UknowWhat said:

252cane said:

UknowWhat said:

Redshirt is a detriment to recruiting. If you Redshirt in 2017 u discourage potential recruits in 2018... Medical RS is different...

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Not necessarily true. Fsu redshirted 2 high ranked D-lineman last year in cedric wood and janarius robinson. They turned around and got 2 5 star players at the same position this past class in kaindoh and wilson.

Ohio st. got one of the best d-lines in the country and they are deep. Their entire starting d-line was all redshirted and they have more guys who will redshirt this year likely and still is on track to sign maybe the best d-line class this cycle.

Click to expand...

I'll take that... valid points ... Considering a RedShirt was Taboo for Shaq... He wanted to be on the field

Click to expand...

jw410 said:

He is in too late... shirt him and sign two jucos..

Click to expand...

mikemike said:

jw410 said:

He is in too late... shirt him and sign two jucos..

Click to expand...

it aint to late man...

the season starts week 3, he got a month to get right

Click to expand...

the23Watcher said:

[MENTION=3894]Peter Ariz[/MENTION] did this happen?

Click to expand...

AllAboutDaU said:

mikemike said:

jw410 said:

He is in too late... shirt him and sign two jucos..

Click to expand...

it aint to late man...

the season starts week 3, he got a month to get right

Click to expand...

There is really no point of redshirting these days. The good players will leave before their senior season anyways. The rest will either transfer out or they're very average players that can easily be replaced.

Click to expand...

AllAboutDaU said:

mikemike said:

jw410 said:

He is in too late... shirt him and sign two jucos..

Click to expand...

it aint to late man...

the season starts week 3, he got a month to get right

Click to expand...

There is really no point of redshirting these days. The good players will leave before their senior season anyways. The rest will either transfer out or they're very average players that can easily be replaced.

Click to expand...

rokulika said:

AllAboutDaU said:

mikemike said:

jw410 said:

He is in too late... shirt him and sign two jucos..

Click to expand...

it aint to late man...

the season starts week 3, he got a month to get right

Click to expand...

There is really no point of redshirting these days. The good players will leave before their senior season anyways. The rest will either transfer out or they're very average players that can easily be replaced.

Click to expand...

I'm generally against redshirting if a player will contribute on offense/defense, but several good payers have stayed for 4 seasons.

Allen Hurns, Sean Spence, Leonard Hankerson, Allen Bailey, Stacy Coley, Sam Shields, Colin McCarthy, Denzel Perryman to name a few

Click to expand...

RyanCane26 said:

rokulika said:

AllAboutDaU said:

mikemike said:

jw410 said:

He is in too late... shirt him and sign two jucos..

Click to expand...

it aint to late man...

the season starts week 3, he got a month to get right

Click to expand...

There is really no point of redshirting these days. The good players will leave before their senior season anyways. The rest will either transfer out or they're very average players that can easily be replaced.

Click to expand...

I'm generally against redshirting if a player will contribute on offense/defense, but several good payers have stayed for 4 seasons.

Allen Hurns, Sean Spence, Leonard Hankerson, Allen Bailey, Stacy Coley, Sam Shields, Colin McCarthy, Denzel Perryman to name a few

Click to expand...

Colin was the only one who stayed five seasons though and that was because of medical redshirt. I'd like to see how many fifth yr seniors have made impacts over the years.

Click to expand...

rokulika said:

RyanCane26 said:

rokulika said:

AllAboutDaU said:

mikemike said:

it aint to late man...

the season starts week 3, he got a month to get right

Click to expand...

There is really no point of redshirting these days. The good players will leave before their senior season anyways. The rest will either transfer out or they're very average players that can easily be replaced.

Click to expand...

I'm generally against redshirting if a player will contribute on offense/defense, but several good payers have stayed for 4 seasons.

Allen Hurns, Sean Spence, Leonard Hankerson, Allen Bailey, Stacy Coley, Sam Shields, Colin McCarthy, Denzel Perryman to name a few

Click to expand...

Colin was the only one who stayed five seasons though and that was because of medical redshirt. I'd like to see how many fifth yr seniors have made impacts over the years.

Click to expand...

This was in response to "if he's any good he'll be gone in three years anyway." It doesn't always apply.

Click to expand...

rokulika said:

Realistic redshirt candidates:

Weldon
Burns
Njoku
Polendey
Dykstra
Hillery
Ford
Steed

who disagrees?

Click to expand...

Peter Ariz said:

View attachment 48453


The final member of Miami's 2017 signing class is set to officially arrive on campus this weekend.

Defensive tackle Jon Ford, a local product from Dillard High School and Miami's lone signeee at the position, told CanesinSight that he's been given clearance to enroll this Sunday.

Miami remained optimistic over the last month that Ford would qualify. Yesterday, defensive coordinator Manny Diaz equated Ford to "a present under the tree that you forget about."

Ford would be able to practice beginning Monday, but is not allowed to wear pads until his 5th day of practice due to NCAA rules.

Click to expand...

AllAboutDaU said:

rokulika said:

RyanCane26 said:

rokulika said:

AllAboutDaU said:

There is really no point of redshirting these days. The good players will leave before their senior season anyways. The rest will either transfer out or they're very average players that can easily be replaced.

Click to expand...

I'm generally against redshirting if a player will contribute on offense/defense, but several good payers have stayed for 4 seasons.

Allen Hurns, Sean Spence, Leonard Hankerson, Allen Bailey, Stacy Coley, Sam Shields, Colin McCarthy, Denzel Perryman to name a few

Click to expand...

Colin was the only one who stayed five seasons though and that was because of medical redshirt. I'd like to see how many fifth yr seniors have made impacts over the years.

Click to expand...

This was in response to "if he's any good he'll be gone in three years anyway." It doesn't always apply.

Click to expand...

Of course there's exceptions. But I'm talking generally about uselessness of red shirting. You red shirt essentially to hope to get 5 years out of the player. But for the most part if the player is good they will leave their RS soph or RS Jr year. They won't stay till they are a RS senior barring injury. Take Herndon for example, he's a RS Jr but most likely he's gonna leave after this year. So that red shirt he took really didn't matter. Instead of leaving as a senior he's gonna leave as a RS JR.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

LuCane said:

rokulika said:

Realistic redshirt candidates:

Weldon
Burns
Njoku
Polendey
Dykstra
Hillery
Ford
Steed

who disagrees?

Click to expand...

Polendey may not be able to redshirt.

Click to expand...