good point. We KNOW Rosier will be awful. We hope Perry can be less awful.
 
Advertisement
kryptonite said:
One simple answer is that it wasn't cool to hate Richt for most of Rosier's PT.

Another is that, having crowned him, people might be hesitant to say Perry isn't all they hoped.

How about once something is somebody's fault, everything is their fault?
Click to expand...
I predicted Perry was a bust when he couldn't beat out Rosier last year.
 
SmokeyRone said:
I predicted Perry was a bust when he couldn't beat out Rosier last year.
Click to expand...

It made very little sense to think that then. Even now, there's no reason Perry couldn't be great. It doesn't look good right now, but I haven't seen anything unfixable about him.
 
am1640 said:
Who says he's a competent coach when Malik plays? Malik is a below average qb and Richt is a below average play caller. The two things aren't mutually exclusive.

I get that people here try to recreate history but has everyone forgot how stuck in the mud the offense was with Kaaya the first 7.5 games of the season? He studied the playbook. He could read defenses, however that offense was trash against FSU, UNC, VT, and the first half against a terrible ND team. You don't remember Lu breaking down film and salivating about our TE going against FSU's garbage Lbers and S over the middle of the field where they were weakest, only to be disappointed that we didn't try that at all. We literally had dudes with knowledge of the offense tell you Richt changed his philosophy/playcalling the second half of the ND game and that's the only thing that saved the offense and the season from being a disaster.

Most intelligent posters have maintained from the beginning that Richt offense playcaller is a major problem. Three years, three different QBs and offense is still a big problem. We still don't attack the middle of the field with any regularity. We don't get playmakers in space. That doesn't mean Rosier isn't also a bad qb. We literally have a dude on this site who breaks down film of the QBs but I guess he's just biased and against Malik also lmao.

Click to expand...

Thank You! I was to lazy to look for it. I knew @Roman Marciante post would have the answer. Big Ups
 
The Franchise said:
Hoping to get some legit discussion going. It seems like Rick and son really started getting destroyed by us for our offensive failures after Perry took over. Fans are almost exclusively claiming that Perry’s struggles are a result of Rick’s busted offense, lousy play calling, and his son’s incompetence.

Prior to Perry taking over, most fans just talked about how much Malik sucked and how he was killing the offense almost singlehandedly. Malik has played in that same busted offense and failed too.

Why don’t the fans give Malik the same benefit of the doubt that they give Perry? If Rick is killing Perry with his busted offense and play calling, then why does everyone just say Malik sucks and not give him the same explanation for failure that they give Perry?
Click to expand...
Problem with this is they both suck IN THIS SYSTEM. Malik would suck with anyone... Nkosi needs to shorten his drops & stick to quick reads AND the playcalling for this type of quarterback (both are similar)sucks *** as well. This rpo **** is a gimmick & it's used to disguise our flaws on the line as well as our qbs inability to actually throw a football accurately down field. Scrap that crap. Go back to a standard pro set(not variations of it) & allow a qb who has the skill set to utilize our numerous weapons across the field to shine. It's common **** sense.
 
407cane said:
Great post
That's essentially my point with most of my posts,

Whenever someone tries to point this out we are made out to be Rosier fans...

Is richt elite? Idk, prob not. But he didn't win 75% of his games playing the 2nd best QB on his team.. something about Perry is off and richt wouldn't lose games on purpose unless Perry was giving him reason to doubt his ability.

I think we'll see Perry, but I feel like Perry must have not prepped enough for UVA and didn't study enough. He trusts Malik more on the road against a good opponent to settle down the offense. Hardly something that is out of line or ridiculous


The Rosier hate on here is ridiculous. He's a 3 star player that has no business ever taking a snap here. He beat out Allison, Perry, scared off kaaya in his senior year, Weldon, sherrifs, and Williams

Out of 7 QB's he's been the best one. Is that his fault? No. We simply need someone to come and take over the reigns

Dude was clutch and led us to 10 wins for the first time in 15 years. Is he gonna nlow a game or two? Probably but he'll also come up huge out of nowhere and I trust him way more than Perry to finish the year out and roll off some wins

I know some fans are okay with losing to develop Perry but that's ridiculous, we're Miami and those same fans would riot the coach when we lost a game. Every game we should win and even if Rosier plays ****** but pulls out the "W" then that's all that matters and I'm with it
Click to expand...
The problem should be the willingness or stubbornness to lose while in either capacity playing the wrong QB for our team... for anyone that doesnt understand that simply look across the field. Look at WV for instance. Will Grier is the same qb he was at ufag. Hes decent maybe even good but nothing to wow anyone. The difference is a mixture of the system & the fact that hes allowed to utilize kids who are playmakers... we have FAR more playmakers at skill positions on our team who are ALL fed up with being hampered by a qb(that's malik or nkosi)who doesnt have the skill set to get them the ball how necessary. **** really is simple when you have playmakers like this. It really takes an incredible amount of futility on EVERYONES part to make this many studs look hopeless. Take it how yall wanna.
 
Brooklyndee said:
The problem should be the willingness or stubbornness to lose while in either capacity playing the wrong QB for our team... for anyone that doesnt understand that simply look across the field. Look at WV for instance. Will Grier is the same qb he was at ufag. Hes decent maybe even good but nothing to wow anyone. The difference is a mixture of the system & the fact that hes allowed to utilize kids who are playmakers... we have FAR more playmakers at skill positions on our team who are ALL fed up with being hampered by a qb(that's malik or nkosi)who doesnt have the skill set to get them the ball how necessary. **** really is simple when you have playmakers like this. It really takes an incredible amount of futility on EVERYONES part to make this many studs look hopeless. Take it how yall wanna.
Click to expand...

Agree with your points here. If you can share, I would just like to know one thing : has there been any talk up to this point about bringing in an OC after the season?
 
Advertisement
Brooklyndee said:
Problem with this is they both suck IN THIS SYSTEM. Malik would suck with anyone... Nkosi needs to shorten his drops & stick to quick reads AND the playcalling for this type of quarterback (both are similar)sucks *** as well. This rpo **** is a gimmick & it's used to disguise our flaws on the line as well as our qbs inability to actually throw a football accurately down field. Scrap that crap. Go back to a standard pro set(not variations of it) & allow a qb who has the skill set to utilize our numerous weapons across the field to shine. It's common **** sense.
Click to expand...
I've said it a thousand times...Get this RPO tf outta my face.....all of a sudden Pro Style isn't Good enough after 5 (6) NCs.....smh
 
The Franchise said:
I’ve seen both QBs have a pretty terrible completion percentage this season. One gets the excuse that Rick sucks; the other gets no such excuse.
Click to expand...


I get that pople want to believe it's Richt because the offense looks like trash, but if the offenisve line isn't very good then the quarterback better be.

As it stands Malik is horrendously inconsistent and makes it impossible to develop any cohesiveness on offense. Can't blame Richt when guys are wide open and the QB air mails it.

Perry on the other hand has the ability, but clearly hasn't taken his responsibility to the team (or himself) seriously. The starting QB should be buried in the playbook and film. There is no excuse to not be obssessed with your preparation. Anyone making excuses for Perry not preparing like his life depends on it is foolish. If I am the HC and I give a kid a shot to be the man and he acts like he doesn't have to outwork everyone on the team and lead then when he ***** uprepeatedly I set his *** cause he doesn't deserve to be the man.
 
kryptonite said:
It made very little sense to think that then. Even now, there's no reason Perry couldn't be great. It doesn't look good right now, but I haven't seen anything unfixable about him.
Click to expand...
That guy is constantly taking credit for predicting gloomy results. Not that hard when you predict everything and everyone will fail.
 
@Brooklyndee I agree with you but one question in terms of the players vs. plays argument.

Do you think that for Richt to make a change to his offense, he has to first see it not work with a QB he loves who he also deems as ready to play week-in and week-out (maturity, off-field work, etc.), which is clearly not categories Malik or Kosi fit into currently. Richt has a track record of loyalty and some stubbornness too, but I am beginning to wonder if his lack of flexibility is also based on what he deems as having wrong players right now. Not saying he shouldn't change to fit their skill sets, but just wonder your opinion if in his mind this could be the thinking.
 
Back
Top