Who are the must keep players?

[Gables Canes]

Here’s who I’d want back, position by position (in order of importance within each position):

QB
TVD
Brown

RB
Parrish
Citizen

WR
Young
Restrepo
B Smith
Horton

TE
Arroyo
Skinner
Brantley

OL
Cooper
Rivers
Zion
Mccoy
Denis

DL
Mesidor
LT
Jackson
Kelly
Moss
JHH
Moten

LB
Wes B
Chase smith
Flagg

DB
The freshmen class (Harris, graves, Rodgers). That’s it

Safety
Kitchens
Markeith williams

I included the freshmen, it’s too early to write any of them off. Other than them, I counted about 20 others.

 

[407cane]

a lot of those are must keep due to depth issues but assuming that they will / can be replaced in the portal I imagine the list of "must keep" to be significantly smaller

 

[Allabouttheu95]

I’m adding J George to this list because he is the only receiver on roster that looked like a p5 receiver with the ball in his hands

Also J Borregalas

 

[MyKidIsLoggedIn2MyAccount]

Here’s who I’d want back, position by position (in order of importance within each position):

QB
TVD
Brown

RB
Parrish
Citizen

WR
Young
Restrepo
B Smith
Horton

TE
Arroyo
Skinner
Brantley

OL
Cooper
Rivers
Zion
Mccoy
Denis

DL
Mesidor
LT
Jackson
Kelly
Moss
JHH
Moten

LB
Wes B
Chase smith
Flagg

DB
The freshmen class (Harris, graves, Rodgers). That’s it

Safety
Kitchens
Markeith williams

I included the freshmen, it’s too early to write any of them off. Other than them, I counted about 20 others.

My list in last night's thread was super close to yours.

-I had Garcia instead of Brown (but Brown is considered elsewhere.) I think we still have a lot to see from Garcia in a real scheme, etc. He makes a lot of mistakes but he can sling it and produce as well. I don't care if he was in garbage time yesterday, he played like he gave a crap.
-Had Knighton despite yet another fumble. You're right about poor Chaney. I feel sorry for him as he's made of glass.
-Had George on mine.

-OL had Mclaughlin instead of Denis
-I should have had JHH on my DL

-LBs I didn't have Flagg

-Secondary I had Balom, Couch. and excluded Rogers

Rest I had only good portal guys and just play with a shortened roster and taper up each year with quality guys. No more fluff. Quality only.

 

[Home Slice]

I'm asking myself what COACHES do we want back?

 

[futurecane]

Brown? Swap for Garcia.

Unless you want him as a TE or something.

 

[Maskoff407]

I'm asking myself what COACHES do we want back?

Gattis gotta go. Bring in Joe Brady for all I care because you can let him be OC/ QB coach giving the chance to get rid of Ponce. Steele is alright but if you wanna get rid of him and promote Strong or Taylor to DC I’m alright with that.

 

[Gables Canes]

I’m adding J George to this list because he is the only receiver on roster that looked like a p5 receiver with the ball in his hands

Also J Borregalas

I didn’t include him because of the off the field issues. If he can get that cleaned up, I agree he has potential.

 

[Gables Canes]

My list in last night's thread was super close to yours.

-I had Garcia instead of Brown (but Brown is considered elsewhere.) I think we still have a lot to see from Garcia in a real scheme, etc. He makes a lot of mistakes but he can sling it and produce as well. I don't care if he was in garbage time yesterday, he played like he gave a crap.
-Had Knighton despite yet another fumble. You're right about poor Chaney. I feel sorry for him as he's made of glass.
-Had George on mine.

-OL had Mclaughlin instead of Denis
-I should have had JHH on my DL

-LBs I didn't have Flagg

-Secondary I had Balom, Couch. and excluded Rogers

Rest I had only good portal guys and just play with a shortened roster and taper up each year with quality guys. No more fluff. Quality only.

I wouldn’t mind Garcia coming back either. At least he’s shown he gives a ****.

Haven’t seen enough of McLaughlin, I did notice how skinny he looks last night

I included Flagg because he has improved and he always gives effort. He should be a depth piece, not a starter

Balom is always hurt, that’s why I didn’t include him. I’ve personally seen enough from Couch and I’m ready to move on

 

[Camerooski]

Flagg?

 

[3FW]

We have huge holes on this team. We have to pull RBs, DBs, OL, LBs, WRs from the Portal. Mario gets a C+ on the portal his first year. He needs an A in his second. The only group I don’t think is a priority in the portal is the DL. Be very picky there and only pull high quality, high character kids.

 

[Angry Ibis]

Gattis gotta go. Bring in Joe Brady for all I care because you can let him be OC/ QB coach giving the chance to get rid of Ponce. Steele is alright but if you wanna get rid of him and promote Strong or Taylor to DC I’m alright with that.

Marcia Brady would have been better than Gattis… yikes Mario…

 

[nycane]

Flagg?

he needs to go.

 

[Ispyin]

Here’s who I’d want back, position by position (in order of importance within each position):

QB
TVD
Brown

RB
Parrish
Citizen

WR
Young
Restrepo
B Smith
Horton

TE
Arroyo
Skinner
Brantley

OL
Cooper
Rivers
Zion
Mccoy
Denis

DL
Mesidor
LT
Jackson
Kelly
Moss
JHH
Moten

LB
Wes B
Chase smith
Flagg

DB
The freshmen class (Harris, graves, Rodgers). That’s it

Safety
Kitchens
Markeith williams

I included the freshmen, it’s too early to write any of them off. Other than them, I counted about 20 others.

Cam. That’s it.

 

[Tru C]

More important is who is coming in

 

[The canesman]

Kinchens

 

[grover]

QB: TVD
RB: Parrish
WR: Young, Restrepo, B Smith
TE: Arroyo, Skinner, Brantley
OL: Rivers, Zion, Clark
DL: Mesidor, LT, Jackson, JHH
LB: [no one]
CB: [no one]
S: Kinchens, J Williams

Removing the Freshmen, I count 17 "must keeps". There are multiple "should keeps" though, including JW, Chase Smith, Chaney, Denis, Couch, Garcia, George, Brinson, Balom, Seymore, Campbell (if he's healthy and wants to return), McLaughlin, Miller (if he wants to return), Ishmael, Chantz, Flagg (for character and leadership, not athleticism)

That would be 33 upperclassmen + the 14 true Freshmen = 47 returners. But I guarantee we lose at least 5-8 of that list, mostly from the "should keep" group, so assume 40 actually come back. Plus the kicker and punter. Which leaves 43 incoming freshmen and portelers, or a slight majority of the total scholarship roster.

 

[fraggle]

Keep as many as possible, question is what coaches to keep?

 

[rgonzalez9824]

Brown? Swap for Garcia.

Unless you want him as a TE or something.

Hope Garcia comes back. He has been put in every position to fail and the kid doesn’t give up when the opportunity is given to him.

 

[kanecrazed]

Here’s who I’d want back, position by position (in order of importance within each position):

QB
TVD
Brown

RB
Parrish
Citizen

WR
Young
Restrepo
B Smith
Horton

TE
Arroyo
Skinner
Brantley

OL
Cooper
Rivers
Zion
Mccoy
Denis

DL
Mesidor
LT
Jackson
Kelly
Moss
JHH
Moten

LB
Wes B
Chase smith
Flagg

DB
The freshmen class (Harris, graves, Rodgers). That’s it

Safety
Kitchens
Markeith williams

I included the freshmen, it’s too early to write any of them off. Other than them, I counted about 20 others.

How many of these guys even want to come back? Some might look for greener pastures.