- Joined
- Dec 22, 2011
- Messages
- 54,756
Look, I am not making this up, this is literally what happened (and it has happened FOR YEARS with the F$U writers).
Rivals star-rankings CLAIM to be based not solely on some writer's judgement of a player's abilities, but also on how "in-demand" a player is for recruiting. Thus, a 5-star is a guy who would get an offer from nearly every program in the country.
So, this Janvier kid from Miami Christian commits to UF. IMMEDIATELY, the Gaytor writers contact Rivals to point out that the offer list of SEC schools alone should vault the kid to a 4-star ranking. Rivals says, yes, you MUST be correct, we are going to ignore the previous 500-spot drop and go SOLELY off the offer list. It is June. The kid has not been observed doing anything. There have been no games to observe him blocking the crap out of anyone. Nope, just "offer list".
And now you guys realize how circular and manipulable the "offer list" is when it comes to rankings. And how certain star-***** schools like UF and F$U push to have certain of their guys "re-ranked", particularly when they take an "underrated" 3-star.
It's a joke. I don't mind the overall rankings system, or re-ranking guys at certain times of the year BASED ON PERFORMANCE, but this one-by-one "requested re-ranking" crap has to stop.
Rivals saying "oh, we "overlooked" the kid...that's a load of crap.
Rivals star-rankings CLAIM to be based not solely on some writer's judgement of a player's abilities, but also on how "in-demand" a player is for recruiting. Thus, a 5-star is a guy who would get an offer from nearly every program in the country.
So, this Janvier kid from Miami Christian commits to UF. IMMEDIATELY, the Gaytor writers contact Rivals to point out that the offer list of SEC schools alone should vault the kid to a 4-star ranking. Rivals says, yes, you MUST be correct, we are going to ignore the previous 500-spot drop and go SOLELY off the offer list. It is June. The kid has not been observed doing anything. There have been no games to observe him blocking the crap out of anyone. Nope, just "offer list".
And now you guys realize how circular and manipulable the "offer list" is when it comes to rankings. And how certain star-***** schools like UF and F$U push to have certain of their guys "re-ranked", particularly when they take an "underrated" 3-star.
It's a joke. I don't mind the overall rankings system, or re-ranking guys at certain times of the year BASED ON PERFORMANCE, but this one-by-one "requested re-ranking" crap has to stop.
Rivals saying "oh, we "overlooked" the kid...that's a load of crap.
@ Chico’s Bail Bonds....