MEGA CFP - Plausible scenario in which Miami wins next two games, gets left out of CFP altogether

Sorry.


You're assuming we will stay at 7, TrumpyCane sees us getting up to at least 5, and if we lose ACCC there's no way we are dropped 7 spots to 12 to be left out


How are we getting to #5 when the six teams ahead of us play incredibly easy schedules for the next two weeks?

Georgia plays South Carolina and Georgia Tech. Even if Georgia were to lose to South Carolina, the CFPC already has TWO 2-loss SEC teams ahead of us. Why would Georgia drop?

Utah plays 5-5 TCU and 5-5 WVU. Praying for a miracle here?

Alabama plays Chattanooga and Auburn.

UCLA plays Michigan and USC.

Texas plays 4-6 Arkansas and 4-6 aTm. Even easier than Utah's schedule.

Notre Dame plays SMU and Syracuse.

Get comfortable with Miami being #7. We could score 100 points each against VaTech and BC and still be #7 if teams 2 through 6 do not lose a single (easy) game over the next two weeks.
Trumpycane addressed it in another post, of those 7 games

TCU isn’t as bad as their record indicates, their biggest loss was by 8, played Zona and BYU tough

UCLA has been putrid offensively, that Michigan game will be a 17-14 type game that can go either way

Bama and Texas finish with rivalry games which are always tricky
 
Don't be an a-hole. Not over this. We can fight over something else in the future. I still remember yur name change to NumbNuts, then back, so you can't be too bad of a guy.

I commented elsewhere ont this topic this morning and in more detail. I'll find the post and tag you. You'll see what I'm talking about with regard to the committee. You likely won't agree, but hey, that's Shpoople.
How am I being an *******? You accused me of starting a fight with you when you originally responded to me. What is going on here, brother 😂
 
To me this is really just the rare case where I agree the sec is better than everyone else this year. That’s MY opinion I’m not trying to force it. Prior to this year I would say it’s been the big 10 and the acc was stronger.

Agreed. The SEC is the best league in the country this year. It’s not miles better like pre-NIL, but it’s the best it’s been compared to everyone else in the last 3-4 years.
 
Show me when the committee screwed over a worthy Miami for an SEC team in the CFP.


It's just so dopey and amnesiac for you to act as if the CFPC finally found religion (when BYU lost) after ******** Miami for five straight polls.

And the CFPC was preparing to vault 3-loss Texas and/or 2-loss Vanderbilt over Miami, if they were given any logical opening to do so.



1795021290785.png

1795021359040.png

1795021441094.png

1795021514106.png

1795021609612.png
 
No I didn’t see your dissertation lol.

Read it. Much like my peeniz, it's not that long.

This isn't about defending Miami so much as it's about the blatant corruption, changing justifications and circular "logic" that the committee uses to explain away their inexplicable positions. It's that simple.
You likely won't agree with all of it, but at least you'll see that I'm looking at this through the other end of the telescope than you are.

And lastly, and I mean this, don't take what I'm saying personally. "Don't be an a-hole" was used as an expression, not to call you an a-hole. If you read it the second way, I apologize. Maybe "Lighten up Francis" would've been a better expression. I appreciate your passion in defending the Canes; it's just not where I was coming from.
 
You’re trying to insult me because you can’t prove your assertion. And it’s tiresome.


I've proven that the CFPC favors the SEC over all others multiple times.

Meanwhile, you act as if "you win" by claiming some sort of bizarre courtroom-like "burden of proof" standard.
 
The argument about someone's best win, or "beat X number of ranked teams" is the argument for why one team may be "more deserving" over another, but doesn't necessarily mean that that team is "better' than the other team. There is a difference between "most deserving" and "better", and the committee's job is to select the "best" 11 teams (I say 11 because of the stupid G5 automatic bid), not the 11 "most deserving".

Is UCLA "more deserving" than Miami because they're undefeated? Maybe, but are they better? Who would Vegas have favored in that one? (rhetorical).

Just because your schedule may, at the end of the year, appear to be weaker, doesn't mean you're not the "better" team.

These arguments make no sense when the objective is the "best" teams.
 
How are we getting to #5 when the six teams ahead of us play incredibly easy schedules for the next two weeks?

Georgia plays South Carolina and Georgia Tech. Even if Georgia were to lose to South Carolina, the CFPC already has TWO 2-loss SEC teams ahead of us. Why would Georgia drop?

Utah plays 5-5 TCU and 5-5 WVU. Praying for a miracle here?

Alabama plays Chattanooga and Auburn.

UCLA plays Michigan and USC.

Texas plays 4-6 Arkansas and 4-6 aTm. Even easier than Utah's schedule.

Notre Dame plays SMU and Syracuse.

Get comfortable with Miami being #7. We could score 100 points each against VaTech and BC and still be #7 if teams 2 through 6 do not lose a single (easy) game over the next two weeks.
Last year at this time it felt like every outcome we felt we needed did not hit. It was frustrating watching some of those games.
Just maybe we get a few results this year to benefit our chances.....or just go out and win the **** conference on our own merit. Go Canes!
 
To me this is really just the rare case where I agree the sec is better than everyone else this year. That’s MY opinion I’m not trying to force it. Prior to this year I would say it’s been the big 10 and the acc was stronger.


Bull and ****.

The SEC has gone to 9 conference games, and will likely go to 10 with conference expansion. Most SEC teams play crap OOC schedules.

It is a veritable Human Centipede.

Texas, the "number 5" team in the CFP, lost two home games to a pair of 6-4 teams.

You can't just say "the SEC is better than everyone else this year" and think that "the eye test" is sufficient justification.
 
I’m genuinely asking. I have no allegiance to Texas I’m a UH grad lol this is just my personal stance. For the first time in years I agree with the back end rankings of those particular sec teams. They only thing I don’t like is that Smu and Duke aren’t ranked but that doesn’t really change my stance. Smu and Duke should have been in the 15 to 20 range anyway
Texas should be the 2nd ranked SEC team.
I wouldn't trip where they rank relative to ND or Miami. What makes no sense in these rankings is Alabama. Honestly if you rank Texas, Obama, and UTenn I genuinely don't see how it's possible to have Bama anywhere but 3rd. The only logic to them a being ahead of UTenn is SOS, and that is only the case cause they lose to two top 10 teams, one of which is ******* UTenn... If they literally moved everyone up 1 and put Bama at 9, I think this ranking as a whole would make pretty great sense.

I also agree Duke should be in the 20s somewhere. SMU, nah not right now.
 
Bull and ****.

The SEC has gone to 9 conference games, and will likely go to 10 with conference expansion. Most SEC teams play crap OOC schedules.

It is a veritable Human Centipede.

Texas, the "number 5" team in the CFP, lost two home games to a pair of 6-4 teams.

You can't just say "the SEC is better than everyone else this year" and think that "the eye test" is sufficient justification.
Hence why the Circle of Suck exists. Also explains the SEC hype put out by sports media.
 
i'm not saying they did us a favor.. i'm just saying if they were bias against us they could have kept us out and dealt with the backlash (zero consequence since our ACC commissioner is worthless)...

they also could have dropped Bama to #10 after looking like garbage in the SECCG and moved ND up to #9 and still kept a 1 team gap between us and ND...

Again, I did not say that the CFPC is "biased against Miami" as much as I said that the CFPC "blatantly tips the scale in favor of the SEC".

If you understand that, you will realize why your last sentence is irrelevant. The CFPC was not going to risk devaluing Alabama by even one spot in order to ***** Miami, when they could easily ***** over an equally-non-SEC Notre Dame.

Why hurt Alabama when you can easily shoot Notre Dame in the back of the head?

I said it last year too, both Miami AND Notre Dame deserved to be in the CFP over Alabama.
 
Again, I did not say that the CFPC is "biased against Miami" as much as I said that the CFPC "blatantly tips the scale in favor of the SEC".

If you understand that, you will realize why your last sentence is irrelevant. The CFPC was not going to risk devaluing Alabama by even one spot in order to ***** Miami, when they could easily ***** over an equally-non-SEC Notre Dame.

Why hurt Alabama when you can easily shoot Notre Dame in the back of the head?

I said it last year too, both Miami AND Notre Dame deserved to be in the CFP over Alabama.
i'm not arguing with that.. their priority is maximizing SEC teams in the playoff... they keep stacking the chips in their favor and it hasn't worked out the last 3 years so they think doing it more will help them...

there are people in here that are saying their is bias against miami and you said "let's not pretend they did us a solid"... I'm just saying they didn't do us a favor but they also didn't keep us out intentionally when they could have...

last year, we ended up being treated fairly in the final poll but shouldn't have had so much drama around it.. Bama shouldn't have been in last year
 
Texas should be the 2nd ranked SEC team.
I wouldn't trip where they rank relative to ND or Miami. What makes no sense in these rankings is Alabama. Honestly if you rank Texas, Obama, and UTenn I genuinely don't see how it's possible to have Bama anywhere but 3rd. The only logic to them a being ahead of UTenn is SOS, and that is only the case cause they lose to two top 10 teams, one of which is ******* UTenn... If they literally moved everyone up 1 and put Bama at 9, I think this ranking as a whole would make pretty great sense.

I also agree Duke should be in the 20s somewhere. SMU, nah not right now.


On what planet should Texas be the 2nd ranked SEC team (and presumably the #3 team overall, because the CFPC loves SEC teams)?

Texas lost TWO home games to 6-4 teams. What have they done that is so deserving? What, because in their last 4 games they beat three 6-4 and one 4-6 team? Good lord, SEVEN teams in the SEC have 6-4 records. The whole conference is the definition of "mid".
 
Bull and ****.

The SEC has gone to 9 conference games, and will likely go to 10 with conference expansion. Most SEC teams play crap OOC schedules.

It is a veritable Human Centipede.

Texas, the "number 5" team in the CFP, lost two home games to a pair of 6-4 teams.

You can't just say "the SEC is better than everyone else this year" and think that "the eye test" is sufficient justification.
I’m also not trying to convince you. lol I’ve already given you the my personal opinion caveat. But I mean I 100% think Oklahoma’s defense is good enough to take a 6 win record so far to at least 8 wins in the acc right now
 
Texas should be the 2nd ranked SEC team.
I wouldn't trip where they rank relative to ND or Miami. What makes no sense in these rankings is Alabama. Honestly if you rank Texas, Obama, and UTenn I genuinely don't see how it's possible to have Bama anywhere but 3rd. The only logic to them a being ahead of UTenn is SOS, and that is only the case cause they lose to two top 10 teams, one of which is ******* UTenn... If they literally moved everyone up 1 and put Bama at 9, I think this ranking as a whole would make pretty great sense.

I also agree Duke should be in the 20s somewhere. SMU, nah not right now.
Agreed!! Alabama is the elephant in the room. And when I said SMU should have been I meant like last week. Lol
 
i'm not arguing with that.. their priority is maximizing SEC teams in the playoff... they keep stacking the chips in their favor and it hasn't worked out the last 3 years so they think doing it more will help them...

there are people in here that are saying their is bias against miami and you said "let's not pretend they did us a solid"... I'm just saying they didn't do us a favor but they also didn't keep us out intentionally when they could have...

last year, we ended up being treated fairly in the final poll but shouldn't have had so much drama around it.. Bama shouldn't have been in last year


I said "let's not pretend they did us a solid" IN RESPONSE TO someone saying that the CFPC put a "deserving" Miami into the CFP last year (after ******* us over for the first 5 weeks).

If history has proven nothing else, at least we can acknowledge that the CFPC drops Miami farther than just about any other team AFTER LOSSES, and barely moves Miami up AFTER WINS (unless another team loses).

As for "keeping Miami out intentionally", I already made it clear that the CFPC chose to **** over Notre Dame instead of imperiling Alabama by dropping Alabama even one spot. I'm not sure why people can't comprehend that.
 
Back
Top