Is he elite?
forums
Grade This Class
- Thread starter nystateofmind
- Start date
Is he elite?
Advertisement
With as much talent this area has....a B should be a given. That should be avg. with little recruiting. So many quality players you don't have to really go all in. I like the NJ boys, very solid. But if they coaching staff can't develop, they will have to get all elite players. You can't miss on another 5 different makers.
Advertisement
No, he's garbage. Let's tear up his signed LOI.
Dude doesn't know NJ from South Florida and now he wants to weigh in on whether an 18-19 yr old kid is elite? Please, lock the doors and stay inside.
i'll give it a c+ cause we failed at DT, WR, CB, and LB. I'll also say we failed at QB,how in the **** don't you offer one out of q.flowers, sean white, and treon and opportunity to play qb right off the bat. Kaaya is good but he concerns me mobility wise and he is no manning, and rosier, well I will never get that one but o well not our call just hope we win it all next year.
- Joined
- Nov 27, 2012
- Messages
- 1,215
Coaching grades:
Recruiting: B
Offense: C
Defense: F
Overall: D+
Recruiting: B
Offense: C
Defense: F
Overall: D+
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2012
- Messages
- 3,350
C
Advertisement
rudebuddha
Senior
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2012
- Messages
- 2,945
Class is an A.
Top 10 class, filled from top to bottom, with players.
This is the first class I've seen in a long time where it is difficult to find even one commit who is a head scratcher.
Only one might be Rosier, and with him you are talking about a 6'2" 210lb 4.6 dual threat qb who can spin it.
120 some odd D1 programs and we are in the top 10 with this class.
That percentage alone makes the class an "A."
Top 10 class, filled from top to bottom, with players.
This is the first class I've seen in a long time where it is difficult to find even one commit who is a head scratcher.
Only one might be Rosier, and with him you are talking about a 6'2" 210lb 4.6 dual threat qb who can spin it.
120 some odd D1 programs and we are in the top 10 with this class.
That percentage alone makes the class an "A."
Advertisement
You still didn't answer if he's elite though
rudebuddha
Senior
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2012
- Messages
- 2,945
I give your rationale a D, and that's being generous.
We signed 4 good to really good DT's. Young, Owens, Smith and McCray are all solid lb's.
We already have 8 current cornerbacks and only 1 is a senior. Don't really have room to load up on them considering our scholly restrictions.
As for wide receiver, we signed Berrios, Langham, Brady, Njoku, and Gray with 6 current wr's to give us 11. 12 if you count Kidd.
As for qb, I and most sane people would take Kaaya over White, Harris and Flowers combined.
As for Kaaya not being Manning, which high school player is?
Advertisement
Yeah, just some simple math refutes Einsteins on the board laughingly offering up -Bs, Cs, Fs. Pretty sure there are 126 FBS programs and consensus ranking has Miami #9. So that puts the Canes in the top 7% of all programs.
If these same characters were graded on their own ridiculous scale by a teacher/professor and received anything short of an A- or A, they'd be raising **** trying to get the teacher/professor fired.
Was anyone reeled in late short of pulling back Wyche? No. Also lost out on some top S Fl talent that went to programs that right now are more appealing. And lost a nice OT prospect to Stanford. So 3-4 additional kids could have made this a spectacular class. But, Negative Nellies aside, Miami still had one of the better recruiting classes in the country.
Marcelo2988
Junior
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2011
- Messages
- 2,194
A-
Could have been great with Valentine, Powell, and/or Cook or Sony
Could have been great with Valentine, Powell, and/or Cook or Sony
Advertisement