Coach Macho
aka Beardy Ryan
- Joined
- Oct 11, 2012
- Messages
- 13,434
You know more than me, but I would think they're pretty accurate. They have a database going back to 2004 and there's rarely any games missing for any player.
I totally agree they may include some bias, but it's not like if a RB runs goes 10 for 50 yds 1 TD it's getting reported as 10 for 100 yds 2 TD's. But they may be adding on a couple yards here and there.
The main thing for me is in the 9 or 10 games they had stats for, Cam is doing considerably worse than everyone else in the same backfield. Cam's at a 3.5 ypc when the other RB's are around a 6.0 ypc.
If the person reporting it is inflating stats for all players, then maybe Cam is actually averaging 2.5 and everyone else 5.0. The other players are still doing twice as good - and that's the red flag.
I don't see a realistic scenario where everyone is actually averaging 5.0 ypc, but the person reporting the stats is inflating Volaskis Watkins to 6.8 and deflating Cam to 3.5
I'm not saying that anybody's stats are being inflated, I'm just pointing out the fact that they're inaccurate.
Some years back we played a stud RB and held him to 24 yards on 16 carries. I opened the paper the next day and he had 122 yards... courtesy of his offensive coordinator who called in the stats to The Herald.
I'm telling you as fact that the Herald's stats are unreliable. They seldom have staff members at the games taking stats. And the only other way they obtain them are if the coaches call them in the night of the game. (and most don't)