No. Star ratings mean nothing. He qualified for the Elite 11. Granted, the Elite 11 expanded to 20 this past year, but that means that Emory was one of the 20 best high school QB's in the country last year.
Moreover, we have actual data. The kid started a game against the best defense we've faced this season and performed admirably. Completed 73% of his passes, 1 TD, 1 Int (on a poor route by J. George). He moved the team when needed.
If Cafecito Morono would just play the kid, people would all see what he brings to the table.