A note on Portal QBs

First nationally in passing touchdowns, second nationally in passer rating, projected Top 5 pick.
In a year with really weak quarterback production. Compare Mendoza’s numbers to any of the other Heisman finalists quarterbacks in recent years and they’re pedestrian. Not because he hasn’t played well. He’s been fantastic but because Indiana doesn’t ask him to throw a lot. What Quarterback in the modern era has won the Heisman while averaging under 230 yards passing per game?
 
Advertisement
What Quarterback in the modern era has won the Heisman while averaging under 230 yards passing per game?
The big story is that possessions are down, which impacts stats at every position. This is a byproduct of, among other things, rule changes to shorten games.

The top team in plays per game this year (FAU) would’ve been 10th in 2020 and 20th in 2015.
 
We probably WIN the Louisville game with Mendoza at QB.

Counterpoint: we probably LOSE the ND game. Beck took chances that Mendoza wouldn’t have.

We lose the SMU game with both of them. Beck was not the reason we lost. He actually played very well, outside of the final interception. Game should have never went to OT.

I think we end up at 10-2 with either guy.

Maybe we’ll see him in the playoffs. In the mean time, can we get back to focusing on A&M?
 
I hope it isnt Miami vs Indiana in the national championship game. Some of you will have to make a decision on who to root for
This is exactly the matchup I want. We have to take care of business this week and then beat OSU (which I think we can, but haven't done a breakdown) so all this IU talkl take's a hit. Mendoza and IU have been great. I am waiting to see how losing their best DL, DE Daley celebrating after OSU is a hurt's them. Daley replaced Wyatt who was lost for the season about mid season. Daley is 2nd in tackles for loss in the country. No way the SO behind him isn't a big drop off. IU doesn't have that depth behind their 2 deep. The backup at RT that replaced Benson was destroyed all game by Curry at OSU. Destroyed! I don't believe their depth can hold up for 3 straight playoff /games. I liked IU in the bracket at 1st, but it is going to be tough for them. Then they are losing everyone after the season. We shall see if Cig can continue this miracle portal transformation one more time.
 
Advertisement
In the last three years, all eight Heisman finalist QBs came from the Portal.

Mendoza, Daniels, Pavia, Ward, Nix, Penix, Sayin, Gabriel.

we need to get a multi year player at QB from the portal imo.

daniels pavia nix sayin and penix had multiple years with their new team. that would help push emory out and give Nickel time to develop behind the scenes so he can take over
 
This is exactly the matchup I want. We have to take care of business this week and then beat OSU (which I think we can, but haven't done a breakdown) so all this IU talkl take's a hit. Mendoza and IU have been great. I am waiting to see how losing their best DL, DE Daley celebrating after OSU is a hurt's them. Daley replaced Wyatt who was lost for the season about mid season. Daley is 2nd in tackles for loss in the country. No way the SO behind him isn't a big drop off. IU doesn't have that depth behind their 2 deep. The backup at RT that replaced Benson was destroyed all game by Curry at OSU. Destroyed! I don't believe their depth can hold up for 3 straight playoff /games. I liked IU in the bracket at 1st, but it is going to be tough for them. Then they are losing everyone after the season. We shall see if Cig can continue this miracle portal transformation one more time.
I dont see IU going all the way. I think they get upset in the semis
 
I never heard that . We sure thats true not all home grown kids wanna stay or come back home .
most kids want to get away from where they grew up. explore new things/new environments not live 10 min from where they grew up.
 
Napoleon Dynamite Rock Throw GIF by 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment
 
I can’t say either way if he wanted to come here. Some others have said he did. Ok that’s fine. However the game manager comment I’ll stand by.
I think hes more game manager than stud but he had a great year.

from what I have heard, we didnt have a shot in ****. he was IU bound immediately when he entered. good choice imo by him. beck has more talent, but Cignetti is a better coach than dawson
 
Checks Miami record of high school QBs for last 20 years.. Posted elsewhere but fits here..

Oh no We miss out on Judd the Studd, Emory The Gaww, future HOF Jack Allison, TVD, Mr. **** yo ***** Nkosi Perry. Where will we be with out Peyton Matocha, Jarren Williams, Malik Rosier, Kaaya, Evan Sherieeff, Japicky and stephen Morris, etc..

What QB are you afraid of missing out on in last 20 years?! That have left an actual mark in cfb lore? Kirby Freeman? Like ask yourself, what the **** are we even talking about right now, really go down the list..

Confused For Real GIF by ALLBLK
morris kaaya and rosier to a lesser extent have been our best QBs here pre cam ward.
 
Advertisement
In a year with really weak quarterback production. Compare Mendoza’s numbers to any of the other Heisman finalists quarterbacks in recent years and they’re pedestrian. Not because he hasn’t played well. He’s been fantastic but because Indiana doesn’t ask him to throw a lot. What Quarterback in the modern era has won the Heisman while averaging under 230 yards passing per game?
This is a really fair take. I don’t get the “we should’ve taken Mendoza” crowd. If you swapped Beck and Mendoza in some alternate reality then replayed the season, would the results really be all that different?
 
We probably WIN the Louisville game with Mendoza at QB.

Counterpoint: we probably LOSE the ND game. Beck took chances that Mendoza wouldn’t have.

We lose the SMU game with both of them. Beck was not the reason we lost. He actually played very well, outside of the final interception. Game should have never went to OT.

I think we end up at 10-2 with either guy.

Maybe we’ll see him in the playoffs. In the mean time, can we get back to focusing on A&M?
Exactly how I feel about this. Net difference is nil.
 
Back
Top